Tweet

100 Days of Sodom

Written by: Gavin Chait

Article Overview: Public Works Minister Thoka Didiza is considering importing an Indian employment model that will guarantee every household the right to 100 days of paid work per year. Didiza, as a representative of the state, is promising people the right to a job based on the premise that not having a job is sufficient reason to get one.

100 Days of Sodom

Public Works Minister Thoka Didiza is considering importing an Indian employment model that will guarantee every household the right to 100 days of paid work per year. Didiza, as a representative of the state, is promising people the right to a job based on the premise that not having a job is sufficient reason to get one.

There are 33,000 vacancies in state hospitals. Government administrators have thousands more unfilled positions. And this is just in the public sector.

Clearly there is no shortage of opportunities to work and, just as clearly, the massed unemployed must be unsuitable for the work available.

Take a deep breath and read that again.

Talk to any employer in the country. They are not refusing to hire people. They are desperate to hire people. But not just any people, skilled people.

The state has allocated R 18 billion for the task which, at an average of R 2 225 per person per month (their recommendation), would employ a total of 1.6 million people per year. That would make quite a difference to the 7 million unemployed. However, consider the implications for those who benefit from the scheme.

A company contracted to refurbish a road will, of necessity, hire people. Those jobs will be filled. Under this scheme they would have to make way for those who are participating in the scheme.

Every four to five months (depending on the nature of those 100 paid days) the entire workforce will be replaced. Instead of a permanent job will come a short-term contract. The new staff will require training, safety equipment and the like. The overall cost of the project will go up as will the time taken for completion.

And it isn't much of a step up for the beneficiaries since the nature of the work won't present them with much opportunity to build a curriculum vitae.

The problem with a right to work is the same as that of a right to housing: people will fight amongst each other for who gets seniority on the list, jobs of dubious value will be created and the state entrenches the idea of short-term contractual work as a solution to unemployment.

And – you may consider this unusual coming from me – there is the potential for terrible worker exploitation.

Where does worker job security go (especially for those in the semi-skilled sectors) when everyone is entitled to 100 days of paid work? How will the state adjudicate unfair dismissal when unscrupulous companies declare that they're obeying the spirit of "100 days" when they dismiss their workforce and replace them?

There is, absolutely and without debate, a critical unemployment problem. But the solution is not in creating meaningless jobs for the unskilled. It lies in appropriately skilling the unemployed so that they can take advantage of the jobs that are available.

The billions of rands lying unspent in the SETA bank accounts are testament to the lack of training taking place.

We need nurses, we need artisans, we need builders. We need people who can fulfil a function and achieve a required outcome. We do not need people employed simply to keep them busy.

Why choose India as a role-model for job creation? Reported unemployment is not an indicator of success. India's is 7.8% and 25% of the population earns less than US$ 1 per day. Nigeria's is 5.8% but 60% of the population are below the poverty line. China's unemployment is 4.2% and only 10% of the population is below the poverty line.

Why not choose the low-waged industrial Chinese model and invite the world to invest?

Creating unnecessary jobs at the expense of the small pool of taxpayers seems an unlikely way to create long-term sustainable development.

Related Articles
  Does Lack of Confidence Impact Your Productivity?
  Give Your Goal 4 Days
  Sometimes Unintended Consequences Are A Good Thing
  Time to Wake Up, Notice the Awakening
  How to Accomplish Your Goals As Soon As Possible By Using This Powerful Method

Article Tags: 6 million, beneficiaries, curriculum vitae, deep breath, dubious value, employment model, five months, government administrators, household, indian employment, job, premise, public sector, safety equipment, seniority, state hospitals, term contract, unfilled positions, vacancies, workforce



Related Forum Posts
enRoute ads - 10 days with my new salesmen - Hi Guys, As some of you may know I hired a sales person for my business. I picked him amongst 50+ interviews, so I did do my due diligence. For any of you who have had experience with outbound sales reps in your company could you please shed some light on these statistics and let me know what you think: Days Employed: 11 Calls Made: 200 Average length of call: 3 minutes Sales: 0 Closing Rate: 0 Previous closing rate at Astral Media: 5% He is selling billboards instead of radio, for an unestablished company vs. an established one There seems to be large gaps in calling made in his daily log, on average he is making 20 calls a day. I am going to try to increase this by providing him with calling lists versus him creating his own. (I will keep you posted on this). I am just wondering, in your experience, what kind of regiment do you have your cold callers work on, 6 hours? 4 hours? 7 hours? And did you notice a curve occur with closing rates as time progressed and experience increased? If so when did you notice this begin to occur, I have him on a 1,500.00 NON-RECOVERABLE sales draw salary which ends in 6 weeks (approx).


Share this article with your friends. Fund someone's dream.

Leave a comment below or share on the left and you'll help support entrepreneurs in Africa through our partnership with Kiva. Over $50,000 raised and counting - Please keep sharing! Learn more.

Tweet

Newsletter

Get advice & tips from famous business
owners, new articles by entrepreneur
experts, my latest website updates, &
special sneak peaks at what's to come!

Name:
Email:

Popular Articles

Reverse Mentoring

Making the Most of Your Trade Show Experience

How To Be Happy at Work? Acknowledge Yourself

Suggestions

Email us your ideas on how to make our
website more valuable! Thank you Sharon
from Toronto Salsa Lessons / Classes for
your suggestions to make the newsletter
look like the website and profile younger
entrepreneurs like Jennifer Lopez.