Feedback Form
Home Features Mastermind Forums About Advertise Blog Network Contact Be An Author

6.1 Propositions for the international development community: Enterprise solutions to poverty

6.1 Propositions for the international development community: Enterprise solutions to poverty

The first set relate primarily to the role of donors
(including corporate foundations and philanthropy
programmes) who, because they control the
money, are critically important influences on what
issues IDC actors focus on and how they work.

1. Don’t give, invest

The core proposition is that donors should act less
like charities and more like investors. In part, this
means allocating more of available resources (such
as might be forthcoming from the ‘International
Finance Facility’ proposed by the UK government)
towards investment vehicles targeting the pro-poor
enterprise sector. However, more fundamentally we
also mean that when donors spend aid money
through their normal partners – government
agencies, NGOs, etc – the primary outcomes they
should be after are measurable impacts on the propoor
enterprise sector linked directly to the project
or activity they are funding.

a. Make it hurt

To facilitate this, donors could do a number of
things – some of which no doubt more progressive
donors are already doing. They could require
grantees to make real financial contributions from
their own funds to the project. Grant payments
could be phased against meeting performance
targets. Financial incentives could be built into
rewarding the grantee if the project exceeds its
enterprise targets (including awarding bonuses or
retaining any surplus). And the grantee could face
sanctions and be held accountable if it does not
deliver on what is promised – perhaps, for
example, by having to return a percentage of the
grant to the donor.

b. Do as I do

And just to demonstrate commitment, the donors
themselves could use their own internal incentive
structures to ensure staff and managers are
rewarded or held accountable for the performance
of their projects against what we would argue is
one of the few ‘bottom lines’ that should matter in
the fight against poverty – measurable growth
among pro-poor enterprises and increased benefits
flowing to poor people as a result.

These are clearly extreme steps for the donor
community, non-profits and civil servants and to be
sure even the Shell Foundation does not operate
entirely along these lines. And many objections
could be raised.61 But we offer them up in such
stark terms in order to encourage debate around
the following proposition.

c. Put the poor ‘customer’ in charge –
not the rich paymaster

Our hopeful assumption is that by striving towards
the ideal of being held accountable for achieving
measurable contributions to pro-poor enterprise
and sustainable livelihoods, donors and grantees
will be catalysed into becoming more enterprising,
innovative and efficient in their search for solutions
to poverty.

Why might this happen? Because this approach
tackles a costly (for the poor) contradiction at the
heart of the aid-poverty equation.

The ‘failure’ of many projects in our portfolio and
elsewhere can often be traced directly to the fact
that the project partners were not focused on best
meeting the needs of their real customers but were
responding to other incentives – including donor
agendas and their own professional interests (See
annex 2).

If one were to apply this ‘who’s the market/who’s
the customer’ filter to the aid-funded ‘output’ of
the IDC, especially that part of the IDC located
institutionally in the rich countries, we expect a
very large share of what is done (and certainly the
vast majority of what is studied and written) in the
interests of development, is primarily undertaken
to meet the agendas of the IDC itself rather than
the material interests of the poor.

So we are arguing – along with others such as
Easterly (2002) – that setting targets and incentives
for donors and other IDCs that are linked to
customer satisfaction (i.e. measurable success or
failure in pro-poor enterprise creation) should ensure
maximum effort is focused on delivering results
that matter (See annex 2).

The logic of the approach we are proposing is
simple. The challenges involved in actually
implementing it are obviously not. It requires
donors and recipients to think very differently
about how they do what they do.More importantly,
it would lead them to work within a risk–return
relationship and ‘consequence accountability’
structure similar to that which exists between an
investor and a start-up business, and between
shareholders and management – cultures that are
foreign to many donors and grantees.

Nevertheless, our experience and that of others
suggest it is possible to structure interventions and
incentives that powerfully and successfully focus
everyone’s attention on the end game of pro-poor
enterprise creation and we suggest the topic is
worthy of wider debate and consideration.

2. It’s not the (aid) money that matters

This proposition harks back to our arguments that
there will never be enough foreign ‘soft’ money to
allow pro-poor enterprise financing to go to scale
and thus the importance of getting local capital
into a lead role in this area.

As argued earlier, using ‘softer’ money from abroad
to invest in pro-poor enterprise can play an
important starter or demonstration role. And
clearly, in regions such as sub-Saharan Africa, it is
very important we do everything we can to
enhance investor confidence.

