Tweet

Killing the Golden Goose, a lesson in Economic Freedom

Written by: Gavin Chait

Article Overview: Aesop's Fables tell of a Golden Goose that, each day, would lay a single golden egg. The farmer who owned the goose was ecstatic but it wasn't long before his wonder gave way to greed.

Killing the Golden Goose, a lesson in Economic Freedom

Aesop's Fables tell of a Golden Goose that, each day, would lay a single golden egg. The farmer who owned the goose was ecstatic but it wasn't long before his wonder gave way to greed.

Why should he be forced to wait an entire day for one golden egg? He and his wife kill the goose and cut it open to get at all the gold in one go. They discover that, dead, it's just an ordinary goose.

The fable is a warning to those who take unearned wealth that is not freely given. It is a lesson few governments in Africa have cared to learn.

Last week saw Robert Mugabe's thuggish regime claim ownership of Olivine, a large cooking-oil producer. Many governments believe that businesses – the gold – can be separated from those that produce it. Mugabe assumes that his nation is poor because business owners and investors refuse to share the wealth of their companies with the "people".

Last week the Free Market Foundation released the Economic Freedom of the World report for 2007. "There is a strong correlation between economic freedom and wealth," says Neil Emerick, of the Foundation.

It should come as no surprise that Zimbabwe is considered the least economically free nation on Earth.

Economic freedom is distinct from democracy. Singapore ranks second in terms of economic freedom but is politically autocratic. Democracies place the needs of the majority over the actions of the individual and this can create winners and losers. The majority could, for instance, vote to ban hunting and so disadvantage the few who enjoy it. Free market trades, by comparison, are win-win transactions since people only trade with each other for mutual advantage.

Since democracies prize collective bargaining over win-win transactions the inevitable result is lobbying where special interest groups campaign to have their own needs prioritised. This can lead to unexpected outcomes and inefficient economies.

In South Africa the minister of telecommunications gets to decide whether or not there is a market need for a new telephone service and lobbyists from existing businesses spend a great deal of money convincing her that this isn't necessary. The result is that consumers lose. Without free competition prices are fixed artificially higher than they would otherwise be.

One argument against free markets is that it leads to inequality between the rich and poor. Research indicates that the level of inequality is marginally higher in countries that are the least economically liberal.

A more significant observation is that the richest people in the world's least liberal economies are poorer than the poorest people in the most liberal economies.

How does South Africa stand in the ratings? Over the past five years our overall score has remained virtually unchanged but our ranking has dropped from 44th to 60th as other countries make efforts to improve their economies. We're not even the best in Africa. That's Mauritius, which has made dramatic efforts to liberalise and improve their investment environment. They are the 22nd most economically liberal economy in the world.

South Africa falls down in terms of the level of government ownership of the economy, tax levels, and the low level at which the top marginal tax rate kicks in. Our inflation rate, especially in terms of increasing money supply, our taxes on international trade and the inflexibility of our labour legislation are also all areas of concern.

Why does a ranking like this matter? It depends on your views of wealth creation. If you believe that people can vote themselves rich and that governments can legislate wealth creation then our level of economic freedom may not concern you.

On the other hand, investors looking for easy places to do business have 59 countries higher up the ladder to invest in before they get to us.

Related Articles
  The Gooose That Laid The Golden Eggs
  An Organic Leader Used Power Versus Force
  Best Internet Network Marketing Training System the Secret in Tough Times
  Lessons in Teamwork from Wild Geese
  You Don't Need An Expert

Article Tags: aesop, aesop s fables, collective bargaining, cooking oil, correlation, democracies, economic freedom of the world, emerick, fable, free nation, golden egg, golden goose, greed, inevitable result, mutual advantage, oil producer, robert mugabe, special interest groups, unexpected outcomes, winners and losers



Related Forum Posts
Re: Why Did You Become An Entrepreneur? - You mean Freedom = Responsibility. Freedom and responsibility are two sides of same coin. But I like the word choice. Robert
Pies & Vodka - It's a good point but I think it comes down to the experience of buying the pie. I think that if you had a story behind your pie business you'd be just as successful. People want to be part of something bigger when they are purchasing a product or service. An affiliation that makes them feel content. Wonder if the story makes the pie taste better... kinda how some people think more expensive wine tastes better than regular priced wine. 20/20 did a story last year on Vodka and did blind tests after they got peoples reactions to brands. Grey Goose came out on top of peoples lists but after they did the blind test the attendees couldn't tell the difference between Absolute (which was the bottom of the list) vs. Grey Goose.
Re: What is Your Favorite Thing About Owning A Business? - 1.Freedom 2.Freedom 3.Freedom
Re: FILL IN THE BLANK: The thing I love MOST about being an entr - Freedom!
Re: FILL IN THE BLANK: The thing I love MOST about being an entr - Freedom to work the hours I want and make my own choices and decisions. MichelleJ


Share this article with your friends. Fund someone's dream.

Leave a comment below or share on the left and you'll help support entrepreneurs in Africa through our partnership with Kiva. Over $50,000 raised and counting - Please keep sharing! Learn more.

Tweet

Newsletter

Get advice & tips from famous business
owners, new articles by entrepreneur
experts, my latest website updates, &
special sneak peaks at what's to come!

Name:
Email:

Popular Articles

Using Social Media Marketing

9 tips to increase ROI in PPC Campaigns

How Many Buckets Do You Need for Retirement?

Suggestions

Email us your ideas on how to make our
website more valuable! Thank you Sharon
from Toronto Salsa Lessons / Classes for
your suggestions to make the newsletter
look like the website and profile younger
entrepreneurs like Jennifer Lopez.