Tweet

Public Sector Pensions: Why “Fixing the Problem” IS the Problem

Guest post by: Pat Lynch

Article Overview: Dramatic increases in public sector pension liabilities at a time when state and local governments have seen their revenues shrink drastically have resulted in an explosive backlash against public sector unions and the workers they represent.

Public Sector Pensions: Why “Fixing the Problem” IS the Problem

Dramatic increases in public sector pension liabilities at a time when state and local governments have seen their revenues shrink drastically have resulted in an explosive backlash against public sector unions and the workers they represent. At the very time that high levels of unemployment increasingly have forced those who have lost their jobs to seek government services, they are being told that those services are being cut because of huge payments required to fund the pensions of public sector employees. This news has turned a spotlight on public sector pensions and served to demonize public sector employees.

Some states are taking advantage of this backlash to curtail or dismantle completely public sector workers’ collective bargaining processes. While discussing public sector pension reform efforts, the executive director of the California Labor Federation recently was quoted as accusing partisan lawmakers across the country of undertaking a “…strategy that goes beyond simply fixing the problems as we know them.” Presumably he wants them to stick to the pension funding issues and leave everything else alone – i.e., maintain the status quo.

Aspiring to the status quo is a big mistake. Simply “fixing” public pension systems is like treating the symptoms of a recurring illness and ignoring the underlying cause. While the symptoms may go away in the short-term, they will recur – often at a much more severe level. The cause itself must be addressed and a workable, long-term resolution achieved. There is overwhelming evidence that the status quo is not working any more. It’s time to stop merely “fixing” the problem and begin working toward eradicating its source.

Unfunded or under-funded pension liabilities in the millions and billions of dollars are grabbing headlines because they drastically reduce the amount of money available for state and local government services. As serious an issue as this is, in fact it is a symptom of a larger and more complex problem, namely the process by which public sector employees are compensated. That process is dysfunctional, which means that a continuation of the status quo is not sustainable.

There are many aspects of public sector compensation systems to consider, including what form the compensation takes (e.g., current vs. deferred salary, types and levels of benefits) and how pay is determined and changed. In unionized workplaces, these issues are addressed through a negotiation process. Bargaining often is conducted between elected officials and labor unions whose leaders provide substantial support in the form of money and campaign workers to labor-friendly candidates during elections. It seemed easy for lawmakers to agree to generous pensions and other terms of employment whose results wouldn’t be felt for years, or even decades – long after the elected officials had retired or (more likely in these days of term limits) moved on. How can that dynamic not influence the provisions of the resulting contracts? Who is looking out for the public in this process?

Providing short-term “solutions” to long-term problems has done a disservice to the public and to the workers who agreed to the employment conditions they were offered. Let’s not forget, however, that there are at least two parties to every contract, and that both must agree to its terms. Public sector unions did not impose their terms on elected officials; both sides were parties to the negotiated agreements. Unfortunately the public has been woefully uninformed about these issues. Yet whose fault is that? How many members of the public have taken the initiative to seek out that information?

In short, there is plenty of blame to go around. But playing the blame game is counterproductive because it doesn’t change anything. “Fixing” the problem with an eye on maintaining the status quo is not a viable option because it doesn’t address the underlying dysfunction. Instead, the focus must be on (a) what government services we as a society are willing to pay for, (b) compensating public sector employees fairly, (c) creating transparency and accountability in budget processes, and (d) implementing a plan that will enable us to achieve those objectives.

It’s time to stop “fixing” the problem by applying short-term “solutions” to long-term issues. We need to go well beyond the status quo, which is not functional or sustainable, to create a process that serves employees and the public well. What are we waiting for?

Related Articles
  The chicken and the egg
  Facing and addressing the challenges as an SME in Kenya
  What To Do When Public Relations Fails
  Problem Solving the Coaching Way
  Hands Off Management Frying Pan Fire or Neither
  Ethics is good business
  REVIVE AN ECONOMY… THE ANSWER LIES WITH THE PRIVATE SECTOR
  5.3.3 Women: Public sector training
  7.5.4 The role of public sector training institutions: Institutional design and capacity building
  Quiznos: What Went Wrong
  Appreciate Your Obstacles!
  Compelling Reasons for Your Salespeopole to Go Mobile
  THE WAY WE SEE THE PROBLEM IS THE PROBLEM
  Problem or Not the Problem?
  What is the best thing your customers can do for you?
  The ‘Don’t Bring Me Problems-Bring Me Solutions’ Brushoff
  Improving business conditions - Increasing SME Access to Finance: A Four Pronged Approach
  3.1.4 Overall resource availability: Training priorities, resources and reorientation
  The Problem is Not the Problem - Insurance Sales Training
  If your company has a supply chain project, who are the top 5 companies you would call?

Article Tags: budget cuts, city government, compensation, government agencies, pensions, public sector, state government



Related Forum Posts
What? - Problem fixed. Never mind!
Re: New web hosting site- would appreciate feedback - No Problem, I know im the new kid on the block, but i like to talk!!
How to get financed - We looked at doing the same thing. Problem is you own the truck out-rite, so most require a add on to your title or release of title to them for liability should you default. Contact Kevin at RV Lending, he assisted us with our stacker transporter, pretty easy to deal with and straight up with the answers before you give all you personal information. Good luck
Getting financed for conversion on an older truck - We looked at doing the same thing. Problem is you own the truck out-rite, so most require an add on to your title or release of title to them for liability should you default. Contact Kevin at RV Lending, he assisted us with our stacker transporter, pretty easy to deal with and straight up with the answers before you give all you personal information. Good luck
Re: LEADERS - Nice post, i like the Doers and the listeners comments from my handbook 8.5 HOW MUCH DO YOU KNOW ABOUT LEADERSHIP? Planning Problem Solving Vision Innovation Leadership Emotional Intelligence Delegation Communication Self-Development Relationship Building Commercial Financial skills Personal Energy Ethics Transparency Even there I see that we are missing "PASSION"


Share this article with your friends. Fund someone's dream.

Leave a comment below or share on the left and you'll help support entrepreneurs in Africa through our partnership with Kiva. Over $50,000 raised and counting - Please keep sharing! Learn more.

Newsletter

Get advice & tips from famous business
owners, new articles by entrepreneur
experts, my latest website updates, &
special sneak peaks at what's to come!

Name:
Email:

Popular Articles

When the Going Gets Tough, the Tough Log On

Living on The Edge of Chaos...

How To Calculate A Minimum Fee For Your Services

Suggestions

Email us your ideas on how to make our
website more valuable! Thank you Sharon
from Toronto Salsa Lessons / Classes for
your suggestions to make the newsletter
look like the website and profile younger
entrepreneurs like Jennifer Lopez.