But our proposition is that the introduction of
pro-poor enterprise aid funding should from the
outset complement and catalyse the increasing
involvement of local capital and local suppliers of
business development services – not substitute for
them. It’s possible to do this and it can work as our
efforts and those of others in Uganda and South
Africa and those of S3IDF in India have shown.

3. Link MDG interventions, debt relief and
other macro-interventions to pro-poor
enterprise creation

We’re conscious that the share of available
resources and effort going to pro-poor enterprise
creation will always be limited. However pro-poor
interventions in other areas can be ‘calibrated’ to
help contribute to the enterprise objective without
detracting from their core objectives. Debt relief
conditions, the way aid financing is delivered and
various MDG programmes including the provision
of education, health care and clean water can relatively
easily incorporate pro-poor enterprise objectives
that do not have negative impacts elsewhere.

In the case of MDGs, this would range from
ensuring money spent on pro-poor service delivery
catalysed local enterprise growth through to the
application of enterprise or business thinking to
better ensure MDG plans delivered specific
measurable outcomes benefiting the most poor
people at least cost.

The same logic applies in relation to interventions
designed to tackle corruption or strengthening the
management capacities of local government. These
are very big problems in most poor countries and
the resources don’t exist to tackle them everywhere
at once. Interventions in these problems areas must
be prioritised.

So why not focus on those aspects of the generic
problems of corruption or capacity that most
inhibit the growth of enterprise? Entrepreneurs and
businesspeople can help governments and the IDC
map out the ‘value chain’ of activities and stages
where corruption or lack of government capacities
impinge on enterprise creation. Then, provided the
political commitment is present, intervention could
focus on tackling the most important blockages.

These are not backdoor strategies for the
privatisation of the delivery of poverty services or
the imposition of user fees. They are simply
suggestions that those designing MDG policies
and programmes be aware, competent and
incentivised to apply enterprise thinking to what
they are doing and to leverage their resources to
aid pro-poor enterprise creation.

There are probably some good examples of this
happening but as aid flows targeting MDGs
increase, many more opportunities will arise. Our
concern is that if enterprise thinking and objectives
are not mainstreamed now, these opportunities will
be ignored at great long-term cost to poor people.

4. Re-engineering the international
development supply chain

We argued and demonstrated earlier that in our
experience the presence of business DNA in our
partners – whether they were non-profit or forprofit
– was an important ingredient in the success
of pro-poor enterprise interventions. This
experience underpins our proposition that donors
should be considering the following options:

a. Transfer business DNA

The first is how they can best use their position
and resources to promote the transfusion of
business DNA and enterprise behaviour all along
the international development supply chain. The
examples given in Section 3 of our efforts on this
front related mostly to ‘front-line’ NGOs who are
traditionally donor-funded and operate in
development project mode, insulated from market
forces as it were.

Other parts of the development supply chain could
probably do with an injection of business DNA as
well. Most academics, policy makers, and development
agency professionals endeavouring to catalyse
pro-poor enterprise don’t have real business-based
experience to draw on. Their knowledge of how
markets operate and the problems faced by business
of all kinds is largely theoretical or conceptual.

Thus they operate on the basis of many partially
informed and often downright incorrect
assumptions about markets and enterprise. This
means the policies and interventions they design
and implement, with the best intentions, to
catalyse the efficient operation of markets or the
creation of enterprise just don’t work or don’t work
nearly well enough.

This mismatch between theory and practice,
between ‘talking the talk’ of markets and enterprise
and actually knowing how to ‘walk the walk’, are obviously not the sole reason why many enterpriseoriented
(and growth-oriented) policies and
interventions in poor countries haven’t worked as
well as intended. But there is a certain logic in the
argument that if we want policies and
interventions that help pro-poor enterprise grow, it
would be useful to be able to inject more
experience-based, business DNA into the project
and policy design process. It’s not easy62 but it can
be done and donors are perfectly positioned to
drive this process – perhaps even via new forms of
partnership with big business that would facilitate
the transfer of their business DNA into the
development supply chain (See annex 2).

b. Develop alternative sources of supply

The second option is to construct an ‘alternative’
development supply chain by working more extensively
and more directly with the for-profit sector
on devising and delivering pro-poor enterprise
interventions. Our experience is that the efficiency
of resource use is higher, the transaction and learning
costs lower and the going-to-scale opportunities
much greater than when trying to accomplish the
same thing with the non-profit sector.

c. Promote hybrids

A third route could be to use market principles to
encourage the emergence of financially viable,
hybrid ‘network business models’ capable of
delivering pro-poor services on a large scale.
Donors could facilitate the coming together of
private and non-profit entities into a new form of
hybrid ‘enterprise’ that could use smart subsidies
and commercial capital, best-practice business and
developmental skills, to deliver differentially priced
services to different segments of the poverty
market.

