Tweet

Budget Cuts: Why Fire Departments and Police Departments Need to Change the Question

Guest post by: Pat Lynch

Article Overview: Instead of focusing on money, politicians and administrators need to begin with the end in mind – i.e., the services to be provided.

Budget Cuts: Why Fire Departments and Police Departments Need to Change the Question

As city, county, and state budgets are being discussed and finalized around the country, one thing is clear: those who allocate resources are asking the wrong questions. As a result, recipients of government services are being short-changed because resources are being misallocated.

During city/county/state budget negotiations, the primary questions generally are:

1. How much must we cut so that our city/county/state has a balanced budget?

2. How much must each agency cut so we can achieve this outcome?

The problem is that these are the wrong questions. Instead of focusing on money, politicians and administrators need to begin with the end in mind – i.e., the services to be provided. Here are the questions they should be asking instead:

1. Is this service something that (city/county/state) government should provide?

(If it is not, stop it!)

2. If it is, what level of service do we (decision-makers) choose to provide?

3. What is the best way to provide this service?

4. How much are people willing to pay for it?

Using public safety (i.e., fire departments and police departments) as an example, here are the questions decision-makers should be asking:

1. Should the government provide public safety services?

2. What level of public safety do decision-makers choose to provide?

3. What is the best way to provide this service?

4. How much are people willing to pay for it?

When the conversation is all about cutting the budget, then guess what becomes the #1 priority? (You are correct if you said “cutting the budget.”) Focusing on cutting the budget can lead to dysfunctional behaviors (e.g., proportional sharing) and outcomes (e.g., ineffective resource allocation). As a result, the public loses. In terms of public safety, for example, there may be fewer fire fighters, emergency medical personnel, and police officers available to respond to calls. Fewer civilian staff as well as outdated equipment and infrastructure also are consequences of cuts to public safety budgets. Together these results mean longer response times in situations in which seconds or minutes matter. Are longer response times okay with the public? If so, then there’s no need to change the question. But if public safety has taken a hit because of misdirected questions and stakeholders are not okay with longer response times, then it’s time to insist that decision-makers stop asking and answering the wrong questions.

The bottom line: if you want different answers, you have to change the questions you ask. If the public is at greater risk due to budget cuts and the heads of fire departments and police departments are not okay with that, it’s time for them to re-direct the conversation by changing the questions. While re-focusing the discussion won’t change the reality of scarce resources, it can ensure a much more effective resource allocation process.

What are you waiting for?

Related Articles
  Cell phones...Conveniently dangerous
  Outsource your marketing to a “Virtual Marketing Department” and set your mind at ease
  Sharing best practices company-wide
  Employee Training: A Management Perspective
  If You Are A New Manager Make Sure You Copy This
  Are You Focusing on the Right Thing?
  When Is The Best Time Of Year To Apply For Government Grants and Loans?
  How public safety professionals are shooting themselves in the foot
  A Better Approach with Purchasing Departments
  Lean, Green Sales with the S.H.A.R.P. Sales TrainingTM System
  HR Departments: Making Structure Make Sense
  Your Buyer is Smarter than You
  Equipment and Lease Financing Considerations for Canadian Government Entities
  LEADERS HAVE BLOOD GROUP OF FIRE POSITIVE.
  Out with the old and in with the new…
  Marketing, sales and service silos why?
  How to Fix Problems With Your HRIS System
  How to Handle the Budget Objection
  Employee Efficiency in the 21st century: Collaborate to Compete
  LEADERS LIVE WITH BLOOD GROUP OF ” FIRE POSITIVE.”

Article Tags: budget, fire department, police department, public safety resource allocation, set priorities



Related Forum Posts
Re: Forum Upgrade - and Fire Fox for mac too
Re: Make Friends...Literally BUILD them! - yes, our technology is almost too convenient. I start to get frustrated if I know someone normally checks their email daily and I've asked them a question but they don't get back to me right a way. What a silly thing. 15 years ago I bought a bag phone at a Police auction and I thought I was really ahead of the times. Look how things have changed. LOL
Re: Does birth order influence the desire to start a business? - I am the eldest in a polygamous family. In Africa where I come from, we are allowed to marry many wives. My mother is the first wife among six others. I am the first born and I am into business and all my other 22 siblings are business people too apart from the second born who is in the Police Force.
Re: Dropped Out Of School To Startup! - First of all, you have great courage to assume this path in your young career. It's bold, it's tactful, it's passionate, and it's all about entrepreneurism. Good job! Keep it up and keep us abreast of your successes! I had a colleague drop out of college, and start a security firm. He hired directly from the Police Foundations program and built a company from the ground up. He now has over 50 employees and has a Hummer. I think he's doing successful!
Re: Does birth order influence the desire to start a business? - [quote="ideasuniversity":2rddqi21]I am the eldest in a polygamous family. In Africa where I come from, we are allowed to marry many wives. My mother is the first wife among six others. I am the first born and I am into business and all my other 22 siblings are business people too apart from the second born who is in the Police Force.[/quote:2rddqi21] Of your siblings - how many are girls and how many boys? Are girls allowed to be businesspeople, or must they stay at home?


Share this article with your friends. Fund someone's dream.

Leave a comment below or share on the left and you'll help support entrepreneurs in Africa through our partnership with Kiva. Over $50,000 raised and counting - Please keep sharing! Learn more.

Newsletter

Get advice & tips from famous business
owners, new articles by entrepreneur
experts, my latest website updates, &
special sneak peaks at what's to come!

Name:
Email:

Popular Articles

Counselling - Who Needs It?

Are You My Mentor

Angel Investors Where Are You?

Suggestions

Email us your ideas on how to make our
website more valuable! Thank you Sharon
from Toronto Salsa Lessons / Classes for
your suggestions to make the newsletter
look like the website and profile younger
entrepreneurs like Jennifer Lopez.