Tweet

Just when you thought it safe to go into storage IO network waters

Guest post by: Greg Schulz

Article Overview: Just when you thought it safe to go into storage IO network waters

Just when you thought it safe to go into storage IO network waters

In the shark infested waters where I/O and networking debates often rage, the Fibre Channel vs. iSCSI, or, is that iSCSI vs. Fibre Channel debates continue which is about as surprising as an ice berg melting because it floated into warmer water or hot air in the tropics.

Here's a link to an article at Processor.com by Kurt Marko "iSCSI vs. Fibre Channel: A Cost Comparison iSCSI Targets the Low-End SAN, But Are The Cost Advantages Worth The Performance Trade-offs?" that looks at a recent iSCSI justification report and some additional commentary about apples to oranges comparisons by me. Here's the thing, no one in their right mind would try to refute that iSCSI at 1GbE levering built-in server NICs and standard Ethernet switches and operating system supplied path managers is cheaper than say 4Gb Fibre Channel or even legacy 1Gb and 2Gb Fibre Channel. However that's hardly an apple to apples comparison.

A more interesting comparison is for example 10GbE iSCSI compared to 1GbE iSCSI (again not a fair comparison), or, look at for example the new solution from HP and Qlogic that for about $8,200 USD, you get a 8Gb FC switch with a bunch of ports for expansion, four (4) PCIe 8Gb FC adapters plus cables plus transceiver optics which while not as cheap as 1GbE ports built into a server or an off the shelf Ethernet switch, is a far cry from the usual apples to oranges no cost Ethernet NICs vs. $1,500 FC adapters and high price FC director ports.

To be fair, put this into comparison with 10GbE adapters (and probably not a real apples to apples comparison at that) which on CDW go from about $600 USD (without no transceivers) to $1,100 to $1,500 for single port with transceivers or about $2,500 to $3,000 or more for dual or multi-port.

So the usual counter argument to trying to make a more apples to apples comparison is that iSCSI deployments do not need the performance of 10GbE or 8GbE Fibre Channel which is very valid, however then a comparison should be iSCSI vs. NAS.

Here's the bottom line, I like iSCSI for its target markets and see lots of huge upside and growth opportunity just like I see a continued place for Fibre Channel and moving forward FCoE leveraging Ethernet as the common denominator (at least for now) as well as NAS for data sharing and SAS for small deployments requiring shared storage (assuming a shared SAS array that is).

I�m a fan of using the right technology or tool for the task at hand and if that gets me in trouble with the iSCSI purist who wants everything on iSCSI, well, too bad, so be it. Likewise, if the FC police are not happy that I�m not ready and willing to squash out the evil iSCSI, well, too bad, get over it, same with NAS, InfiniBand and SAS and that's not to mean I don�t take a side or preference, rather, applied to the right task at hand, I�m a huge fan of these and other technologies and hence the discussion about apples to apples comparisons and applicability.

Related Articles
  Reasons your business needs self storage
  The Best Business Online Storage Services
  Beware of april 1st announcements
  Smart Women Need a Lighthouse
  Proper Storage & Stacking Pallets for Hazardous Materials
  More Data Footprint Reduction (DFR) Material
  The Benefits of Fusion Marketing Your Self Storage Facility with Other Local Businesses
  The data storage prayer
  Self Storage Investing Webinars Can Hold Valuable Tips
  Where to Store Inventory for Your Party Planning Company
  Do you make your clients feel safe?
  How to Restore Lost Photos from Virus Infected Storage Devices?
  Politics and Storage
  Trains going green
  Kawasaki Advertises A Wide Selection Of Jet Ski All Over Australia
  What is a reasonable cost model for providing a 3PL warehouse management service (Survey Result 1)
  Implement Efficient Document Management Software to Get Organized in Your Home, Office and Storage
  Recession Proof Real Estate
  Self Storage: Second Class Investment? Not Anymore!
  Charge back for storage

Article Tags: block, cloud, fcoe, file, infiniband, iscsi, nas, pcie, san, sas



Related Forum Posts
Need your own website but can't afford to pay for it? Let's - Do you need a professional looking website or blog? Maybe you need help with optimizing your site for search engines or even help to generate leads on the internet for your own business? My name is Tracy and I have been running my own web/graphic design business for nearly 10 years and my internet marketing services for about 3 years now. I am also a network marketer. I am looking to build my network marketing business and am using my skills to barter with people. I am willing to give my time and skills in exchange for your help in building my business. If you need a website but can't afford to pay a professional to build it for you AND you have a wide network of people who may be particularly interested in safe, effective weight loss, please contact me offline at tracyselena@rogers.com. Thanks and all the best to all of you. Tracy
Re: DropBox.com - Hey Evan, I just started using their service very recently. I'm currently using their free 2GB storage option. I mainly got it to send large-sized files to other people, as sometimes uploading to my web host server can become problematic and not work. I searched around for online storage options and landed on their site. Works great and very easy to share files with others. I currently have a 1TB external drive I backup all of my computer data on. Maybe someday I'll consider online backup, just for added protection of my files.
Re: Google Calendar - [quote="mbrand2222":2rrdft2b]Michelle makes a good point, although I'm not sure anything we do on the internet is "safe". From what I've heard, pretty much everything we do on our cell phones or internet is filtered from the top down. Who knows? The technology is definitely there to make it possible. Supposedly they do it to keep our nation safe, but sometimes it just crosses the line too much for me.[/quote:2rrdft2b] Mary you are right, today nothing is safe, your internet provider, cell phone company, google and other SE, all know exactly what you do, when and where. Michelle, nothing is safe anymore, the best you can do is protect your PC with antivirus and spyware, it's not riskier than shopping online.
Re: Why do people hate Network Marketing / MLM? - I want to start network marketing but I am afraid of losing money. I had heard about many scam stories and due to this reason people hate network marketing. Please anyone have any experienced with network marketing can suggest me. network marketing
Re: Anybody use Adify? - Trafficspaces used to be called Aductions - an ad network that launched at the end of 2007. I believe they exited the ad network space to focus on the ad manager and did the whole rebranding thing. The founder, Niyi, is a an old uni mate of mine back in Bristol (England) so I know a bit about their progress. I'm not sure about starting in Jan 09 cus they rebranded in June or July 08. Been in stealth mode since then till January. Maybe that explains the high Alexa. anyway, you don't have to use them right now, I guess. Just thought I should let u know what was out there. Keep an eye out. I think they've got something solid. Mark


Share this article with your friends. Fund someone's dream.

Leave a comment below or share on the left and you'll help support entrepreneurs in Africa through our partnership with Kiva. Over $50,000 raised and counting - Please keep sharing! Learn more.

Newsletter

Get advice & tips from famous business
owners, new articles by entrepreneur
experts, my latest website updates, &
special sneak peaks at what's to come!

Name:
Email:

Popular Articles

Are You Fulfilled

Basic Operating Question (BOQ) for Empowerment

Using your social media profiles to drive traffic

Suggestions

Email us your ideas on how to make our
website more valuable! Thank you Sharon
from Toronto Salsa Lessons / Classes for
your suggestions to make the newsletter
look like the website and profile younger
entrepreneurs like Jennifer Lopez.