Tweet

Slaves to land, the policies of Land Affairs

Written by: Gavin Chait

Article Overview: The land that peasant farmers, or shack-dwellers, live on is frequently either public land, or land that vests in a tribal chief. The residents act to improve that land in some form, either by farming it or building a home on it. Neither the improvement or the land are theirs to trade.

Slaves to land, the policies of Land Affairs

The land that peasant farmers, or shack-dwellers, live on is frequently either public land, or land that vests in a tribal chief. The residents act to improve that land in some form, either by farming it or building a home on it. Neither the improvement or the land are theirs to trade.

Hernando de Soto, the Peruvian economist, declared that land ownership amongst the currently impoverished has the capacity to unlock trillions of dollars of "hidden capital". De Soto has visited South Africa on several occasions to present his ideas to government officials.

It appears that they have either not listened, or have concluded that they know better.

Speaking in Wallmansthal last week at a land hand-over ceremony, Agriculture and Land Affairs Minister Lulu Xingwana stated that, "Upon the date of transfer, the property shall not be encumbered, sold or otherwise disposed of without written consent from the minister."

Land, in and of itself, is simply a tool. It is not a magic tree that produces gold coins just by owning it. Only when you use it and develop it can it support you. Without full and transferable title you cannot offer your land as collateral to raise capital to improve your land.

By denying unencumbered title the state has achieved a contradiction: the land is yours, but you cannot use it. You are a slave to your property, not the other way round. In other words, the government just became the feudal overlord of a whole bunch of peasant farmers who are now indefinitely tied to their land.

Land does not confer wealth creation. House prices have risen steadily over the past decade but not as a consequence of simply being houses.

Companies, after the incredible interest rate hikes of the 1990s that saw lending rates reaching 25.5%, took advantage of lower borrowing costs to redevelop themselves. This spending helped other companies' profits, increased consumption as salaries rose and created a more confident and wealthier middle-class.

This middle-class bought houses. They borrowed more money against the value of their houses and improved them, raising property prices further and triggering a boom.

The long bull run of the past decade started with the ability to raise capital against the value of an asset and then invest that cash in the improvement of that asset. A factory owner who is unable to put his factory up as collateral when applying for a loan will not get a loan. All he can do is run it as it is until it no longer works.

Giving land to the landless does not make them wealthy unless they also have the right to sell that land. Neither does landlessness automatically make one poor. Many of the most highly-skilled South Africans are landless. They rent their apartments and earn their living by trading their knowledge and skills.

Land, like any tool, can be used to create wealth. Like any tool you must have both the desire and ability to use it.

The state desires to convert South Africa's landless poor into land-owning subsistence farmers. What happens if the people concerned want no such thing? What happens if what they really want is the rather more general (and more vague) "opportunity to earn a living"?

Then, at the first opportunity to do so, they will sell their newly-received land, and use the capital to do something else. By selling the land they allow another farmer to combine different plots to create a larger and more productive farm, and the seller can take their profits and use it to improve their own lives in some other way.

Xingwana is behaving like a smothering parent. She demands not just that the recipients of government benevolence appreciate their gift, but that they remain tied to that gift for all time. She wishes to make slaves of the poor.

Related Articles
  SME's - an African challenge
  What To Do When Your Job Search Isn’t Working
  SMEs - why governments contribute to SME failure in Africa
  We Become What We Think About
  Your House Insurance Coverage is Wrong

Article Tags: affairs minister, building a home, contradiction, economist, feudal overlord, gold coins, government officials, hernando de soto, house prices, interest rate hikes, land affairs, lulu, magic tree, middle class, peasant farmers, shack dwellers, tribal chief, trillions, vests, wealth creation



Related Forum Posts
Re: Question for the Masses - Okay, millions, first I would like to tell the members of the forum I come from(Kenya) and US$ 1million is equivalent to Kshs 80Million. This money can buy 2 houses each 6 bedrooms in one acre of land in the poshest areas in Nairobi (The capital city). This would make me the neighbor to the current and the retired presidents, the head of European union, the richest people in that country just to mention. If I don't buy those houses, I would but over 10,000 hectares of land in the fertile areas and become a coffee farmer, selling my coffee to Starbucks and the like, making me even more richer. If I don't want to become a coffee farmer, then I would convert the land to one of the biggest golf course that even Tiger Woods would pay to play. I don't know well what I would do with many more millions of dollars, but with only one million dollars, then I would invite all the members of this forum to come play Golf in my huge golf course.
Re: Patent Walk-Through - there are also some policies given by designers allowing companies to own designs as logos. For me it’d be really important especially when a company own one and wants to modify it. Of course it’ll need the right colors and software modifying it but keeping it right
Re: Should I Get A Patent? - In what stage is your patent? I'm a strong believer in property policies, you should consult an insurance company that deals with those kind of properties. But never ever release the product or advertise it before listing it!!
Re: Modeling the Masters Video #3 - Hewlett-Packard - I found the link by accident, but I found it most helpful. I didn't know that HP is where Flex-Time and open-door policies started. It's short and highly informative. good job.
Greetings, from Plunder Ventures - Hi, My name's Tristan. A partner and I are launching a web business and decided to join the forum to get the lay of the land (legally speaking), and to avoid getting swindled!


Share this article with your friends. Fund someone's dream.

Leave a comment below or share on the left and you'll help support entrepreneurs in Africa through our partnership with Kiva. Over $50,000 raised and counting - Please keep sharing! Learn more.

Tweet

Newsletter

Get advice & tips from famous business
owners, new articles by entrepreneur
experts, my latest website updates, &
special sneak peaks at what's to come!

Name:
Email:

Popular Articles

Tips to Take Control of Credit Card Debt

International Employment Background Checks

SEO and the Entrepreneur

Suggestions

Email us your ideas on how to make our
website more valuable! Thank you Sharon
from Toronto Salsa Lessons / Classes for
your suggestions to make the newsletter
look like the website and profile younger
entrepreneurs like Jennifer Lopez.