Tweet

The Obama approach to change

Written by: Neil Crofts

Article Overview: We have a complex relationship with change. On the on the one hand we desperately want it, on the other we desperately resist it.

The Obama approach to change

We have a complex relationship with change.



On the on the one hand we desperately want it, on the other we desperately resist it.



If we want to motivate change in our organisations or in our society we need to look at it with an anthropologists eye. We need to understand what has shaped our attitudes to change.



For most of our evolutionary and historical past change was definitely regarded as a bad thing. Centuries passed where the life of the one generation was not significantly different from the previous one or the next one.



When change came it tended to be imposed from the outside and it tended to signify extreme danger, in the form of famine or war. For most people change only occurred when the risks of not changing were clearly greater than the risks of change.



From an evolutionary perspective we are also programmed to prefer more modest short term certainties over more generous longer term risks. Hence “A bird in the hand is worth two in the bush.”



We tend to be tolerant of significant discomfort, before we take the plunge and decide to make a change, even when the alternative is obviously and logically better. We will even defend a compromised system or situation simply because it is the one we are used to. As Morpheus said in the Matrix “These people are so hopelessly dependent on the system that they would fight to protect it.”



At an individual level most of us were educated primarily to be obedient. We were educated out of our creativity and our confidence and into conformity and doing what we are told. However it is not always obvious who, or what, we are being obedient to.



As a result of both our evolutionary and our cultural programming many of us prefer a seemingly safe, if slightly uncomfortable, predictable life to change.



There are also times when we embrace change. We marry, change jobs, have children, move house and even move country. In many cases these changes are inspired and positive changes towards a perceived, and sometimes even long term improvement.



Even these changes can be coerced, but in many cases they are associated with a feeling of empowerment. There are also, clearly changes most of us want: Most of us want to be paid more, to feel safer and so on.



From the anthropologists evidence we can see that there are two approaches to change.



1 - The Coercive Approach.



2 - The Empowered Approach.



The coercive approach assumes that someone knows the answer. It uses fear or force to motivate people to change.



The weakness of this approach is that the change is often grudging or poorly understood by many of the participants. The change is likely to be resisted and half hearted for many.



The empowered approach requires those who are driving the change to have the confidence to trust others to be able to understand the evidence and make the right decisions based on it.



The weakness of this approach is that the evidence can be manipulated and not everyone has the wisdom to make decisions in the best interests of all involved.



The reality is that whenever we are contemplating change, in our own lives, in our organisations or in society as a whole, we probably need to use a combination of coercion and empowerment to introduce effective change. The mix we need will depend more on the nature of the audience than our own preferences.



We can demonstrate that the change has positive results, at the same time we can show the negative effects of not changing.



We can engage in a co-creative process to determine the nature of the change and at the same time create penalties for failure to change.



Those who believe in authority (Spiral Dynamics Red and Blue) will respond better, on the whole, to the strength shown by the coercive approach - even if they don’t agree with it.



Those who believe in self determination (Spiral Dynamics Orange and Green) will respond better to empowerment and involvement.

Related Articles
  Change Management - Obama Style
  Barack Obama scores a marketing home-run on The Tonight Show
  Why is the President Obama using YouTube?
  The Value of Your Personal Brand
  What Every Manager Can Learn From Barack Obama

Article Tags: anthropologists, attitudes, centuries, letter spacing, organisations, relationship, span style



Related Forum Posts
Re: Obama or Mcain will not change anything - It is true neither Obama or Mcain will change anything but whoever wins the election can determine the way entreprenuers will operate. Every business prospers in an atmosphere that is condusive for business operation. This affect even internet business because as long as the prospective clients are affected by government policy will determine their purchasing powers. In my own view, Obama or Mcain might change things if their policies are very flexible for business operation.
Re: Obama or Mcain will not change anything - [quote="ideasuniversity":3lof0wbg]A lot of people are thinking that either Obama or Mcain will change things in America. Entrepreneur are to look inward and strategies on how to make their businesses to be successful. No ruler had ever change the way we grow our businesses. Their policies may try to delay us but we have way of scaling all the hurdles.[/quote:3lof0wbg] Oh, I don't know about that... If politicians start taxing the "achievers" so high that there is no longer any incentive to achieve... then we'll go the way of England or some other socialist country... From what I've read there's little to choose between Obama and McCain..though McCain is running on the Republican democrat his ideals are more on the Democrat side...
Obama or Mcain will not change anything - A lot of people are thinking that either Obama or Mcain will change things in America. Entrepreneur are to look inward and strategies on how to make their businesses to be successful. No ruler had ever change the way we grow our businesses. Their policies may try to delay us but we have way of scaling all the hurdles.
Re: HISTORY HAS BEEN MADE! - Obama made history as the first black president in America. This is the wind of change we are talking about.
Re: Obama or Mcain will not change anything - [quote="OmnivoreInk":1nr9f27v][quote="ideasuniversity":1nr9f27v]A lot of people are thinking that either Obama or Mcain will change things in America. Entrepreneur are to look inward and strategies on how to make their businesses to be successful. No ruler had ever change the way we grow our businesses. Their policies may try to delay us but we have way of scaling all the hurdles.[/quote:1nr9f27v] Oh, I don't know about that... If politicians start taxing the "achievers" so high that there is no longer any incentive to achieve... then we'll go the way of England or some other socialist country... From what I've read there's little to choose between Obama and McCain..though McCain is running on the Republican democrat his ideals are more on the Democrat side...[/quote:1nr9f27v] From the history of capitalism, they love rich people and achievers more than the poor. Rich people pay less tax than the poor, that is why they put their assets in trust


Share this article with your friends. Fund someone's dream.

Leave a comment below or share on the left and you'll help support entrepreneurs in Africa through our partnership with Kiva. Over $50,000 raised and counting - Please keep sharing! Learn more.

Tweet

Newsletter

Get advice & tips from famous business
owners, new articles by entrepreneur
experts, my latest website updates, &
special sneak peaks at what's to come!

Name:
Email:

Popular Articles

The new marketing question. Will they follow?

Unharnessing Creativity in Business

Effective Leadership

Suggestions

Email us your ideas on how to make our
website more valuable! Thank you Sharon
from Toronto Salsa Lessons / Classes for
your suggestions to make the newsletter
look like the website and profile younger
entrepreneurs like Jennifer Lopez.