Tweet

The $8 billion story/scam

Written by: Seth Godin

Article Overview: In case you had any doubt that human beings are irrational creatures, driven by stories, consider the case of the gift card.

The $8 billion story/scam

In case you had any doubt that human beings are irrational creatures, driven by stories, consider the case of the gift card.

Christmas has become a holiday about shopping, not about giving. Case in point: the $100 gift card, now available from banks, from stores, even in a rack at the supermarket.

Last year, more than $8,000,000,000 was wasted on these cards. Not in the value spent, but in fees and breakage. When you give a card, if it doesn't get used, someone ends up keeping your money, and it's not the recipient. People spent more than eight billion dollars for nothing... buying a product that isn't as good as cash.

Along the way, we bought the story that giving someone a hundred dollar bill as a gift ("go buy what you want") is callous, insensitive, a crass shortcut. Buying them a $100 Best Buy card, on the other hand, is thoughtful. Even if they spend $92 and have to waste the rest.

The interesting thing about stories is that the inconsistent ones don't always hold up to scrutiny. Consumer Reports and others are trying to spread a different story. One that sounds like this:

Gift cards are for chumps.

If enough people talk about this new story, people will be embarrassed to give a gift card. It's a waste. It's a scam. It's a trap for the recipient.

The irony is that the gift card companies could easily spend, say, half the profits and create a wonderful, better story... where every $100 gift card also generates two or three dollars for a worthy cause. That would resonate with a lot of people... But I think it's unlikely.

If I were a creative non-profit, I'd start marketing alternative gift cards. They would consist of PDF files you could print out and hand over to people when you give them cash. It could say,

"Merry Christmas. Here's your present, go spend it on what you really want. AND, just to make sure we're in the right holiday spirit, I made a donation in your name to Aworthycause."

Stories come and go. It's up to marketers to spread the good ones.

Related Articles
  Google US Search Share Reaches 63.2% in May 2009
  Export Subsidies by Developed Countries: Barriers to African External Trade
  Thai store chain CP All Q4 net profit more than doubles
  Booming IT Spending in Middle East & Africa
  Is Profit the Sustainable Goal?

Article Tags: best buy, billion dollars, case in point, chumps, consumer reports, different story, dollar bill, gift card, gift cards, holiday spirit, human beings, irony, keeping your money, marketers, merry christmas, pdf files, scrutiny, start marketing, three dollars, worthy cause



Related Forum Posts
Re: Is Twitter really worth $1 Billion? - Twitter is simply worth what someone will pay for it. Youtube sold for about 1.7 billion (Google recently admitted they paid too much) and that was when the economic outlook was a lot better, and YouTube was way more established and had many more users. Twitter at $1 billion is over valued in my opinion, but it just depends on what someone else will pay and what it is worth to them
Re: Billion Dollar Business - [quote="mphcoach":2ce34yto]How do you create a billion dollar business? Spend two billion on an airline - boom, boom! [/quote:2ce34yto] It's interesting how the government - of any country - can make or break businesses. I'm not an expert on the airline business, but wasn't it deregulation in the 70s that put the kibosh on everything? Although I think things weren't too bad, until after 9/11, and then they started hiring more security and not hiring more air traffic controllers --with just as much efficiency as you might expect from a government-run program, and things have been going down hill ever since.
Re: Marketing to Wealthy Consumers - [quote:30rrziaf]In addition, have you considered creating custom rugs/mats for dogs and cats? T[/quote:30rrziaf] Yes we have. The custom side of the market is untapped... and very large. We've set aside time to focus on a few markets for the time being. Here's a short list of the bigger markets from a report that I've made available on our training site. Most of these markets are still growing... $29 billion annual - Pet themed products - includes custom pet mats, rugs etc... $30 billion annual - Auto aftermarket: includes custom floormats $23 billion annual - Boating - includes custom yachts etc... $12 billion annual - Motorcoaches - includes custom touring coaches, RV's etc.. Our research shows that more and more people are interested in a personalized product experience. This is reflected in websites like Amazon.com, and the social marketing sites. The more sophisticated companies know that tailoring your marketing message to 'individuals' is more effective. It's pretty clear that we're entering an age of personalizing products... this is especially true for the wealthy consumers, which is why I'm always looking for new ways of making those connections: [i:30rrziaf]as cheaply as possible![/i:30rrziaf] [quote:30rrziaf]A carmat tailored to someone's logo or whatever would be a great Prize here....[/quote:30rrziaf] The challenge, and this is true for all of these markets, is that an infrastructure needs to be developed, this takes time and money. Every car is different, each floormat is a different size, templates need to be made etc... I suppose a template making kit could be made and FedExed to the winner, then returned for manufacturing. Most of our custom logo flooormats are $300-400 price range - not sure if it's too expensive for a freebie? If we came up with a generic shape and design concept, that could bring our costs down.
New Squiddledee Prizes!! - I think I like the shark tie...It would sure be cool for someone in the big corporate world..letting everyone know you're really a shark! You know- for the guys or gals who digest multi-billion dollar deals for breakfast! Nana- I doubt i could ever get my husband to wear oe either...but I agree with you- I would! LOL
Women Entrepreneur - Female entrepreneurs are all over nowadays. Not just in high-visibility positions such as CEO of a multi-billion dollar corporation, but also behind the scenes in support posts. I read a few profiles of success stories on Young Entrepreneur and was actually impressed by Kristy Taylor and Paula Yakubic. Their entrepreneurial sense and dedication are paying off quite well now.


Share this article with your friends. Fund someone's dream.

Leave a comment below or share on the left and you'll help support entrepreneurs in Africa through our partnership with Kiva. Over $50,000 raised and counting - Please keep sharing! Learn more.

Tweet

Newsletter

Get advice & tips from famous business
owners, new articles by entrepreneur
experts, my latest website updates, &
special sneak peaks at what's to come!

Name:
Email:

Popular Articles

Ways to Improve Your Landing Page Conversions

Looking for an Easy Online Business Opportunity?

Local Marketing: 3 Simple Low-Cost Strategies

Suggestions

Email us your ideas on how to make our
website more valuable! Thank you Sharon
from Toronto Salsa Lessons / Classes for
your suggestions to make the newsletter
look like the website and profile younger
entrepreneurs like Jennifer Lopez.