Tweet

Leased or Fleeced - The Invisible Side of Leasing

Guest post by: Ty Bakti

Article Overview: The North American equipment leasing market exceeds $500 billion in annual sales. Canada contributes $60 billion of this rapidly expanding total. Hundreds of leasing transactions are finalized daily, featuring a multitude of rates, terms, conditions and transactional structures. Interestingly, in spite of the profound impact that such financing has, few managers fully understand all of the aspects and implications of a lease contract.

Leased or Fleeced - The Invisible Side of Leasing

The North American equipment leasing market exceeds $500 billion in annual sales. Canada contributes $60 billion of this rapidly expanding total. Hundreds of leasing transactions are finalized daily, featuring a multitude of rates, terms, conditions and transactional structures. Interestingly, in spite of the profound impact that such financing has, few managers fully understand all of the aspects and implications of a lease contract.

Consequently, thousands of dollars are lost or unnecessarily pass into the hands of lessors due to overpayments, missed cut-off dates, or incorrect tax classifications, to name a few. A lessor who does not fully disclose pertinent information, or manipulates a transaction, can do so with a high degree of skill. Takeovers or mergers encumber the acquiring party with predecessor lease contracts and in instances where downsizing or reengineering affects institutions or companies, it is much easier for items to "fall through the cracks."

The onus is on the lessee to represent its best interests in each lease contract, as it is the lessor's mandate to maximize profits. Lease agreements can be tricky, complex and difficult to understand, and allowing a lessor control of the contract virtually assures the lessee a less-than-optimum deal.

When it comes to today's lease consultants proposing opinions to lessees, it is significant to note that they are most likely biased in their advice, in that either the equipment vendor or leasing company remunerates them.

Just when you thought it was safe to go back into the water, the foregoing might lead you to conclude that there are sharks circling in the pool of lease finance. In fact, THE WALL STREET JOURNAL devoted a front-page article describing the unknown and hidden side of leasing. The story pointed out to the widespread jeopardy of leasing, and the fact that it was not just the little guy that was being bitten, but major U.S. and Canadian corporations too.

So, what's so complex about leasing? After all, the definition of leasing isn't so difficult: The lessor provides equipment for use by the lessee, while the lessee agrees to pay a specific series of payments over a set term. Lessees have two basic types of leases from which to choose: capital and operating. A capital lease (akin to a conditional sales contract) is when the lessee will own the equipment at the end of the term with the last payment or nominal payment (usually $1 or $10). An operating lease is signed when the equipment ownership issue is unclear, or if the lessee is intent on returning the equipment at the end of the lease term. In this case a future value ("residual") is structured into the contract. If ownership is unsure, or if the lessee considers upgrades prior to the end of lease term, an operating lease with a capped residual of a certain percentage of the equipment cost should be used.

In operating leases the fun begins where the residual is designated as "fair market value" (FMV). FMV is commonly taken to mean what a "willing buyer" would pay a "willing seller" in a normal market place. But in the world of leasing, without written evidence to the contrary, FMV means whatever the lessor wants it to mean. FMV could be "far more vague" than is in the lessee's best interests, and therefore the lessee now becomes "far more vulnerable."

Considering the multitude of delights upon which a leasing shark may feast, the FMV issue is probably number-one. Lessors grant themselves the opportunity to make up for the apparent low rates offered at the beginning with the FMV end of term buy-out.

If the residual is capped, there can be no dispute about the payment due at lease end. In this respect, the lessee may pay a slightly higher monthly rate, with the comfort of knowing that there will be no surprises at the end of the lease. Consider this example: leased equipment became integral to a client's operation, unlikely to be sent back following the last payment. The original purchase price of the equipment was $380,000. It was agreed that the funder was to receive four, annual payments in advance of $111,000, over a period of 48 months to a FMV end. The interest rate was quoted at 10.5%.

In a case where a capital or capped operating lease should have been written, the client was either led into an FMV lease or not given full disclosure of the end-of-term options available. At lease end, the lessor requested a FMV buy-out of $116,000, for which the lessee was duly and legally bound to pay if they wanted to keep the equipment. Had this payment been made in full, the interest rate for this lease would have more than doubled to approximately 23%!

In another FMV example, a company had leased $1.5 million worth of computer equipment, which it decided to keep nearing lease end. Over the phone, the vice-president of finance was told by the leasing company sales person that at the end of the lease the buy-out would cost up to about $200,000. But as the lease approached expiration, the leasing company pointed to language in the written contract saying the price had to be "mutually agreeable." Then the lessor issued an invoice agreeable to the leasing company for $500,000.

