Tweet

3 Lawsuits That Are Changing the California Labor Law Landscape

Guest post by: Ari Rosenstein

Article Overview: In the first half of 2011, employment and labor lawsuits in California have resulted in many important decisions that will directly affect the way employers in the state relate to their employees. Many of these cases have already been decided upon by the California Supreme Court, while others are still pending a decision. This article provides a brief outline of three key cases, and an important "take away" for employers from each one.

3 Lawsuits That Are Changing the California Labor Law Landscape

Employment lawsuits have risen to their highest peak in history, with almost 100,000 claims files in 2010, according to the EEOC. Incredibly, that number reflects a 31% increase from just 4 years ago! There is a never-ending flow of new court cases and decisions that change the employment landscape, making it extremely difficult for employers to stay ahead of the curve. Particularly in California, labor law evolves faster than federal law, adding to the complexity of employment compliance. In the first half of 2011, employment and labor lawsuits in California have resulted in many important decisions that will directly affect the way employers in the state relate to their employees. Many of these cases have already been decided upon by the California Supreme Court, while others are still pending a decision.

Below is a brief outline of three key cases, and an important "take away" for employers from each one.

Case #1

Summary: The Plaintiff was a senior executive at Google and claimed that he was discriminated against because of his age in a notoriously "young" corporate culture. To support his case, he relied on various comments by superiors and coworkers that his ideas were "obsolete" or "too old to matter," that he was not a "cultural fit" and that he was an "old man" and an "old fuddy-duddy." Google argued that none of these remarks were made in connection with any employment decision and should be deemed irrelevant "stray remarks."

The California Supreme Court rejected the notion that "stray remarks" made by non-managerial staff, or by supervisors outside of the disciplinary process, should not be given weight in court. Rather, such "stray remarks" may and should be considered in the context of the evidence and could be used towards reaching a final decision.

Take away: All managers should be aware of what is being said in the workplace, even in casual talk between employees, and to be proactive in eliminating derogatory or discriminatory remarks.

Case #2

Summary: This employer's corporate location was based in California, but had employees working out-of-state. Due to California's dissimilar overtime laws, the employer paid the out-of-state employee based on his state of residency, and not according to California's overtime regulations. The California Supreme Court is currently reviewing the case to determine if the California Labor Code applies to overtime worked in California for a California-based employer, by out-of-state workers.

Take away: While the case is still pending before the Supreme Court, employers should carefully review all state labor code guidelines.

Case #3

Summary: The E.E.O.C. sued a California airport services company based on a male employee's allegation that he was sexually harassed by a female co-worker and thus suffered from a hostile work environment. The California Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals reversed a summary judgment for the employer, emphasizing that Title VII of the Civil Rights Act entitles men, like women, to protection from an abusive work environment. The California Supreme Court eventually found in favor of male plaintiff.

Take away: Never just tell a male employee to "Be a man" or "Get over it", if he claims of harassment. Take the claim seriously and conduct a proper investigation.

In conclusion

Most work related acts made by employers toward employees are not intentionally bigoted, malicious or discriminatory by nature. However, the complexity of labor laws in California demand that employers act with extreme caution when engaging employees and making employment decisions. In many cases, these actions can and will be brought against them in an employment lawsuit. As a reminder, California labor laws differ in many areas from Federal laws, so check with legal counsel before making any questionable employment decision or act.

Related Articles
  California Labor Laws and the Domestic Workers Bill of Rights Movement
  California Labor Law Update: Recent Court Decisions Favor Employers
  Labor Law in California: Proactive Efforts Can Help Reduce HR Risks
  Employment and Labor Law in California Updates
  Meal & Rest Periods – California Labor Law May Hold Employers Liable for Additional Hours of Pay
  Victory for Starbucks in Tip-Pooling Class Action
  Seven Steps to Avoid Employee Lawsuits
  The Fearful FLSA Audit
  Understanding California Labor Laws and the WARN Act
  California Labor Law Challenges and Solutions
  The Differences Between Federal and California Labor Laws
  The Value of EPL Insurance to Protect Your Business Against Employment Lawsuits
  Financial Advisor Keith Springer Quoted In The Sacramento Business Journal
  Companies Insist Suppliers be more Socially Conscious
  How To Avoid Employee Lawsuits – 5 Management Best Practices
  The Mustard Seed Problem
  Wal-Mart v. Dukes: 7 Employment Takeaways from the Recent Supreme Court Ruling
  Supreme Court Ruling May Lead To More Unionization
  Undocumented Worker Legislation - A New Reality for California Employers
  In the number of startups, California is first in 13 industries

Article Tags: california labor law, employment law in california, labor and employment law, labor laws in california



Related Forum Posts
Re: Search Engine Optimization - A lot of SEO in terms of on-page optimization is trial and error. Changing just one word can have a huge impact on your rankings.
Re: Best Month For Getting Financed? - Let me suggest that May/June are the best months to inquire about funding and investment. Once tax season is over, banks and investors have plenty of budgeted or reserved funds waiting for commercial clients. Funds start to become limited around Labor Day!
Re: HI@All - Hi David from from California, Welcome to the forum.
Hi from California - Hi everyone, I thought I should introduce myself. I am currently a student in southern California, and I hope to one day own a clothing boutique. I'm interested in the website as a way to network with entrepreneurs, since I hope to be one myself. I look forward to chatting.
Re: Off to Disney World - Sound like a long vacation at Disney, California, Florida or My shortest trip to Disney was about an hour in the parking lot, and we had tickets for 8-10 people, but that is a story for another day enjoy yourself


Share this article with your friends. Fund someone's dream.

Leave a comment below or share on the left and you'll help support entrepreneurs in Africa through our partnership with Kiva. Over $50,000 raised and counting - Please keep sharing! Learn more.

Newsletter

Get advice & tips from famous business
owners, new articles by entrepreneur
experts, my latest website updates, &
special sneak peaks at what's to come!

Name:
Email:

Popular Articles

Common Sense Stress Management

Sales is a Flawed Model

Tips for the Novice Traveler

Suggestions

Email us your ideas on how to make our
website more valuable! Thank you Sharon
from Toronto Salsa Lessons / Classes for
your suggestions to make the newsletter
look like the website and profile younger
entrepreneurs like Jennifer Lopez.