Tweet

2.3 Looking for Financial Sustainability: Microfinance in Africa - Experience and Lessons from Selected African Countries

Guest post by: International Monetary Fund

Article Overview: The technologies described above, based on the formalization of informal techniques and on group-based instruments, have been used to promote financial sustainability of MFIs. They have the advantage of addressing a number of problems faced by financial institutions when operating with the poor or with the informal sector, for example, asymmetry of information, lack of collateral, and difficult enforcement of legal rights.

2.3 Looking for Financial Sustainability: Microfinance in Africa - Experience and Lessons from Selected African Countries

(IMF Working Paper, Prepared by Anupam Basu, Rodolphe Blavy, and Murat Yulek1, September 2004)

The technologies described above, based on the formalization of informal techniques and on
group-based instruments, have been used to promote financial sustainability of MFIs. They
have the advantage of addressing a number of problems faced by financial institutions when
operating with the poor or with the informal sector, for example, asymmetry of information,
lack of collateral, and difficult enforcement of legal rights.

The linking of savings and credit programs is often used as a way to overcome the problems
caused by asymmetry of information between lenders and borrowers, and by the borrowers’
lack of collateral, although this limits the flexibility in allocating loanable funds. In
particular, the weakest performers could drag down the performance of the entire group.
However, by making the group responsible for loan recovery and repayment, peer pressure
acts as a substitute for collateral. MFIs can then save on transaction costs and increase the
repayment rate. Hence, group-based microfinance techniques may also be viewed as a
response to portfolio performance problems experienced with individual loans. At the same
time individual lending technologies have also been successfully adapted to the microfinance
context. In Ghana for example, the RCBs had initially focused on standard commercial loans
to individuals and experienced a high volume of non-performing loans, but they later
improved performance by adjusting the terms of the loans, generally to short-term (4-6
months), and by requiring weekly repayments, and retaining a compulsory up-front savings
of 20 percent as a security.

Group lending with joint liability tends to encourage self-selection and group formation
among good credit risks, addressing partially the problem of imperfect information faced by
the lender, and thereby lowering the overall risk of the group lending scheme. This is because
the risk of a potential default by any one individual is borne by the whole membership. A
number of limits/risks may exist in group lending schemes with joint liabilities, where the
behavior of one individual may affect the repayment of the group as a whole:

• First, under a group lending scheme, the burden of risk borne by an individual
member of the group is higher than it would have been under a limited liability
scheme. Thus for a group lending-scheme to be the preferred alternative to a limited
liability scheme, the gains from lower overall risk under the former would have to
outweigh the default risk that borrowers pass on to the nonborrowers of the group
lending scheme.

• The second risk is a contagion effect whereby a default by one borrower affects the
credit rating of the group as a whole and causes it to default.

• The third risk is a coordination failure problem as individual borrowers have an
incentive to default when they expect other individual members of the group to fail.
This may prompt a default of the group even when all its members are solvent.

Some mechanisms have been designed to reduce the risk that individual behavior may
impose on the group as a whole. Sequential lending, when loans are provided sequentially to
different sub-groups of borrowers participating in a given group lending scheme, is one
example, that reduces contagion and coordination failure risks.6 Also, self-selection leads to
the formation of groups of relatively safe borrowers, hence limiting the transfer of risk from
the group to the individual borrower. One concern is that group lending schemes have been
argued to be overly conservative in risk-taking, selecting only the safest projects.

The obvious critical issue is whether MFIs have achieved financial sustainability, at least in
the sense of achieving “break-even” in their current operations, if not also in fully covering
their investment costs. There is little hard data available for African MFIs to answer this
question, and one has only partial data at best. There is some evidence that MFIs are able to
improve their financial performance, if they have autonomy over their management
decisions; are allowed to set their lending and deposit rates to maintain a spread consistent
with profitability; are vigilant in their efforts to avoid or reduce the incidence of
nonperforming loans; and focus on addressing their capacity and skills supply constraints.

• In Benin, following the financial rehabilitation programs of 1989-93 and that
launched in 1999 (described below in Box 4), many SLCs were able to substantially
expand their deposits and loan portfolios, recover their nonperforming loans, and
achieve break-even or positive net profits in their current operations.

