Tweet

Annual Franchise Legal Update

Written by: Marcus Hunt

Article Overview: In our courtrooms last year we saw a multitude of decisions that reflect the state of our economy - "Uncertain".

Annual Franchise Legal Update

In our courtrooms last year we saw a multitude of decisions that reflect the state of our economy - "Uncertainty". 1. Taxation

Perhaps the biggest uncertainty franchisors face today is their growing exposure to state taxes as states struggle to find new sources to replace lost revenue. Franchisors are being exposed to more and more states which are re-defining "Nexus" to by-pass the old requirement that franchisors had to have a physical presence in a state to be subject to the state tax laws. The most dramatic change last year occurred in New York, requiring franchisors to act as tax auditors for their New York franchisees (New York Tax Law, § 1136 (i) (1) (B) Subpart G, Part V-1 of Chapter 57, L. 2009). California has also joined the state tax feast and recently mandated that all franchisees "withhold" if their franchisors do not file.

In Surters v. Ventures, Inc., 8 So. 3d 950 (Ala. Civ. App.), aff'd, 8 So. 3d 983 (Ala 2008), cert denied, 129 S. Ct. 2051 (2009) the Court of Civil Appeals upheld the Alabama Department of Revenue's assessment that royalty payments had to be added back to the taxpayer's income under Alabama's version of an add-back state. See also Decision Nos. 506 - 544N & 06 - 545 FN, West Virginia Office of Tax Appeals, January 6, 2010.

2. Disclosure

In the matter of the California Corporations Commissioner v. Play N Trade Franchise, Inc., No's. 99 3 - 5595 and 993 - 5596 (April 14, 2009), the California commissioner found that the franchisor failed to file the required notice when the franchisor openly negotiated different sales terms with prospective franchisees. The Commissioner found a willful disregard for disclosure requirements and material misstatements in the Franchise Application. As a result, the unit registration was revoked and the area application denied. The franchisor was also fined $132,500 and Ordered to pay Complainant's attorney fees and the franchisor was also required to offer California franchisees the right of rescission.

As we all know, franchising is a very specialized area of the law. When an attorney who is not knowledgeable about franchise law steps out of his normal practice areas he can find the road very bumpy. In State ex. Rel. Counsel for Discipline of the Nebraska Supreme Court v. Orr, 759 N.W. 2d 702 (Neb. 2009), a veteran business lawyer drafted a disclosure document. The franchisor was sued by several franchisees claiming the disclosure document did not comply with applicable law. Formal charges were filed against the attorney for violating several ethic rules, one of which states that a lawyer shall not handle a legal matter "which the lawyer knows or should know that he or she is not competent to handle, without associating with a lawyer who is competent to handle it or without preparation adequate in the circumstances."

3. Wrongful Termination

A wrongfully terminated franchisee turned an initial franchise fee into almost $350,000 plus interest and attorney fees. Quiznos Franchising, LLC v. Zig Zag Restaurant Group, LLC, Bus. Franchise Guide (CCH) ¶ 14,046 (D. Colo. Dec. 31, 2008). The Court lambasted the franchisor's termination based upon a mystery shopper program which was flawed and inconsistent. This case emphasizes that franchisors which retain discretion in deciding whether facts exist to warrant termination are under an implied duty to exercise their discretion reasonably and justifiably. It is a very good case for franchisors to read and learn what not to do.

In Emergency Accessories & Installation, Inc. v. Whelen Engineering Co., 2009 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 40956 (D. N.J. 2009) the Court noted that the 60-day notice of termination required by statute was required even though the Franchise Agreement chose the law of another state and provided for an at-will termination by either party. As always, franchisors must comply with the termination laws of the franchisee's state.

4. Unconscionability

California continues to lead the challenge on arbitration provisions being unconscionable. In the case of Bridge Fund Capital Corp. v. Fastbucks Franchise Corp., 2008 U.S. Distr. LEXIS 83724 (E.D. Cal. Aug. 19, 2008) the franchisor contended the franchisees were contractually bound to submit their claims to arbitration in Texas pursuant to their Franchise Agreement. The California court found the arbitration provision to be unconscionable and thus unenforceable. Part of the finding focused on provisions of the Franchise Agreement which were so one-sided that the Court found them to tilt the scales of unconsciousness. The Court stated that the limitation of damages to actual damages, shortening of the statute of limitations, the place of arbitration and banning class actions was enough to find against the enforcement of an arbitration clause in the Franchise Agreement. Similar issues were presented in Ben Charsky v. Cottman Transmission Sys., LLC, 2008 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 105 689 (N.D. Cal. Dec. 29, 2008). The Court severed the unconscionable provisions that violated the California Franchise Investment Law and upheld arbitration but required the application of California rather than Pennsylvania law.

