Evan Carmichael Top Header about About About facebook Twitter YouTube Google+

Social Media Investigations May Be Essential to Hiring and Can Be Conducted Lawfully



Free PDF Download
2013 Gamechangers: New Rules in Employee Motivation - By Jessica Ollenburg

Name: Email:


Some attorneys will advise employers to avoid using social media as a recruitment and screening tool. The caution is wise; however, avoidance may be impractical, and the proper use of social media can most definitely pay off. In many cases, we consider it actually necessary. While risks of unlawful use exist and need be avoided, bona fide occupational qualifications can be investigated through proper methodology. The following 3 rules are set forth to simplify legal compliance.

1)Timing is everything. The EEOC is often more concerned about the timing and outcomes of collecting data than the collection of data itself. That is, we know certain visual characteristics when we interview or videoconference a candidate, yet premature collection and use of this data is considered unlawful "profiling." The investigation of social media after interview is typically safer than prior to interview. A company that shows reasonable care and great diversity in demographics and advancement provides substantially stronger affirmative defense than a company with insufficient diversity and/or without reasonable care compliance. Protected characteristics are found not only in the Civil Rights Act of 1964 but also in the legal changes and state regulations emerging ongoing.

2)Bona Fide Occupational Qualifications (BFOQs) are still considered a lawful job requirement subject to reasonable investigation. How a candidate presents his/herself to the general public and company stakeholders is a legitimate public relations and credibility concern. While off duty behavior may or may not be appropriate to monitor and discover as a BFOQ, how a candidate chooses to be known on the Internet as searchable by customers, co-workers, competitors, associates, vendors, investors and other stakeholders, is certainly a BFOQ. Such a presence affects on duty performance, especially when easily detected by search engine or links to professional or company presence. A great job description and strong company policies will validate social media investigations.

3)Outsource investigation and/or control consistency and chain of information. HRS policy establishment, training and candidate investigation services are currently booming. While we are biased that no competitor meets our standards, please know resources abound for outsourcing implementation or procedural design as risk management. If choosing to insource the effort, control documentation and custody of information. Appropriate policies and disclosures should be considered. One size does not fit all here. Social media usage and monitoring policies should match the company's unique practices. And, although the candidate may choose the "world wide web" to air private and personal information, the employer must remember to not further the information distribution except on a "need to know" basis. Use of search engines to collect data is recommended. The method of collecting data should align with reasonable access to information by company stakeholders.

The appropriate use of social media in hiring provides cost-effective recruitment, often with cost savings or targeted candidate access impractical to ignore. However, the very nature of recruitment via social media could grant us access to candidate social media profiles too soon. To use only social media for recruitment, in certain cases, may in itself be considered discriminatory. Audience demographics should be considered to both control costs and to also ensure abidance with Affirmative Action Plans where they exist.

It is difficult to investigate certain social media sites, especially those of a personal rather than professional focus, without receiving information regarding age, race, nationality, military, family status, sexual orientation, religion, or some combination of the many, many lawfully protected characteristics. Pictures, comments, links, interests and profile page data cannot be reasonably avoided. To better manage risks, we suggest directing the candidate to the company's own application system rather than linking the recruitment response with the candidate's social media profile. Such a step allows the company to broadcast the recruitment via social media but to collect responses through traditional methods discouraging profiling.

Upon reaching the correct stage and method of data collection, be certain to avoid risk of error and falsehood. Identities can be confused, and inaccurate information may be collected. Be certain you have the correct individual, and be certain the information is true. Background check permission forms should collect necessary data to validate identity. HRS recommends and designs a sequential plan of using social media investigations lawfully, consistently, with proper timing and privacy controls toward the appropriate evaluation of BFOQs. As an added safeguard, it is popularly recommended to involve an outside firm or an individual not participating in the employment decisions. That individual or firm should then be in position to report only on job requirements and BFOQs, thereby inherently controlling the distribution and use of data.


