Tweet

Hedge Fund Job: Must Understand Benford's Law

Written by: Paul Kedrosky

Article Overview: The folks over at Valleywag are having fun with a Craigslist posting for a hedge fund job. In addition to looking for someone with all the typical quant skills, the ad asks applicants to do the following

Hedge Fund Job: Must Understand Benford's Law

Another guest post

The folks over at Valleywag are having fun with a Craigslist posting for a hedge fund job. In addition to looking for someone with all the typical quant skills, the ad asks applicants to do the following

1) Prepare a cover letter.
2) Flip a coin 50 times. Record the results on your resume as a sequence of heads (H) or tails (T) symbols.
3) Email your cover letter and resume to us.

Speculation abounds as to what the fund is getting at, but a few commenters suspect it's some sort of honesty test. The idea is that when people try to manufacture randomness on their own, they usually do a bad job. For example, a 25/25 split of heads/tails would be a dead giveaway that the applicant didn't to the assignment. The are other tells too that you could come up with.

An old NYT article explains what's going on, and how it relates to Benford's Law:

Dr. Theodore P. Hill asks his mathematics students at the Georgia Institute of Technology to go home and either flip a coin 200 times and record the results, or merely pretend to flip a coin and fake 200 results. The following day he runs his eye over the homework data, and to the students' amazement, he easily fingers nearly all those who faked their tosses.

"The truth is," he said in an interview, "most people don't know the real odds of such an exercise, so they can't fake data convincingly."

There is more to this than a classroom trick.

Dr. Hill is one of a growing number of statisticians, accountants and mathematicians who are convinced that an astonishing mathematical theorem known as Benford's Law is a powerful and relatively simple tool for pointing suspicion at frauds, embezzlers, tax evaders, sloppy accountants and even computer bugs.

Then again, maybe they're getting at something totally different. Any guesses?

Joseph Weisenthal is the proprietor of The Stalwart and a reporter at paidContent.org. You can email him at jnathan -at- gmail -dot- com or follow him on Twitter here.

Related Articles
  Peter Bernstein on Amaranth: Better to be Wrong Than Too Right
  Repeat!
  Brokers, Dealers, Private Lenders, and Venture Capital
  Financial Regulation: Necessary Evil or Evil Necessarily?
  Investing In A Weak Dollar

Article Tags: any guesses, commenters, computer bugs, craigslist, dead giveaway, fund job, georgia institute of technology, hedge fund, homework data, honesty test, mathematical theorem, mathematicians, mathematics students, nyt, nyt article, p hill, randomness, statisticians, tax evaders, weisenthal



Related Forum Posts
Should FDIC Worry about FHLB? - What do you think the impact would be on the Bank Insurance Fund with Federal Home Loan Advances for business? Especially since you can obtain a grant when used in combination with FHLB advance. The grant can be used for anything you want for your business (down payment to a seller or franchise fees, working capital...etc.) This puts the borrower in a pretty good position. Should FDIC worry about FHLB?
Re: Should FDIC Worry about FHLB? - [quote="BizLoanz4u":3cde91n6]What do you think the impact would be on the Bank Insurance Fund with Federal Home Loan Advances for business? Especially since you can obtain a grant when used in combination with FHLB advance. The grant can be used for anything you want for your business (down payment to a seller or franchise fees, working capital...etc.) This puts the borrower in a pretty good position. Should FDIC worry about FHLB?[/quote:3cde91n6] Hi Michele, Could you first tell us a little more detail about both organizations?
Re: Success - I study success intently, and would like to share: Here's two excellent and nearly identical success-formulas from a couple of the world's masters. FIRST FORMULA: 1. Passionate Desire 2. Clear, Definite Purpose 3. Committed Decision 4. Take Action In Faith (Bonus Secret Sauce: 5. Repeat Consistently) I made a video about this, but am not allowed to link it yet. Google "Ryze Success Steps" for it. Oh, and this is Napoleon Hill's (Master Of Success Laws)'s Formula. SECOND FORMULA: 1. Passionate Desire 2. Understand It Is Already Done (Faith) 3. Relax & Allow It To Unfold (Go about your life calmly) This one is courtesy of Abraham-Hicks (inspiration for the movie The Secret). Hope that helps!
Risky business? - I follow the rule that you should never do business with friends or family (aside from business, I never borrow from them on a personal level either). It's nice that your friend offered without being asked, and i'm sure he thinks your idea is a really good one or he wouldn't have made that type of offer (to risk money) just out of friendship. I'm sure if he didn't think it woould fly, he wouldnt have made the offer. It's a matter of personal preference whether you want to have a friend (or family memember) be your Angel investor. You both need to understand the risks involved and discuss the "what if's" beforehand....What if it doesn't work out? Does he lose his initial investment? Should you try to pay him back if the business fails, when he offered to take the risk and you didn't ask? These are things that should be discussed and even though you are friends, you should have a lawyer draw up an investment or partnership agreement. Understand it's a business venture and the friendship should have nothing to do with it.
Re: Sales Letters: Do they work? - Sales letters are a unique and very beneficial element to almost any businesses marketing and sales letters, if done professionally and ethically. According to Rudyard Kipling, 'words are the most powerful drug we humans can deliver' the reason these letters and sites work, and they do, trust me, is people they are targeted to a very specific type of person/demographic. The more you understand your market, the better you can write your sales letters and collateral material. Every form of communication essentially uses this format, identify the pain propose a solution offer proof - through testimonials outline the benefits make an offer they cant refuse etc etc if your radar flags when you read some one else's letter, that only speaks to your own integrity and how you want to be seen. In fact, some of the best sales letters every written have been for World Wildlife Fund, Foster Parents Plan, Canadian Cancer Society etc. The difference is that now mainstream businesses and especially information marketers are using these tactics. Personally the formula is used all the time in every successful campaign - you only need to decide what you are comfortable with. As far as one of the links Shri provided, I'm very familiar with his work and quite frankly wouldnt bother recommending it.... But to sum up - sales letters are an old and traditional way of motivating someone to buy - right now. dont knock it - if you aint tried it. But make sure you are 100% acting in integrity and within the comfort level of your audience. Jude


Share this article with your friends. Fund someone's dream.

Leave a comment below or share on the left and you'll help support entrepreneurs in Africa through our partnership with Kiva. Over $50,000 raised and counting - Please keep sharing! Learn more.

Tweet

Newsletter

Get advice & tips from famous business
owners, new articles by entrepreneur
experts, my latest website updates, &
special sneak peaks at what's to come!

Name:
Email:

Popular Articles

Email Marketing Made Easy #11 - Avoiding Spam

9 Steps to Improve Performance

A Guide to Franchise Financing

Suggestions

Email us your ideas on how to make our
website more valuable! Thank you Sharon
from Toronto Salsa Lessons / Classes for
your suggestions to make the newsletter
look like the website and profile younger
entrepreneurs like Jennifer Lopez.