|
|
Like this article? PLEASE +1 it! |
|
Start your business in Johannesburg but hire your advisor in Cape Town
Written by: Gavin ChaitArticle Overview: Small business development is a crucial part of government's strategy to reduce unemployment and increase black economic empowerment.
![]() |
Free Download - Jacob Zuma, Inflation Denialist? By Gavin Chait |
Start your business in Johannesburg but hire your advisor in Cape Town
Small business development is a crucial part of government's strategy to reduce unemployment and increase black economic empowerment.
Whythawk has recently completed rating individual small business development consultants in the Western Cape and Gauteng as well as their overall impact on supporting emerging entrepreneurs.
Gauteng beneficiaries' businesses are three times larger, employ 30% more staff and pay a third higher wages than those in the Western Cape. Yet only 47% of beneficiaries of small business programs in Gauteng are self-employed one year after the intervention compared to 76% for the Western Cape. "This is despite greater opportunities in Gauteng," says Hermann Jeuschenak, Director of Ratings at Whythawk.
Gauteng entrepreneurs secure significantly less finance (R 42 000 per business relative to R 233 000 in the Western Cape), are less likely to invest and three times more likely to remain unemployed post intervention. In addition service providers in Gauteng charge 250% more for their services than in the Western Cape.
Many of the small business support voucher programs, such as the Umsobomvu Youth Fund, do not require consultants to conduct follow-ups, guide their clients through the loan application or implementation phases post-intervention, or even to provide mentorship. Many consultants in the Western Cape endeavour to provide this anyway while virtually no Gauteng consultants do. The results are visible in significantly higher implementation rates in the Western Cape.
Gauteng service providers, in particular, regularly make unrealistic loan applications with limited hope of success. Both regions make similar loan representations (58% vs 59% of all clients) but only 15% in the Western Cape and 11% in Gauteng go on to have their loan applications granted.
"These are poor results and indicate consultants have little interest in progressing beyond simply producing business plans," says Jeuschenak. "This is a pity as banks have expressed interest in working with consultants who consistently identify and support successful entrepreneurs."
This is the first year that ratings of this nature have been conducted and the objective is to improve the transparency of development as well as offering beneficiaries the ability to choose consultants who will offer them the greatest chance of success.
"Our results offer consultants, as well as development programs, the opportunity to improve their effectiveness in order to create more businesses and more jobs," says Jeuschenak.
|
About the Author: Gavin Chait RSS for Gavin's articles - Visit Gavin's website Gavin Chait is the principle analyst for Whythawk Ratings, the trusted advisor for many of South Africa's most demanding development initiatives for almost a decade. Chait specialises in economic and enterprise development. He both creates systems for economic and business generation and then project manages these through the implementation phase. Gavin has worked with the University of Cape Town Department of Management Studies in the Faculty of Commerce to develop student entrepreneurial consulting projects. He has a close relationship with the Department of Economic Development and Tourism working on projects as diverse as tourism development and support; and the 1000 x 1000 Project in which 1 000 individuals were given the opportunity to start a business for R 1 000 each. Gavin assisted with the initial project scoping and development of his original idea for implementation at such a large scale. He further wrote the training and feedback manuals to be used in the event and project managed the event. Gavin’s qualifications include degrees in Microbiology and Biochemistry (from the University of Cape Town in 1994) and a degree in Electrical Engineering (UCT, 1998). Click here to visit Gavin's website Africa China and Investment This festive season the accumulating effects of individual activity Trevor Manuel and the Plunder of Skills Jobs are from Mars Business is from Venus The war of informal markets against central states a bellwether of support |
Related Forum Posts
Share this article with your friends. Fund someone's dream.
Leave a comment below or share on the left and you'll help support entrepreneurs in Africa through our partnership with Kiva. Over $50,000 raised and counting - Please keep sharing! Learn more.
Get advice & tips from famous business
owners, new articles by entrepreneur
experts, my latest website updates, &
special sneak peaks at what's to come!
Why Marketing Outsourcing is Growing So Quickly
Environment and productivity at the office
LISTENING SKILLS IN COACHING
Email us your ideas on how to make our
website more valuable! Thank you Sharon
from Toronto Salsa Lessons / Classes for
your suggestions to make the newsletter
look like the website and profile younger
entrepreneurs like Jennifer Lopez.