Related Articles

  Where Are You in Social Media Adoption Curve?
  Evolving to adopt Social Media…
  Three approaches for improved PR activity
  Top 5 Social Media Tips You Should Know About
  “Should I or shouldn’t I”
  Using Social Media Effectively As A Business Professional And Author
  Social Media Marketing for your Business
  Addressing law firm objections to social media
  A Foolproof Way To Evaluate Marketing Advice
  Social Media Principle 8 – The Behaviour is “Social”
  Resourcing B2B social media
  Social Media is NOT about Twitter, Facebook and Linkedin
  Legal Marketing: Social Media and Law Firms
  Are you anxious about using social media in your business?
  Social Media Gains Momentum for B2B Marketers
  Strategies For Utilizing Social Media Outlets
  Financial services: Transparency through social media
  Why Should You Hire a Social Media Consultant?
  Social media : why should my business use this resource?
  Social Media Marketing Effective Advertising for Your Business

Home > Human-Resources > Jessica Ollenburg > Social Media Investigations May Be Essential to Hiring and Can Be Conducted Lawfully >

Free PDF Download
2013 Gamechangers: New Rules in Employee Motivation - By Jessica Ollenburg

Name: Email:

About the Author: Jessica Ollenburg

RSS for Jessica's articles - Visit Jessica's website
Jessica Ollenburg is CEO at HRS-Human Resource Services, Inc., with global satellites providing organizational development and HR management solutions and research since 1983.  HRS serves employers of choice, with size ranging 25 - 100,000+ employees. Educator, Entrepreneur, Author, Media Magnet and Senior Management Consultant, Jessica's bio is available at http://www.AskHRS.com/our-ceo.htm
Click here to visit Jessica's website.
Dashed Line

More from Jessica Ollenburg
If Im a SelfStarter Why Arent You Those High in Initiative May Be Challenged as Coaches
Team Motivation Principles Debunk the Crazy Propaganda that All CEOs are Greedy
Sensitivity Creates Results In Business Dont Misinterpret It
Great Consultants are Never In Between Jobs Consulting Outsource PartTime Management and NonProfit Associations are 4 Distinctively Different Solutions When and Where to Deploy Each
Choosing Employee Assessments Hand Scoring by Experts Still Safeguards Validity ROI

Related Forum Posts

Re: Kevin needs "social glue" ideas Re: Kevin needs "social glue" ideas
Re: Kevin needs "social glue" ideas Re: Kevin needs "social glue" ideas
Re: UPDATES: New Campaign! New Layout! New Ideas! Re: UPDATES: New Campaign! New Layout! New Ideas!
Re: Marketing 2.0 - What Are Your Thoughts Re: Marketing 2.0 - What Are Your Thoughts
Re: Social Media Marketing Ignorance Re: Social Media Marketing Ignorance

Share this article. Fund someone's dream.

Share this post and you'll help support entrepreneurs in Africa through our partnership with Kiva. Over $50,000 raised and counting - Please keep sharing! Learn more.
Share for a Cause
Featured Blog



Worksheets
By: Evan Carmichael

Do you have what it takes to be an entrepreneur?

8 Powerful Steps to Finding Your Passion

Does your pitch suck?

Create a plan of attach to launch your new business.

8-Cover

Like this page? PLEASE +1 it! Evan Signature
Bottom Footer



Newsletter

Get advice & tips from famous business
owners, new articles by entrepreneur
experts, my latest website updates, &
special sneak peaks at what's to come!
Name:
Email:
Popular Articles

The Bounce Back Book by Karen Salmansohn

When Did You Last Put Your Ear To The Ground?

Cleavage in the Boardroom

Suggestions

Email us your ideas on how to make our
website more valuable! Thank you Sharon
from Toronto Salsa Lessons / Classes for
your suggestions to make the newsletter
look like the website and profile younger
entrepreneurs like Jennifer Lopez.