Tweet

7.2.1 A pro-poor training strategy: Room for manoeuvre

Written by: International Labour Organization

Article Overview: Recommendations concerning poverty reduction are frequently flawed because they fail to take adequate account of underlying political and social constraints and the ability of the state to fund and deliver effective programmes.

7.2.1 A pro-poor training strategy: Room for manoeuvre

Recommendations concerning poverty reduction are frequently flawed because they fail to take adequate account of underlying political and social constraints and the ability of the state to fund and deliver effective programmes. Almost everywhere, the room for manoeuvre in developing effective training strategies for the poor is very limited. Furthermore, the unintended consequences of anti-poverty programmes are commonplace mainly because of lack of information and dysfunctional incentives (see Klitgaard, 1998). Consequently, any strategy that is adopted needs to be experimental and participatory and to make the least possible demands on already weak institutional capacity

To a large extent, the failure of public training institutions to reorient their activities in favour of the poor is part of a wider political problem. In particular, pro-poor training reforms will invariably threaten powerful vested interests - both those of capital and organised labour in the formal sector - and the state itself. Thus, it is rather ironic that conventional tripartism between employer and worker organisations and the state, which was originally introduced as a progressive, social democratic governance arrangement, has become a major obstacle preventing the poor gaining an effective voice in VET systems in many developing countries.

7.2.1 A pro-poor training strategy

What exactly are the main features of a 'pro-poor training strategy'? This is a strikingly simple and obvious question, but the discussion about 'training for the poor' has been mainly preoccupied with the effectiveness of specific training interventions 'on the ground', particularly in relation to the provision of credit and other forms of assistance (see Box 12). Just why so little attention has been devoted to targeted reforms of the training system itself so that training provision is more inclusive of the poor is an interesting issue in its own right. As was discussed earlier, this neglect can, at least in part, be explained by superordinate concerns with meeting the training needs of formal sector enterprises and the almost universal crisis of confidence about the actual and potential role of training in poverty reduction. Current debates about the reform of national training systems are excessively preoccupied with how the 'higher skills' needed to achieve international competitiveness in a rapidly globalising world economy should be provided. There is an urgent need, therefore, for a more balanced and serious dialogue about the provision of (lower) skills for the poor. The ILO needs to take the lead in initiating this process of dialogue among all key stakeholders.

The overall objective of a pro-poor training strategy is to ensure that training needs of the poor are met in an equitable and effective manner. There are, therefore, two sets of issues that must be addressed namely, overall resource availability and the development of the training system itself. Sufficient resources need to be made available that ensure that skill development among the poor is given the priority attention that it deserves. This training needs, therefore, to be mainstreamed in poverty reduction programmes and, more widely, in pro-poor development strategies. Equally important, a coherent, well articulated training system needs to be developed which ensures that resources that are made available are used efficiently and effectively. The main functional components of such a system are the governance, organisation, planning, funding, and actual delivery of training services to targeted groups of the poor and the disadvantaged.

To be effective, all training systems must be demand-driven. How training demands are articulated is, therefore, of paramount importance. Appropriate institutional structures have to be created that ensure that decisions about the control and utilisation of training resources are made not by the suppliers of training services, as traditionally has been the case, but by end users themselves. In the case of the poor, shifting the locus of control and decision-making in this way amounts to a radical change from past practices. In most countries, it can only be achieved as part of a much wider process of development that is based on local economic development initiatives and with poverty reduction as the top priority.

In broad terms, a pro-poor training strategy should be designed in accordance with the following principles:

· In order to improve their livelihoods on a sustainable basis, the poor need both improved skills and more resources in the context of an enabling economic environment.

· Governments must normally take primary responsibility for funding skills development for the poor while enterprises and individuals who are able to pay for training should be required to do so.

· The planning and funding of training by the state should be clearly separated from the provision of training services by public sector training institutions

· Training services must be closely integrated with local economic development. Consequently, primary responsibility for the identification of training needs for the poor should be devolved to community-based and other local organisations which also have control over other public resources made available to meet priority needs.

· Wherever possible, effective training markets need to be created by establishing a level playing field on which all suppliers, both public and private, can compete.

· Training should be delivered by a strongly motivated cadre of high level personnel who have the special skills needed for small enterprise and self-employment promotion.

