Internal vs External Mentoring
Internal vs External Mentoring
[#3 in a series of 9 articles]
Series compiled by leading business-mentor, Michael Donovan –iMentor-pro
This list is not exhaustive. The items are examples of what has been seen, experienced and commented upon as some differences between internal or external mentoring sources.
Perhaps, a way of looking at the two options is to look at what the corporation wants and the individual needs. Often, the individuals needs dictate which method will get the best results. Neither internal nor external are mutually exclusive. They can both aim for similar outcomes but arrive there using different techniques. It is also possible to have both and for them to be used as progression based on achievement and reward.
- Internal
- Strong organisational history source that underpins sense of belonging within the culture of the enterprise
- Strengthens networks of influence and persuasion within the business
- Excellent way of showing executive commitment to emerging talent
- The relationship is often more strongly focussed on results based on the internal KPI’s of the participants, as such it can be very tactical
- Access and engagement is hard to divorce from ‘What I am doing now?’ Expressed as catching and passing hand-grenades
- Mentor is a natural protector, influencer and reference point for internal political manoeuvring
- Excellent growth, learning and renewal for the mentor themselves
- Trust and the working relationship can take longer to get established but are very strong when confirmed
- Rival mentees should not use the same mentor internally
- Changing horses to another mentor can be problematic if the relationship sours and is poorly handled
- If mentor falters then mentee is often also tainted by association
- Internal mentor is a good but often suspect advocate or champion for the mentee within the corporation and limited externally
- Often unqualified to conduct formal 360 into results or apply other measures of progress and / or success
- The burden on the mentor can cause the relationship to fail if the commitment wanes
- Mentee team members may have trouble trusting the mentor if a review takes place
- Can be perceived as aligning factions within the management structure and playing to favourites
- Remember, it is simply not possible to live long enough in order to make every mistake from which to learn. Therefore, we must learn from the mistakes of others.
- External
- Can step outside those parts of the culture that restrain and seek different scenarios
- Brings no ‘internal political baggage’ to the relationship, completely independent
- Application of broader external perspectives or knowledge is often greater
- Much broader playing field associated more with strategy issues, strategic outcomes and visioning
- Process is often more robust in terms of pushing big strategic issues that will affect that part of the business performance controlled by the mentee
- Limited in political influence but excellent as an independent and dispassionate sounding board
- Within bounds of confidentiality, brings new perspectives from other clients to the relationship which are often of very high benefit
- Independence can be seen as ‘separate from’ and engagement bonding can take time
- Will not work individually for rival mentees
- Mentor can be changed when usefulness or experience is consumed with little fallout – in fact changing is recommended to suit circumstances
- No internal baggage. But can take time to get the internal perspective right
- External mentor has greater credibility as an independent advocate or champion for the mentee within and outside the business
- Can bring independent evaluation of progress and measures which is seen as more robust
- Works exclusively for the mentee and time is dedicated to that purpose without other conflicts
- High level of trust and engagement that facilitates good feedback on improvement
- Totally independent with perceived higher levels of trust, confidentiality and broader experience
- Experience is a wonderful thing.
- Experience allows us to recognise a mistake when we are about to make it again.
The content of ideas, concepts and experiences that make up this series of nine articles have been contributed from a number of sources and authors. Assembly by leading business-mentor, Michael Donovan, Managing Director, iMentor-pro 1300 720 190
Internal vs External Mentoring - To learn more about this author, visit Michael Donovan's Website.
Like this article? Share it with your friends
Internal vs External Mentoring
[#3 in a series of 9 articles]
Series compiled by leading business-mentor, Michael Donovan –iMentor-pro
This list is not exhaustive. The items are examples of what has been seen, experienced and commented upon as some differences between internal or external mentoring sources.
Perhaps, a way of looking at the two options is to look at what the corporation wants and the individual needs. Often, the individuals needs dictate which method will get the best results. Neither internal nor external are mutually exclusive. They can both aim for similar outcomes but arrive there using different techniques. It is also possible to have both and for them to be used as progression based on achievement and reward.
- Internal
- Strong organisational history source that underpins sense of belonging within the culture of the enterprise
- Strengthens networks of influence and persuasion within the business
- Excellent way of showing executive commitment to emerging talent
- The relationship is often more strongly focussed on results based on the internal KPI’s of the participants, as such it can be very tactical
- Access and engagement is hard to divorce from ‘What I am doing now?’ Expressed as catching and passing hand-grenades
- Mentor is a natural protector, influencer and reference point for internal political manoeuvring
- Excellent growth, learning and renewal for the mentor themselves
- Trust and the working relationship can take longer to get established but are very strong when confirmed
- Rival mentees should not use the same mentor internally
- Changing horses to another mentor can be problematic if the relationship sours and is poorly handled
- If mentor falters then mentee is often also tainted by association
- Internal mentor is a good but often suspect advocate or champion for the mentee within the corporation and limited externally
- Often unqualified to conduct formal 360 into results or apply other measures of progress and / or success
- The burden on the mentor can cause the relationship to fail if the commitment wanes
- Mentee team members may have trouble trusting the mentor if a review takes place
- Can be perceived as aligning factions within the management structure and playing to favourites
- Remember, it is simply not possible to live long enough in order to make every mistake from which to learn. Therefore, we must learn from the mistakes of others.
