Tweet

Destination branding in place St Louis

Written by: Steve Cranford

Article Overview: One American municipal leader precisely captures the challenge of those engaged in destination/place branding for cities, states and countries.

Destination branding in place St Louis

One American municipal leader precisely captures the challenge of those engaged in destination/place branding for cities, states and countries.
“We sell cheeseburgers, they sell screwdrivers,” says Mary Herndon, a spokesperson for the St. Louis Convention and Visitors Commission in comparing her organization to the city’s economic development focused Regional Chamber and Growth Association.
In a nutshell, Ms. Herndon frames the value of effective destination branding; that of creating growth in tourism and convention traffic, while at the same time attracting business investment. As the St. Louis Post-Dispatch further reports, community leaders express disbelief that one brand addressing both objectives is possible:
Hello St. LouisUnless you are a meeting planner from out of town, you probably wouldn’t know that a new marketing campaign is out to sell the Arch City. “Hello, my name is St. Louis” reads the tagline, fitted onto one of those sticky labels you usually attach to your lapel.
The “Hello” campaign is being launched by the Convention and Visitors Commission, and is aimed strictly at meeting planners…. Meanwhile, the Regional Chamber and Growth Association recently received nine proposals to “brand” St. Louis as a good place for businesses to relocate to or to step up their business activities.
Last week, a task force of the convention commission put out a report, recommending, among other things, a “genuine destination brand” for St. Louis.
It is the first of what looks to be at least three new “branding” campaigns for St. Louis.
Could they all work together, and give one coordinated image to all those seeking to visit or do business here? No.
…[One senior executive of the Chamber says] a coordinated campaign is “a wonderful idea that makes a whole lot of sense. But when you get into the specifics, it is very hard to do.” He said of the nation’s 25 largest cities, not one has successfully built a branding campaign that served both business planners and leisure travelers.
When leaders placed in charge of brand decisions fail to understand advertising is not branding, and public relations is not branding, it is easy to develop such a conclusion. But the fault for this lies not with such leaders, but rather at the feet of advertising or public relations firms often hired to formulate and guide the development of a brand.
With apologies to Virginia O’Hanlon and Francis P. Church, Yes, Virginia, there is one brand solution for St. Louis.
Just as advertising is not branding, nor is public relations branding, decision makers leave themselves open to criticism for the inability to demonstrate financial returns six, twelve and eighteen months after a new brand launch if relying upon an advertising agency to create effective brand strategy. The results are predictable: as if jamming a cheeseburger down the fuel tank of an automobile.
To create or reformulate a destination/place brand calls for a process discipline of which few are aware. For example, it is impossible to invest dollars wisely in the development of a new brand unless everyone on the team understands the answer to two fundamental questions: “What is a brand?” and “What is brand success?” Without such an understanding, the attempt to brand will fail.
What should an effective branding process look like? Any worthwhile, let’s not throw-our-money-away brand development process should include, as basic examples, a competitive analysis and market intelligence. There’s much more, of course, but let’s talk about these two key process components. Fail to include these steps and others, and your new brand is DOA.
Without a competitive analysis in which the tone and strength of competitor positioning strategies, key messages and surrounding contextual support are weighed, decision-makers in St. Louis will have little idea of the brand positions their competitors own, and what brand position St. Louis may uniquely claim within the mind of the market.
To develop a breakthrough brand requires breakthrough market intelligence. Many forms of consumer research offer results crafted to tell decision makers what they already know, instead of providing the new insight so vital to framing a compelling brand.
Unless the research construct enables subjects to speak freely, St. Louis will not uncover the fundamentals so necessary to effective brand development such as [1] the pain experienced by the market; [2] the cure for the pain the market craves to find; [3] the unique difference St. Louis may rightfully claim to the exclusion of all competitors; [4] a relevant expression of how people will feel when investing in or visiting St. Louis; and [5] how these same people want others to see them as a result of this affiliation with St. Louis. The answers to each of these fundamentals are similar for both tourism and business development interests, as each interest feeds into the other (think cheeseburger with an order of screwdrivers on the side).
Yes, a single brand can be developed to sell both tourism and business. The reality is, of course, it must be that way. Any brand must stand for one key difference, not three. Otherwise, the audience city leaders seek to engage does not have the time to listen to St. Louis go on and on about themselves, much like an irritatingly gabby aunt.
The St. Louis Cardinals would not sign a table tennis prodigy as their next can’t-miss prospect. Something for those brand decision makers down the street from Busch Stadium to think about.

Related Articles
  Map-Quest. How to Find Your Way to Success - Insurance Sales Training
  Italy vs Holland
  Pump Up Your Product Branding – Steroids for Your Business
  Do Less! Think More! by Robin J Elliott
  The definition of branding

Article Tags:



Related Forum Posts
Re: The Flaw In Personal Branding...? - The original post in this thread got my mind spinning in so many different directions. Typically when we think of branding we think of large company branding. It's interesting how many large companies have taken seemingly made up words and created a brand around those words. For example, what does the word "kleenex" mean? When you hear or read that word you automatically think of a facial tissue. How about the word "Google"? Google has come to mean an internet search engine. Having used those two examples though it leads me to what I think is most important about branding whether you are an individual, small business, or conglomerate. The purpose of your brand is to create a unique space or position in the marketplace that you and you alone own. In many cases people create a personal brand through there persona. Frank Kern is the good old boy strikes it big in internet marketing persona. Zig Ziglar is the good boy does good motivational speaker persona. When you hear there names you immediately associate that name with there unique space in the market. So coming back to personal branding and whether you should allow your personal flaws to show I would say you absolutely must because that's who you are and you can't fake you. Whether people like you or don't like you they have to know exactly who they are liking or disliking. Bottom line when it comes to branding or personal branding I think the critical question is... Does your brand create a unique place in the world that people are already looking for?
Import Export coach - It seems like they're just trying to sell products Louis - what section do you find useful? Maybe I went to the wrong place - was at business plans...
Section for Introductions? - It could work Louis. It was also suggested in a different forum thread. Any other thoughts on this? Would you guys find it useful to have a place to introduce yourselves?
Re: The Flaw In Personal Branding...? - I suppose it depends on what type of business you are in. If you are in a business such as MLM or affiliate marketing I would think that branding yourself would be better. That way whatever you decide to sell, people are buying mainly because of you. On the other hand if you have a unique product or service then maybe branding that is better. MichelleJ
Adsense Plug in - [quote:1ew3d1l8]Go to widgets.yahoo.com and download and install the widget engine.[/quote:1ew3d1l8] Thanks for the info, Louis. I shall go and do it now! I love this place! So much valuable info, so many resources!


Share this article with your friends. Fund someone's dream.

Leave a comment below or share on the left and you'll help support entrepreneurs in Africa through our partnership with Kiva. Over $50,000 raised and counting - Please keep sharing! Learn more.

Tweet

Newsletter

Get advice & tips from famous business
owners, new articles by entrepreneur
experts, my latest website updates, &
special sneak peaks at what's to come!

Name:
Email:

Popular Articles

Convening a focus group for a niche product

Why Small Businesses Don't Survive

Effective Leadership

Suggestions

Email us your ideas on how to make our
website more valuable! Thank you Sharon
from Toronto Salsa Lessons / Classes for
your suggestions to make the newsletter
look like the website and profile younger
entrepreneurs like Jennifer Lopez.