• In Ghana, the performance in the rural microfinance (RMF) sector is reported to
have improved in recent years. The combination of (i) a more commercial
approach, (ii) a restructuring of the sector through re-capitalization and capacitybuilding,
and (iii) strengthened regulation contributed to reduce drastically the
proportion of distressed RCBs. At the level of S&Ls and credit unions, weak
financial performance, mostly due to a welfare focus and policies of low interest
rates, was reportedly improved through a greater commercial focus supported by
better management and financial reporting. From 1996 to 2001, the proportion of
“unsatisfactory” credit unions declined from 70 percent to 60 percent and that of
those in the worst categories from 42 percent to 15 percent.

• In Guinea, the four existing MFIs are reported to have strengthened their financial
performance over the period 1997–2003. They achieved this by lowering the share
of non-performing loans (NPLs) in their total credit and raising their lending rates, and improved their prospect of achieving a more sustainable financial position. The
share of NPLs in the four MFIs was considerably lower than that of the commercial
banks, and with the aim of achieving financial sustainability, the MFIs maintained a
wider interest rate spread than that prevailing in the banking sector.

Related Articles
  II. How Can MicroFinance Succeed In Africa?
  IV Module I Key Principles for an African Model of Microfinance
  III. BACKGROUND - Microfinance in Africa
  1.0 Introduction: Microfinance in Africa - Experience and Lessons from Selected African Countries
  SME's - why is franchising not more popular in Africa

Article Tags: financial sustainability, group lending, individual



Related Forum Posts
Re: Newbie from Africa - [quote="Evan":22gvtxlq]Welcome to the forums Biiyke! You asked if we know any sellers who were trying to reach the African market... I think you'd honestly have more luck going the other way - try to find sellers in Africa and sell to the rest of the world.[/quote:22gvtxlq] Hello Evan, You are absolutely correct.Thank you for your advice.That's actually the whole idea,Africa to the world and the world to Africa. So I will throw more weight on that area.
Re: How will an african make money truely on the net? - Is it possible for an African business to set up an "offshore" account in the US or England... or even Switzerland... where all monies are paid? And a trusted agent there, who gets a percentage of any money, can then take that money from paypal and wire it or mail it or whatever to an African bank? There are lots of countries in Africa, is this a problem in all of them? Seems like an internet entrepreneur who can set up a "Paypal" like company of their own might be able to make money on this... ? Course you'd need governmental contacts...
Re: Newbie from Africa - [quote="MichelleJ":1mn7d7fx]Hello Biiyke Welcome to the forum. Which part of Africa are you from it is quite a big continent? I live in South Africa. MichelleJ[/quote:1mn7d7fx]Hello MichelleJ,Nice to hear from you.I live in Nigeria.I am also trying to reach the South African market because I know You guys have a lot of unique stuff to show the world!
Re: How will an african make money truely on the net? - [quote="OmnivoreInk":koqfopnc]Is it possible for an African business to set up an "offshore" account in the US or England... or even Switzerland... where all monies are paid? And a trusted agent there, who gets a percentage of any money, can then take that money from paypal and wire it or mail it or whatever to an African bank? There are lots of countries in Africa, is this a problem in all of them? Seems like an internet entrepreneur who can set up a "Paypal" like company of their own might be able to make money on this... ? Course you'd need governmental contacts...[/quote:koqfopnc] Hi Topeyinka I don't know what products you sell, but if they are digital how about selling them through Clickbank. They will handle the sale for you and will send you cheques on the money you have earned. MichelleJ
Re: Newbie from Africa - Welcome to the forums Biiyke! You asked if we know any sellers who were trying to reach the African market... I think you'd honestly have more luck going the other way - try to find sellers in Africa and sell to the rest of the world.


Share this article with your friends. Fund someone's dream.

Leave a comment below or share on the left and you'll help support entrepreneurs in Africa through our partnership with Kiva. Over $50,000 raised and counting - Please keep sharing! Learn more.

Tweet

Newsletter

Get advice & tips from famous business
owners, new articles by entrepreneur
experts, my latest website updates, &
special sneak peaks at what's to come!

Name:
Email:

Popular Articles

How Many Buckets Do You Need for Retirement?

Smart & Simple Internet Techniques

10 Reasons Your SBA Loan May Be Declined

Suggestions

Email us your ideas on how to make our
website more valuable! Thank you Sharon
from Toronto Salsa Lessons / Classes for
your suggestions to make the newsletter
look like the website and profile younger
entrepreneurs like Jennifer Lopez.