Any franchisor updating its franchise agreement should consider a requirement that its franchisees create and maintain a home page on the Internet. The cost of home page design may be shared amongst participating franchisees, much like yellow page advertisement. The agreement should also require the franchisee to insert a “hot key” or hyperlink between the franchisee’s home page and that of the franchisor and other franchisees.
In the Courts - Timothy’s Coffees v. Frank Switt This recent Ontario decision will be of interest to franchisors whose franchise agreement contains provisions for renewal which require the franchisee to “execute the form of franchise agreement then in use by the franchisor”. In the Switt case, the franchisee exercised his right of renewal. The renewal agreement contained terms that were different from the original franchise agreement, including an increase in the royalty rate from 6% to 9%.
The court found that the franchisee had an obligation to carefully review the franchise agreement to satisfy himself that it contained the terms that the franchisee thought it did. Even though the franchise agreement was drafted by the franchisor and provided very little flexibility to the franchisee, the court said that “this, of course, is the very nature of a franchise operation where uniformity, conformity and standardization go to the heart of the operation, and where individuality plays no part”.
The court confirmed that the franchisee, in order to effectively exercise its right of renewal, was required to sign the form of agreement being used by the franchisor at the time of renewal. The court ordered that the franchisee pay additional royalty fees owing as a result of the difference in royalty fees between those provided for in the original agreement and those provided for in the renewal agreement, from the effective date of renewal.
We advise franchisors to carefully review the wording of their renewal clauses to specifically allow for different financial terms to be contained in the renewal agreement. The clearer the terms with respect to this matter, the less likelihood that a franchisee will be able to avoid the requirement to live by the terms of the renewal agreement.
Trademarks, Etc. - What can be trademarked?
In any franchise or distribution systems, there will be a number of valuable assets that may need protection under the law of trademarks. In this report, we look at three registrable items.
Logo. It is common for business owners to invest a considerable amount of money and time to develop a memorable graphic design, and to spend even more money on various forms of advertising to create an association in the public’s mind between that logo and their business or products. Having invested all of this money and time, it is well worth gaining the advantages of formal trademark registration.
Slogan. A series of words such as “we never cut corners” or “clean, fresh, friendly” are slogans that may be registered as trademarks. A purely “laudatory” phrase, such as the expression “your dog will love it” in connection with pet food, is not permitted for registration.
Numbers. Pizza Pizza’s well known phone number “967-11-11”, in which Pizza Pizza invested heavily, was registered as a trademark. This was at some expense to Pizza Pizza, since the Registrar of Trademarks had originally taken the position that a telephone number, being purely functional, was not subject to registration. The matter was finally determined by the Federal Court of Appeal, who held in favour of Pizza Pizza.
More information.
For more information on franchising in Canada, the United States and internationally, please contact Peter Macrae Dillon, head of Siskinds Franchise Law Group. Peter is recognized expert in franchising. He is the author of the annotated Ontario Franchise Disclosure Act and the annotated Alberta Franchises Act and over 40 other publications on the subjects of franchising, licensing and distribution. He is licensed in Ontario and New York. Peter can be contacted at 800-816-9596 ext. 389 or by email at peter.dillon@siskinds.com. The information contained in this note is for general reference only, and should not be relied upon as constituting legal advice.
Disclaimer.
This article does not constitute legal advice. If you require assistance with the issues raised in this article, either to determine whether your business constitutes a franchise, to establish a franchise, or to avoid a finding that your business constitutes a franchise, you must obtain competent legal advice. Siskinds would be pleased to assist you in this regard.
Updating Your Franchise Documents - To learn more about this author, visit Peter Macrae Dillon's Website.
Like this article? Share it with your friends
 |
Related Articles |
|
 Negotiating the Terms of Your Franchise Agreement
|
| |
It is of course up to the franchisor to decide whether one not its franchisees can negotiate the terms of a franchise agreement. Unsurprisingly, the majority of large, established franchisors will not allow franchis...
|
|
International Franchise Expansion
|
| |
Once you start offering franchises, it may not be long before you begin receiving inquiries from individuals and firms interested in being part of your franchise program, or in opening franchised outlets, in other c...
|
|
Look Both Ways Before Franchising
|
| |
Many entrepreneurs consider franchising as a way to grow their business. Franchising is an attractive business model, based in part upon the fact that the capital of individual franchisees can help fund the growth o...
|
|
Franchise Agreements The Basics
|
| |
What you need to look for when you want to start a franchise and are ready to sign the franchise agreement.
So you’ve taken all the appropriate steps; you’ve researched, asked questions, found out about the co...
|
|
10 Tips For Investing In A Franchise
|
| |
Keep these 10 Tips in mind, when starting your search for that perfect franchise...
|
|
|
Peter Macrae Dillon
(Visit Peter's Website)
Peter Macrae Dillon is one of North
America’s leading and most-respected
franchise attorneys. He is licensed to
practice law in Ontario and New York. He
specializes in advising start-up
franchisors in the conversion and early
stages of franchising. His group
represents mature Canadian and American
franchise systems operating in Canada, the
United States, and internationally. Email
Peter at pe
ter.dillon@siskinds.com or visit his
website at: www.franchisel
aw.ca
peter macrae dillon franchise franchisor
lawyer attorney Toronto Ontario Canada www.franchisel
aw.ca
|
|
|
Peter Macrae Dillon's
Complete
List Of
Franchises
Articles
|
|
|
If you enjoyed this article, get Peter Macrae Dillon's Complete List of Franchises Articles For FREE!
|
| |
|
|
|
![[Get Copyright Permissions]](http://license.icopyright.net/images/icopy-w.gif){kind=small}