- External
- Can step outside those parts of the culture that restrain and seek different scenarios
- Brings no ‘internal political baggage’ to the relationship, completely independent
- Application of broader external perspectives or knowledge is often greater
- Much broader playing field associated more with strategy issues, strategic outcomes and visioning
- Process is often more robust in terms of pushing big strategic issues that will affect that part of the business performance controlled by the mentee
- Limited in political influence but excellent as an independent and dispassionate sounding board
- Within bounds of confidentiality, brings new perspectives from other clients to the relationship which are often of very high benefit
- Independence can be seen as ‘separate from’ and engagement bonding can take time
- Will not work individually for rival mentees
- Mentor can be changed when usefulness or experience is consumed with little fallout – in fact changing is recommended to suit circumstances
- No internal baggage. But can take time to get the internal perspective right
- External mentor has greater credibility as an independent advocate or champion for the mentee within and outside the business
- Can bring independent evaluation of progress and measures which is seen as more robust
- Works exclusively for the mentee and time is dedicated to that purpose without other conflicts
- High level of trust and engagement that facilitates good feedback on improvement
- Totally independent with perceived higher levels of trust, confidentiality and broader experience
- Experience is a wonderful thing.
- Experience allows us to recognise a mistake when we are about to make it again.
The content of ideas, concepts and experiences that make up this series of nine articles have been contributed from a number of sources and authors. Assembly by leading business-mentor, Michael Donovan, Managing Director, iMentor-pro 1300 720 190
Internal vs External Mentoring - To learn more about this author, visit Michael Donovan's Website.
Like this article? Share it with your friends
| |||
 |
No article feedback found. | ||
|
Leave Your Feedback | ||
|
|||
 100 Ways to Succeed #85
| |||
 R.O.C(I): "They" All Work For Me! |
|||
|
Internal vs External Mentoring
| |||
| So what are some of the differences? Here is a short list to think about. There are more and they are most often specific to the business environment. What are yours? |
|||
|
A Better Way to Implement Mentoring Programs
| |||
| Formal mentoring programs have become a staple in many organizations, but they often fall short because they tend to make employees feel awkward on both the mentor and mentee side of the relationship. This is not be... |
|||
|
Passing the Leadership Torch
| |||
| A corporate mentoring program is an effective part of succession planning: when employees feel good about what they are doing, when they are productive and satisfied with their positions they are in a better positio... |
|||
|
Running Helps Entrepreneurs Succeed
| |||
 Ah - two of my favorite topics - running and entrepreneurship. |
|||
| |||
Casey GollanCasey Gollan, Business Coaching & Mentoring Programs. Add $1 Million to $10 Million in the next 1 to 3 years. Since 1996 Casey has to added hundreds of millions of dollars to businesses. Watch a free video see client results Business Coaching website. - Visit Casey Gollan's Website |
|||
|
To learn more about the Evan Elite Author Program please contact us. | |||
 | |
 Michael Donovan (Visit Michael's Website) iMentor-pro is an alliance of former CEO’s, Senior Executives and Company Directors who have an interest in keeping fresh, involved and of assistance to others who are currently in the ‘hot seat’ as the leader, part of the leaders team / direct reports or in the line of succession within a business or a business unit. They will share their experience unreservedly toward your success and that of the business you lead. Led by Michael Donovan, former Asia-Pac CEO for global business-mentoring business Merryck & Co., the alliance offers its services individually or as a pool-of-talent to organisations like the Australian Institute of Company Directors to underpin the AICD, Coach and Mentor Connection, the Amazing Results CEO90DT, 120CEOP and ETBMP Programs. The alliance participants form a Guild of Mentors. Each have working portfolio interests and all are still actively involved in business either through their mentoring, directorships, advisory or other roles. Find out more about - iMentor-pro – International Mentor Professionals at www.imentor-pr o.com | iMentor-pro Values | iMentor-pro Services | iMentor-pro Guild of Mentors |
|  |
 |
|
|
 |
|
|
|
 |
| Modeling the Masters: Learn the true secrets behind Walt Disney's business success factors & grow your company! Video produced by Phanta Media |
|
|
 |
| Have you written articles that would be of value to entrepreneurs? Become an expert on our site by publishing them! Expose yourself to a wide audience, drive more traffic to your website and get more sales! Click Here for details. |
 |
 | ||
 |
||
|
||
 |
||
|
| ||
|
|
|
Get advice & tips from famous business owners, new articles by entrepreneur experts, my latest website updates, & special sneak peaks at what's to come!
|
|
|
 |
 Book of Leadership Breakdown, Breakthrough Setting Priorities Worksheet A Clean Desk Federal and State Laws |
|
 | ||
 |
Top 50 Franchising Blogs
Top 50 Franchising Blogs | |
 |
Top 50 Business Plans
Top Business Plan Blogs | |
| ||
 |
|
|
|
|
|||||||||||||||||||||
 |
|
|
||||||||||||