This is an approach the Shell Foundation is
piloting in the scale-up phase of its Breathing Space
programme in India and elsewhere, where the aim
is to achieve significant ‘market penetration’ of
cleaner stoves and fuels among poor household
‘markets’ that number in their millions.

The re-engineering of the development supply
chain along business lines is happening to a certain
extent as some donors and non-profits try to apply
business thinking to what they do.63 But these
business-like development entities and experiments
are still in the minority and largely peripheral to
the way most of the IDC is organised and
incentivised. We suggest therefore that whether
and how to introduce business principles and
business DNA into the mainstream IDC is a topic
worthy of further urgent debate.





61 Propositions for the international development community Enterprise solutions to poverty - To learn more about this author, visit Shell Foundation's Website.

Like this article? Share it with your friends

Article Feedback
 61 Propositions for the international development community Enterprise solutions to poverty Great take
Commented on 61 Propositions for the international development community Enterprise solutions to poverty.
 61 Propositions for the international development community Enterprise solutions to poverty Leave Your Feedback
article feedback

Article Feedback
John Brennan
John Brennan Ed.D. Dr. Brennan is President of Interpersonal Development, LLC, a training and development firm. Interpersonal Development has provided sales training and coaching to more than 3,000 sales reps from over 100 companies. A native of Australia, Dr. Brennan received his doctorate from the University of Rochester. His dissertation researched the effectiveness of Behavioral Modeling Technology in training people in interpersonal skills. While he has spent most of his career designing or delivering training, he was also a Vice-President of Sales of a training and development franchise with operations in 25 markets. Dr. Brennan has designed and delivered sales training in North America, Asia, Europe, Australia and the Middle East. He has been a guest speaker at numerous national and regional professional conferences. When Microsoft wanted Best Practices articles on sales for their web site, they called Dr. Brennan. The results are at http://office.microsoft.com/en-us/FX011387391033.aspx His firm’s clients have included Volvo, The Prudential, Merrill Lynch, Eastman Kodak, Gannett, Equifax Europe, the Economist Group and countless small businesses. - Visit John Brennan's Website

Anne Barr
Anne Barr has over 26 years experience in sales and marketing, six years as a franchisee. She has assisted over 367 business owners and purchasers to achieve their goals in career change, transition and exit strategy. She holds the designation of Certified Franchise Executive from the International Franchise Association, Certified Business Intermediary from the International Business Brokers Association and Board Certified Broker from the Texas Association of Business Brokers. Anne is active in professional organizations, networking groups and volunteers for non-profit entities. As owner/operator of four successful businesses, Anne has proven people skills and enjoys helping clients find the right "fit" in business ownership. Visit www.FranchiseOpportunitySpecialist.com for more information about me and my company. - Visit Anne Barr's Website

Linda Richardson
Linda Richardson is the Founder and Executive Chairwoman of Richardson, a global sales training and performance improvement company. As a recognized leader in the industry, she has won the coveted Stevie Award for Lifetime Achievement in Sales Excellence and she was identified by Training Industry, Inc. as one of the “Top 20 Most Influential Training Professionals.” Ms. Richardson is credited with the movement to Consultative Selling and is the author of ten books on selling and sales management, including Sales Coaching — Making the Great Leap from Sales Manager to Sales Coach, and Stop Telling, Start Selling. She teaches sales and management at the Wharton Graduate School of the University of Pennsylvania and the Wharton Executive Development Center. Linda is a frequent speaker at industry and client conferences, has been published extensively in industry and training journals, and has been featured in numerous publications, including The Wall Street Journal, Forbes, Nation’s Business, Selling Power, Success, and The Conference Board Magazine. Learn more about Richardson's sales training and performance improvement solutions at http://www.richardson.com web - Visit Linda Richardson's Website