When cases like this go to court, the leasing company, supported by a written contract, invariably wins.

Unfortunately, stories of this nature are commonplace. So, in the face of all of this, what is a CFO, controller or purchasing manager supposed to do?

Related Articles
  Lease Equipment
  Medical Equipment Leasing Canada
  Advantages of Leasing Equipment, Cars and Machinery
  The Evolution of Equipment Financing and Leasing in Canada - an Overview
  Is a Leasing Company Your Best Choice For Business Equipment Financing – Choose Business Leasing That Makes Sense !

Article Tags:



Related Forum Posts
Re: Did you reach your goal this year? - I finally realized the subconcious mind achieves LARGE goals just as easily as small goals. All the RIGHT people are now showing up to manifest my BIG GOALS now. It's been interesting and worth sharing. [Side Note: Be prepared for them when they come. Some ppl think it's too good to be true.] Take it anyway....
Re: Men don't wear ties (necktie: US) like before! - Time and place. Some places of business really do require a tie. Depending on your business, you're often dressing for your client's comfort more than your own. When I meet with clients at a big corporate office downtown, I of course wear a suit. But when I meet clients in less formal settings, such as a restaurant in The East Village or Lower East Side (and I know my client is going to be wearing jeans), then I wear a stylish outfit that matches my environment, but is just slightly dressier than my surroundings. So I really dress for the setting I'll be in and also for my clients comfort. I noticed that when I started to wear dressier clothing, my clients actually matched me and upped the level of their own dress which I found interesting.
Re: Did you reach your goal this year? - I love the honesty in this thread. There is so much power in that! It's reassuring to remember that entrepreneurship is TOUGH. But I find that very motivating. But to know that we all CAN do it, if we only stay the course. Sometimes I can compare myself with the worlds most famous whoever, and then feel discouraged. But that's not really realistic now is it? I've had a lot of ups and downs since I moved to Manhattan 3 years ago, and last year was no exception. I've been really surprised by some happy developments though -- just when you think everything is going to fail, something good happens! Last year, I'm most proud of being invited to speak at 3 different events, getting 6 new clients, and having a magazine article published about my coaching. A few years ago I never would have thought I could do any of that -- I had some really frustrating times where I was seeming to get nowhere. So for me, dealing w/ disappointment,frustration, and having realistic expectations has improved over the last 5 years, and now it's helped me to become a better coach for others going through the same thing. I really do understand what it's like to move to NYC alone w/ a suitcase, not have an apartment,and meanwhile try to start a business w/o support. It was sort of a right of passage for me. Side note story, but sort of represents some of the feelings I'm talking about here -- I used to make paintings. I'd sell them online. I made one called "idealism" which was basically showing how there is no place for idealism, art, or new ideas is a society of grids and stop lights and cubicles. It was an extremely low time for me, and I wanted to take all of my paintings to the dumpster -- I almost did! My mom called me and insisted that I not throw them out. Within a month, a stranger in NYC (I was still in AZ at the time), bought my idealism painting. This buyer must have felt the same way I did, and that alone proved to me that there WAS a place for what I had to offer in the world -- even if I couldn't see it at the time. I then moved to NYC where there was much more of a place for what I had to offer. Moments like that drive me forward, past whatever doesn't seem to be working.
Different Types of Funding - Finance for business can be obtained through a number of different sources. Let's review some of those channels to help you decide what's right for your business needs: Grants There are over 930 different EU and UK grants and loans available from over 100 issuing bodies. This is the cheapest form of finance and an important part of the funding package that companies and individuals need. We can help you find your way through this maze. Technology Micro Projects: 50% of eligible costs up to £20,000 Research project: For a technical and feasibility study of an innovative idea for new technology 60% of costs up to a grant of £75,000. Development project: For development up to pre production 35% of costs up to a grant of £200,000 Developing an innovative idea: valuable for small companies and individuals at the start of a technical project: 75% of costs of hiring a mentor and consultants. Export To start exporting or moving into new markets grants of 50% of costs up to £20,000 each. Training and Education Knowledge Transfer Partnerships, Achieving Best Practice in Your Business, Investors in People Modern Apprenticeships New Deal for various grants. Environment BOC Foundation for the Environment: 25% to 50% of Project cost, typically £20,000 to £100,000 Clean up Fund: Emission reducing equipment up to 75% of cost Community Chest Fund: Up to £25,000 for projects near active SITA sites High Impact Fund: £150,000+ for larger projects near SITA sites Assisted Areas Regional assistance grants of between 10 and 35% for capital expenditure in less favoured areas