· Business, self-employment and entrepreneurship concepts need to be closely integrated into training activities.

· Training programmes must be carefully targeted both with respect to particular groups of the poor and their particular skills development needs. As a general rule, specific training should be provided only where the required skills are a "key missing ingredient" for the development of the enterprise as a whole.

EMPLOYMENT AND TRAINING
PAPERS
43
Learning to change: Skills
development among the
economically vulnerable and
socially excluded in
developing countries
Paul Bennell
Employment and Training Department
International Labour Office Geneva
First published 1999

Related Articles
  Stretching the Training Budget
  4.2.2 Training provision for women
  6 Common Objections and How to Handle Them
  The Top 10 Home Staging Ideas During The Holidays
  How To Get The Right Loan For You (UK)

Article Tags: adequate account, democratic governance, developing countries, developing effective training, dysfunctional, formal sector, institutional capacity, interventions, manoeuvre, neglect, obstacle, poverty reduction, social constraints, specific training, training institutions, training strategies, tripartism, unintended consequences, vet systems, worker organisations



Related Forum Posts
Need Help Growing? - One resource that I've found to be extremely helpful was calling the Business Development Bank of Canada (BDC). I've met a lot of top business owners who have used the BDC for various reasons (i.e. sales/marketing strategy, training, foreign development, etc) and all say it was a massive help. The BDC will usually help you create the strategy using industry specific consultants and then not only help you fund the consultant's work but also the strategy. Their loan terms are little higher than banks but they’re a lot more easy going and understanding than regular banks.
Training - Louis: Some regulated industries mandate that you attend training. However, even then, finding time to meet those requirements becomes an issue. This may explain the growth of tele-seminars. To answer your questions though, ROI is very important and everyone needs to sell or market no matter what they do. The best tip I ever got on training is not to pitch training as training b/c even big companies have limited budgets for training but training rebranded as "sales support." It makes the ROI argument that much more appealing. Hope that helps. Good luck.
One Thing To Note - As a trainer myself, I'm always amazed at the lengths organizations go to to pay for training and then not follow through. Any training I design myself has to have at least an offer built in for future support as well, for the benefit of those receiving the training, the organizer and the people the trainee works with. Corporates don't seem to like this too much - they often seem to want to budget, sign it off, run it and close it off. I'd always ensure that there is the offer of ongoing support/challenge/development in some shape of form. Not sure what Louis or any other training providers find...
Re: Do Women Play the Stock Market? - Hi Aneshia, [quote="AneshiaYS":1lz5khur]I implement a strategy for risk management[/quote:1lz5khur] I'm glad to read this. I think it's the most important part of investing. "Diversify" and have a clear "exit strategy" - ah yes, but "following it" is the hard part and if you have a strategy to induce your clients to follow the strategy, I should think it would be an excellent service.
Strategy People - Greetings all! Recently I have come to the understanding that I am severely lacking strategy. I have many, many tactics on how to make money with my business but without a strategy to implement those tactics I'm spinning my wheels. Has anyone found someone who is a great strategist for their business? There are lots of 'readable' resources around but like more entrepreneurs, I'm too busy thinking of ways to make money for my business rather than learning strategy. So, for me the best thing is to find someone who can help guide my business in strategic planning. Someone who can supplement my strengths with their own. As an extra question, is this a common trait amung entrepreneurs? How many here are good at strategy? If you learned to be good, how did you learn?


Share this article with your friends. Fund someone's dream.

Leave a comment below or share on the left and you'll help support entrepreneurs in Africa through our partnership with Kiva. Over $50,000 raised and counting - Please keep sharing! Learn more.

Tweet

Newsletter

Get advice & tips from famous business
owners, new articles by entrepreneur
experts, my latest website updates, &
special sneak peaks at what's to come!

Name:
Email:

Popular Articles

How Many Buckets Do You Need for Retirement?

Starting A Set of Books

The Right Job - Part Five 'Compensation'

Suggestions

Email us your ideas on how to make our
website more valuable! Thank you Sharon
from Toronto Salsa Lessons / Classes for
your suggestions to make the newsletter
look like the website and profile younger
entrepreneurs like Jennifer Lopez.