Cheryl Matthynssens

Cheryl is a life skills coach, licensed Chemical Dependency Counselor and a 20 year entrepreneur.  Cheryl's dedication to achieving a life of balance led to her expanding her teaching from the simple managing of life's daily challenges to adding financial well being as well.  A direct marketer with DrinkACT, she is gaining ground in the online community with her concepts of making sure business owners, entreprenuers and employees have well rounded life styles.  She opened up a small affiliate site - The Balance Guide-  to help others find resources for mental and emotional well being.  Visit Cheryl's blog to see more of the diversity beyond business she has began offering online at www.thebalanceguide.blogspot.com

- Visit Cheryl Matthynssens's Website

Leanne Hoagland-Smith
Are your sales where you want them to be? Will you be one of the few who achieves sales or business success or one of the many who have failed to change? Are you tired of being told you are like everyone else? Then you may find my first book on sales of interest. Be the Red Jacket in the Sea of Gray Suits, The Keys to Unlocking Sales available at Amazon or at http://www.processspecialist.com/red-jacket.htm. This book is a reflection of my no-nonsense approach to improving sales to overall business results. If you are truly committed to making sustainable changes, then I can help you secure a positive return on your investment because I focus on executable solutions not telling you the problems you already know you have. From training to corporate (group) coaching to executive one on one coaching, my approach is to assess, create awareness, build a goal driven action plan and then execute. The bottom line question is "Not do you or your employees know it, but do you or they want to do it?" Please call for a free strategy session at 219.759.5601. - Visit Leanne Hoagland-Smith's Website

David Barr
David Barr is the President of Venture Opportunities, Inc. David has been a professional business broker/intermediary since 1980 focusing on General Business Brokerage and Mergers and Acquisitions representing client transaction value from $400,000 to $20,000,000. Mr. Barr has handled the sale of over four hundred and fifty companies. David earned a university degree from the State University of New York majoring in economics and business. David holds the Mergers and Acquisition Master Intermediary and the Certified Business Intermediary designations from the International Business Brokers Association. He is also a Senior Business Analyst and a Texas licensed Real Estate Agent. For more information about David and Venture Opportunities, visit www.bizdealmaker.com. - Visit David Barr's Website

George Ludwig
George Ludwig is a recognized authority on sales strategy and peak performance psychology. An international speaker, trainer, and corporate consultant, he helps clients like Johnson & Johnson, Abbott Laboratories, Northwestern Mutual, CIGNA, and numerous others improve sales force effectiveness and performance. Though it's George's strategies and processes that help corporations increase productivity and performance, it's his tremendous energy and dynamism that spark the transformation. Again and again, clients remark on his amazing ability to unleash human capacity and inspire men and women to break out of their comfort zones. The result is a whole new type of salesperson. His customized presentations teach achievers to make stunning advances in their lives. From helping salespeople realize cherished dreams to helping corporations exponentially accelerate revenue streams, George Ludwig leaves audiences and individuals empowered, emboldened, and clamoring for more. George is the best-selling author of Power Selling: Seven Strategies for Cracking the Sales Code and Wise Moves: 60 Quick Tips to Improve Your Position in Life & Business. - Visit George Ludwig's Website

Dave Kurlan
Dave Kurlan is the founder and CEO of Objective Management Group, Inc., the industry leader in sales assessments and sales force evaluations, and the CEO of David Kurlan & Associates, Inc., a consulting firm specializing in sales force development. Dave has been a top rated speaker at Inc. Magazine's Conference on Growing the Company, the Sales & Marketing Management Conference and the Gazelles Sales & Marketing Summit. He has been featured on radio and TV, including World Business Review with General Norman Schwarzkopf, in Inc. Magazine, Selling Power Magazine, Sales & Marketing Management Magazine and Incentive Magazine. He is the author of Mindless Selling and Baseline Selling – How to Become a Sales Superstar by Using What You Already Know about the Game of Baseball. He created and wrote STAR, a proprietary recruiting process for hiring great salespeople, and he writes Understanding the Sales Force, a popular business Blog and is a contributing author to The Death of 20th Century Selling and 101 Great Ways to Improve Your Life, Volume 2. - Visit Dave Kurlan's Website


To learn more about the Evan Elite Author Program please contact us.