of the UK. Loans Loans are an excellent source of finance if you have suitable security to borrow against or a reliable earnings stream. This needs to be planned and presented well to obtain funds. Credit cards Provides up to 56 days free credit if you play the game! Overdraft Banks are surprisingly supportive when presented with a well thought through plan and competent management. Bank Loans Lenders tend to look for a good business plan and security. Typically the loan is approved by a centralised back office function rather than the person you meet. Terms and rates depend upon the risk. Repayments can be very flexible to meet your specific needs. Mortgages These can include flexible repayment terms to meet your business needs. This can even be incorporated into your overdraft finance so that you have one flexible account for both personal/ business mortgages and overdraft Small Firms Loan Guarantee Scheme Up to two years trading: Up to £100,000 Over two years trading: Up to £250,000 However these are difficult to obtain and are a loan of last resort. Export Guarantee Scheme This is government backed insurance against appropriate export documentation. Mezzanine This is a halfway house between loan and equity. It can be an innovative way of raising funds for the more established business. Mostly for expansion capital. Equity This is not as easy as the papers would have you know. Only 1% of business plans received by Venture Capital Funds are successful. However, a good business proposition consisting of a strong demand for the product or service, management track record and a sound financial plan will enhance the chance of success. Business Angels These are high net worth individuals who are successful businessmen looking for investment opportunities. They can provide both time expertise and money. Typical investment size is £25,000 to £250,000 but can go as high as £2m for the right opportunity. Exit within 3-5 years. Venture Capital These are investment funds seeking high rates of return. However typically investments are over a million pounds. Some funds are targeted at lower amounts depending upon the sector and region. These funds are looking for exponential capital growth over 3-5 years. Asset backed finance This can cover machinery, sales invoices even sales orders. It can be a very flexible source of finance to the growing business Leasing This will cover your capital expenditure and spread the cost over a three to five year period. It is particularly useful if you do not have taxable profits to maximise your capital allowances. Sale and leaseback of a property you own is another good source of funds. Factoring Factoring offers a sales ledger administration and debt collection service. Up to 95% of an approved sales invoice is paid within 48 hours, quicker if required. Credit protection is also available to protect against a bad debt. The Factor will own and place a first charge over the book debts and they might also take other charges, depending upon the strength of the financial information. Invoice discounting Invoice Discounting can be Confidential or Disclosed; it depends upon the strength of the financial information. The service is the same as Factoring, except that the sales ledger administration and the debt collection is the responsibility of the client and not the Factor. Pre payment of the approved sales invoice is still up to 95% and the factor will still have a first charge on the book debt and therefore own the debt. This service can also have credit protection cover. All sales invoices need to be for a business to business debt, and some proof of delivery is generally required. Trade Finance This is funding provided against stock purchases, signed contracts and orders whereby the funder will prepay a certain percentage of the value Pension fund It may be possible to use your pension funds for a loan back to the business What do u think about it?
Ladies Who Launch Profile: Heidi Flammang - Heidi Flammang Top Dog, Camp Bow Wow When one of the country's first doggy day cares opened next door to her dad's business, Heidi Flammang and her husband, Bion, would sneak over to hang out with the dogs. They fell in love with the concept—and the dogs—and were soon making trades of services with the owner to have their own dogs stay there. When the owner of that business wasn't interested in franchising, Heidi and her husband started brainstorming and the business plan for Camp Bow Wow was born. They were searching for their first location when Bion was killed in a plane crash, in 1994. Heidi received a $1 million insurance settlement after his death, and in the following years attempted a number of ventures, including a financial consulting business to help others handle sudden wealth. But Camp Bow Wow was never far from her mind. In 2000, with the help and encouragement of her brother, she dusted off that old business plan and set out to bring her and Bion's dream to life. Within weeks she had found her first location, and from that point on she never looked back. Camp Bow Wow has now sold more than 205 franchises, 125 of which will be open by the end of the year. It is the premier upscale doggy day care and boarding company, and is expected to generate $18 million in systemwide sales in 2008. What we learned from Heidi: To persevere and never lose sight of your dreams. Heidi was a young widow who tried financial consulting, pharmaceutical sales, and launching a high-end baby-bedding catalog before coming full circle to find success with the idea that she'd loved all along. Not Just Fun and Games "A lot of people come into this business thinking how fun it's going to be to hang out with dogs all day. But we are taking care of people's furry children, all day and night, 365 days a year! It is an all-consuming business and you have to know so much more than people think—everything from dog behavior to disease management, in addition to the nuts and bolts of running a business. We get franchisees from so many different backgrounds and they all have a love of dogs in common, but we have to teach them to be businesspeople and to market the business and not just focus on the dogs. It's a challenge to find people who want to make it a real moneymaker and not just a labor of love." Getting the Word Out "We receive a lot of leads on possible new franchisees through word of mouth from our existing franchisees and open Camps. Also, we've been featured on AOL's main page, Donny Deutsch's The Big Idea, in Pink magazine, and in some other great media outlets, and we advertise in the airline magazines and do quite a bit on the Internet, utilizing our Web site as a marketing tool. All of these have been great resources." What Worked "What has worked for us is to stay focused on our brand and what it's about: offering a place where a dog can be a dog. We don't let ourselves get distracted by other business opportunities that come in our direction, and we don't try to be everything to every dog owner. I am a perfectionist and have been very specific about what the rules are and what the brand is, and that really led the way for franchising opportunities. But we are constantly evolving based on the learning experiences and opinions of our franchisees, and I think that helps us stay ahead of the competition." And What Didn't "Be wary of getting family and friends involved and assuming that because they have good hearts and are interested in your business that they'll have the skills to do it. It's important to be surrounded by knowledgeable people who have great skills, not just people who love you." Networking Is Not Just For the Dogs "People in the dog-boarding business are very protective, so it's not as easy to network and meet people with like businesses as it might be in other industries. I found great mentors at the International Franchise Association, other people who had been there and done that in terms of franchising. I'm very involved with that group and work to champion other women entrepreneurs. I'm also part of a CEO support group called Vistage. There are 12 of us in the group who meet for a day once a month and it's extremely valuable, but I am the only woman in the group. So I also have an informal group of women who I meet with in Denver to share professional successes and disasters. Women are just so much more open to that type of dialogue." Like Mother, Like Daughter "I'm writing a book about starting and running a successful woman-owned business called Tales From the Bark Side. My tween-aged daughter is writing her own book that will be released at the same time called Tori's Tales, about growing up with a mom who's an entrepreneur. My pet project is working with young girls to help them set goals and develop self-confidence and pride in their accomplishments." Man's Best Friend "Last year we started Bow Wow Buddies, a foundation dedicated to improving the lives and health of dogs around the world. We foster dogs, we sponsor a PhD fellow in canine cancer research at CSU veterinary school, and we fund organizations such as RAVS and VIDAS that go into poor areas in the U.S. and elsewhere to spay and neuter stray dogs. We undertook a rescue mission abroad after our in-house counsel vacationed in Greece, a country with no humane society, and saw how poorly strays were treated there. We brought 17 dogs back with us and fostered them until finding them homes." Favorite Quote "'Worry is a debt you may never have to pay.' I really strive to live in the now, focus on solutions that are in the moment, and not worry too much about things that may never happen." Recommended Reading "My favorite dog book is Marley & Me. But I have two business books that I find invaluable: The E Myth Revisited (a fantastic book to help you figure out whether you have the right personality and skill mix to be an entrepreneur) and The Question Behind the Question (a great management book about instilling personal accountability in your people)." Parting Thoughts ... "I will retire when ... every dog has a home." "My greatest strength in business is ... my flexibility." "My dream is ... to give back as much as I get from my life. I have been so blessed with so many things and I want to respect the universe and give back." This featured lady was profiled by Noelle Pechar Hale, a freelance writer living in Los Angeles.


Share this article with your friends. Fund someone's dream.

Leave a comment below or share on the left and you'll help support entrepreneurs in Africa through our partnership with Kiva. Over $50,000 raised and counting - Please keep sharing! Learn more.

Tweet

Newsletter

Get advice & tips from famous business
owners, new articles by entrepreneur
experts, my latest website updates, &
special sneak peaks at what's to come!

Name:
Email:

Popular Articles

Do You Pretend To Listen To People?

Work at home Opportunities for the Disabled

What If You Had a 100% Success Rate?

Suggestions

Email us your ideas on how to make our
website more valuable! Thank you Sharon
from Toronto Salsa Lessons / Classes for
your suggestions to make the newsletter
look like the website and profile younger
entrepreneurs like Jennifer Lopez.