5. International

a. Canada

In April, 2009, the provincial Department of Justice and Consumer Affairs published its Consultation on Proposed Regulations that will give effect to the New Brunswick Franchise Act. It is expected that the disclosure regulations will be introduced in the next two months followed by implementation six months after introduction.

b. South Africa

On April 30, 2009, The President of South Africa signed into law a sweeping consumer protection bill that includes a regulatory regime for franchising.

6. Conclusion

It is my hope that our Annual Legal Update will assist your company in analyzing the sufficiency of existing safeguards in your franchise program and help you decide whether to modify or implement new procedures in your franchise system. As part of your Annual Review make certain to include a legal review with your counsel. I am a firm believer that an "ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure".

Related Articles
  The Cost of a Franchise Offering
  Franchising Your Business Should Not Be Smoke and Mirrors
  Franchise Agreements The Basics
  Franchise Operations Manuals
  Franchise Agreement Key Provisions

Article Tags: alabama, attorney, birmingham, franchise law, franchisee, franchisor, lawyer, legal



Related Forum Posts
Re: Info for would be franchisers... - [quote="Sebastien":1d29sdv1]Like Franchise Times, Franchise Update is a very practical magazine. There is no blah blah, just straight facts that anyone in the franchise community can relate to. I just want to mention that all these magazines are NOT franchisee oriented. I mean these magazines are for franchise professionals. If you're looking to buy a franchise, you won't find much information in there. To answer your question, getting published in Franchise Times was fairly easy. I don't want to brag too much but I think I am known in the franchise industry. I was the marketing guy at Franchise.com for a few years before joining my new company, the World Franchising Network. So people know me and I have a very good relationship with Nancy Weingartner, the Managing Editor at Franchise Times. I was talking with her at the last Franchise Expo South in Miami and she mentioned she'd like me to be profiled. I was like "ok, sure!". I like this franchise executive profile thing in Franchise Times as it is rarely BS. People are usually really natural in there.[/quote:1d29sdv1] Thanks for the follow up Sebastien! And I can't say that I'm surprised that networking with the right people and managing your relationships with them properly are the keys to being published. I guess the old adage holds true of "it's not who you know, but who knows you" that's important.
Re: Info for would be franchisers... - [quote="Sebastien":2gam0klq][quote="BuzzAroundBooks":2gam0klq]Like Franchise Times, Franchise Update is a very practical magazine. There is no blah blah, just straight facts that anyone in the franchise community can relate to.[/quote:2gam0klq][/quote:2gam0klq] That is really what I look for in any industry publication. We lead busy lives and when people fill their magazines with fluff, not only does it benefit no one, but it makes us truly appreciate those that don't. Thanks!
Re: Enticing Franchises - Top 9 List - All Franchise listed above are in millions of dollars. Do you have the list of Franchise in thousands
how much for a franchise fee? - Dear Colleague There is no easy answer to this question. Things to consider: [list=] The sizeof the Franchise Clent base Expected Turnover Intellectual Property costs (recoup) Number of Franchises Number of employees Original Set up costs Franchise admin costs An example: A franchise that I was involved in setting was to a simple "lawn mowing/home repair" franchise. The Franchise included national/local advertising - preparation of client lists - general admin - central accounting etc The Franchise involved 300-500 clients - and an annual turnover of about $300,000 . The annual franchise fee was $30,000. Hope that this gives you some idea Take care Ian[/list]
Partner with them - Welcome to the Group TMR, Some ideas of people you can partner with for the Custom Napkins: - Wedding Planners - Photographers - Annual General Meetings for Corporations - Pageants - Hotels - Elite Restaurants - Elite Spas


Share this article with your friends. Fund someone's dream.

Leave a comment below or share on the left and you'll help support entrepreneurs in Africa through our partnership with Kiva. Over $50,000 raised and counting - Please keep sharing! Learn more.

Tweet

Newsletter

Get advice & tips from famous business
owners, new articles by entrepreneur
experts, my latest website updates, &
special sneak peaks at what's to come!

Name:
Email:

Popular Articles

What is Give Back Marketing?

Living on The Edge of Chaos...

Suggestions

Email us your ideas on how to make our
website more valuable! Thank you Sharon
from Toronto Salsa Lessons / Classes for
your suggestions to make the newsletter
look like the website and profile younger
entrepreneurs like Jennifer Lopez.