About The Author


Shell Foundation
(Visit Shell's Website) The Shell Foundation is established to support efforts to achieve a balance between economic growth, care for the environment and equitable social development - the goal of sustainable development. The Foundation's focus on sustainable development is based upon the Shell Group's belief that the long-term health and prosperity of societies of which it is part, and its own future, depends on the ability of all stakeholders, worldwide, to attain such balance. However, as one of the most significant international oil and energy groups, Shell recognises the global dimension of many sustainability issues related to its activities. It believes it has a responsibility and an opportunity to play its part in addressing these issues.

Shell Foundation is a Gold author on EvanCarmichael.com
About The Author

View Author Blog
View Author Blog

View Author Video
View Author Video

Free Downloads


Shell Foundation's

Complete
List Of
African-Accounts
Articles

Name
Email
If you enjoyed this article, get Shell Foundation's Complete List of African-Accounts Articles For FREE!

More Shell Foundation
51 Case Study 1 Enterprise solutions to poverty
50 Shell Foundations experience on the ground Enterprise solutions to poverty
40 Learning by doing Enterprise solutions to poverty
62 Propositions for engaging the international business community Enterprise solutions to poverty
60 Propositions and conclusion Enterprise solutions to poverty
52 Case Study 2 Enterprise solutions to poverty
30 The case for putting propoor enterprise at the heart of the war on poverty Enterprise solutions to poverty
57 Meeting the needs of the entrepreneur Enterprise solutions to poverty
20 Introduction Enterprise solutions to poverty
58 So far so good in Uganda Enterprise solutions to poverty
Free Downloads


 
 
 


Evan Elite Authors
Anne Barr  
David Barr  
Dave Kurlan  
Evan Elite Authors

Become An Author
Have you written articles that would be of value to entrepreneurs? Become an expert on our site by publishing them! Expose yourself to a wide audience, drive more traffic to your website and get more sales! Click Here for details.
Become An Author

Evan's Latest Video
Modeling the Masters: Learn the true secrets behind Walt Disney's business success factors & grow your company! Video produced by Phanta Media
Evan's Latest Video

Business Opportunities
"Learn straight from Evan how you can Make a Full Time Income (And More) from a Website"

How to Start An Online Business

Click Here To Learn More
Business Opportunities



Evan's Newsletter
Get advice & tips from famous business owners, new articles by entrepreneur experts, my latest website updates, & special sneak peaks at what's to come!
Name:
Email:
Evan`s Newsletter

Free Downloads
Memorandum Template 2 Icon Memorandum Template 2
Sale Systems Icon Sale Systems
EMPLOYMENT PRACTICES LIABILITY Icon EMPLOYMENT PRACTICES LIABILITY
The Small Picture Icon The Small Picture
Boomers & Zoomers Icon Boomers & Zoomers
Free Downloads - Complete List

Entrepreneur Tools and Guides
Top 50 HR Blogs 2009
Top 50 HR Blogs 2009
Top 50 HR Blogs 2009
 
More PR Resources
More PR Resources
Press Release Builder
 
Entrepreneur Tools and Guides

SEO For Africa
SEO For Africa
Boni Ketowou Adéta, Togo,
Boni Ketowou
Adéta, Togo
SEO For Africa

If I Were A Startup...
Kerry Shapansky, $2.0 to $51 Mil in 5 years
Kerry Shapansky
$2.0 to $51 Mil in 5 years
Chris Nguyen, 30+ national clients on $0
Chris Nguyen
30+ national clients on $0
If I Were A Startup... - Complete List

Famous Entrepreneurs
Anita Roddick, The Body Shop
Anita Roddick
The Body Shop
Henry Heinz, HJ Heinz
Henry Heinz
HJ Heinz
Famous Entrepreneurs - Complete List

Entrepreneur Advice
Guy Kawasaki, The Art of the Start
Guy Kawasaki
The Art of the Start
David Allen, Getting Things Done
David Allen
Getting Things Done
Entrepreneur Advice - Complete List

Popular Articles
(Premium Authors)

     Getting Your Message Heard Amidst The Clutter
By Allan Katz
     The 5 Easy Ways To Increase Store Traffic
By Allan Katz
     What Makes Marketing Work
By Allan Katz

Have A Suggestion?
Toronto Salsa Classes / Toronto Salsa Lessons Email us your ideas on how to make our website more valuable! Thank you Sharon from Toronto Salsa Lessons / Classes for your suggestions to make the newsletter look like the website and profile younger entrepreneurs like Jennifer Lopez and Sean Combs!
Have A Suggestion?

More Evan Carmichael
More Information