Tweet

Giving Up Salary for Equity After VC Funding

Written by: Brad Feld

Article Overview: I got a great question the other day which highlights the tension that can emerge in an early stage company between VCs and entrepreneurs.

Giving Up Salary for Equity After VC Funding

I got a great question the other day which highlights the tension that can emerge in an early stage company between VCs and entrepreneurs.

Company X - which is VC backed – has six months of cash in the bank. Almost every employee could go without a paycheck. The team is on full pay now – it’s a small team of under 10. Not taking salaries buys the company another six months. There is a major launch in about four months.

An option the team is discussing is that if the current investors won’t throw in another million now so they have room to raise money after the results of the launch, they will "self finance" the company by everyone cutting pay if the investors issue a significant additional chunk in common to the employees

What are the issues for the team in doing something like this have you seen it, when not in a "difficult" situation?

While there is no tension yet, here’s a negative view of how this could play out. The entrepreneurs ask the VCs to put up money – presumably at a certain price – in exchange for buying another six months of runway. The VCs don’t like the price the entrepreneurs suggestion (presumably it’s too high) and offer to do a bridge loan with warrant coverage or an equity round at a lower price. The entrepreneurs don’t like this, so they tell the VCs they’d rather go without salary for six months and get stock equivalent to what the VCs would have gotten (at the lower price of course) for their investment. The VCs don’t like this because (a) they aren’t getting money to work, (b) they are ending up with less, not more of the company, and (c) they potentially lose some of the control over the financing dynamics. After much handwringing (and wasted time), everyone comes to an agreement on the amount of stock the entrepreneurs and staff get for going without salary for the next six months.

Wind the clock forward. The entrepreneurs have an “ok” launch, but the valuation for the new round is lower than they expected or there is no outside lead and the VCs start talking about an inside round. The VCs have no incentive to get the valuation up in this case - they are focused on buying up more ownership, so they’d rather have a lower valuation anyway. The entrepreneurs are pissed because they just gave up salaries for six months but didn’t end up in the “better” position they wanted. The VCs aren’t appropriately sympathetic (at least in the entrepreneurs mind) to the situation – the entrepreneurs just made an investment they aren’t getting credit for.

Tension mounts. No one is happy.

While it’s a logical trade, it’s an uncertain one for the entrepreneur because there is no way to predict whether or not the launch will be successful, so fundamentally the entrepreneur is buying more runway, but not necessarily for the exchange of more ownership. Of course, in the positive situation (where the launch goes great and new investors show up willing to invest at meaningfully higher prices) this could work out nicely.

Read this article on Brad's blog.

Related Articles
  Part 7: Funding Request
  UK Business Finance - The Options Available To You
  My sales director wants equity - should I give it to them?
  Surviving Tight Credit Creative Financing
  Franchise Funding and Financing Options for Franchisees In Canada

Article Tags: bridge loan, chunk, clock, four months, getting money, investors, launch, paycheck, salaries, salary, six months, stage company, stock, suggestion, tension, vcs, warrant



Related Forum Posts
Why pay a Consultant? - Consultants can bring you into contact with a Funding Source but how do you tell whether a consultant will be successful beforehand? Professional Consultants ALWAYS ask for some kind of retainer so that they can feel they're not being used by a 'chancer'. However, when raising funding, a real consultant will offer to REFUND THAT RETAINER out of the % BROKERAGE he charges, payable once he finds your Funding Source, and payable from initial disbursements. Retainers only cover part of the costs that a consultant has to pay while working on behalf of the Client. Their real wages come from the agreed upon Brokerage, received when they are successful on the Client's behalf.
Lisa Shepherd Story - Great story! I love the Earn - Learn - Equity - it's very relavent for new entrepreneurs.
Different types of funding - Business Relationship Funding This is another source of funds that can be overlooked. It may be possible to introduce potential alliances to add value to both parties. It may produce an ultimate exit route in the medium to long term. Joint Ventures: Requires a legal agreement embodying the deal and another company Partnerships: Two companies collaborate with possible funding. Joint working relationships: These are an informal partnership which may be more project specific where the parties can share resources. Agencies: These can be geographical or product specific and generally incorporates a payment for the right to the agency. Distributors: Very like an agency but may not necessarily involve up front payment. Alliances: These do not require a separate company and can be embodied by a legal agreement to work together. Trade investors: Otherwise known as Corporate Partnering. This can be a good way to involve a much larger company in the business with a view to possible trade sale further down the line. Associates: This can be a loose arrangement with no fundamental commitments either way, rather like a preferred supplier. Equity Swop: Two companies exchange shares to a similar value to develop both businesses. Franchises: This can allow the business to grow without further direct investment. Licensing: This involves licensing a product or service to enable others to sell it. This requires you to own the intellectual property.
Home Equity to Finance your business - Jen, do you have Home Equity you can leverage? Maybe a relative or close family member can do it for you in return for an interest "balloon payment" at the end of 5 years (the rate would be above what they would get if they invested it in a GIC).
Re: Quick Ways To Utilize SEO Effectively - 1. If you dont want too much competition from other SEO's, choose your keywords precisely.For example, Instead of keyword Loan choose keywords like Bank Loan, Equity Loan, Student Loan, Home Loan etc. Order of keyword also matter for search engines. Search engine treats ?Loan Equity? and ?Equity Loan? as different keywords. 2. Best seo practice is to get at least one of your primary keywords in domain or sub domain name of your website. You can use hyphens (-) to separate multiple keywords. For example: seo-service, seo-guidelines, free-seo each cover two keywords. 3. Get your second or third keywords in your directory name and filename. 4. Keep your webpage free from any syntax error, declare document type at the beginning and validate your HTML and CSS because search engine don?t like pages with too many errors. 5. Give a short Title in of your page in 3-9 words (60-80 characters) maximum in length containing your primary keyword. Remember it will be displayed in search results so choose wisely. 6. Try to include your most important keyword phrases in heading tags on your page if you can but keep in mind it should not be exactly same as title of your page. You can use (H1 H2 H3) tag for specifying anything important. To reduce size of heading use CSS. 7. Specify Meta keywords in heading of document. Limit it to 15 to 20 words. Although not all the search engines give importance but there is no harm doing it. Search engine like Yahoo still give it importance. 8. Write Your Meta Description tag attractive containing keywords because it will appear on the search engine result pages. 9. Use text for navigation menu instead of using images or Java scripts. 10. Try to include your most important keyword in hyper linked text and text and text that immediately precedes or follows the hyperlink. Do not use same keyword always use synonyms at few places. Just like instead of seo, I have use search engine optimization at many places on this page.


Share this article with your friends. Fund someone's dream.

Leave a comment below or share on the left and you'll help support entrepreneurs in Africa through our partnership with Kiva. Over $50,000 raised and counting - Please keep sharing! Learn more.

Tweet

Newsletter

Get advice & tips from famous business
owners, new articles by entrepreneur
experts, my latest website updates, &
special sneak peaks at what's to come!

Name:
Email:

Popular Articles

Using Social Media Marketing

Adapting to Technology and the Internet

Unspoken Yet Important Rules for Book Proposals

Suggestions

Email us your ideas on how to make our
website more valuable! Thank you Sharon
from Toronto Salsa Lessons / Classes for
your suggestions to make the newsletter
look like the website and profile younger
entrepreneurs like Jennifer Lopez.