Tweet

How Top Management Views Performance Appraisal Systems

Guest post by: Leslie Allan

Article Overview: How important is your leadership team's support of the performance management system in your organization? A recent study into the views of HR professionals towards their appraisal system sheds interesting light on the value of top level endorsement.

How Top Management Views Performance Appraisal Systems

A survey of human resources professionals recently found a surprisingly high number of them lacked confidence in the effectiveness of their company's performance-management system. Though 91% of respondents said their organization evaluates performance, only 47% said the process is effective.

It gets worse. Only 47% of respondents said their appraisal system helps their organization achieve strategic objectives, while 30% said employees do not trust the system. An even smaller number - 28% - said their managers regarded the appraisal process primarily as an administrative headache.

Numbers like these from Sibson Consulting help explain why performance appraisal is at a train wreck at so many companies around the world. The study, conducted in mid-2010 with the HR association WorldatWork, queried executives at hundreds of companies of all sizes from every corner of the planet. No place on Earth is immune from performance-evaluation angst.

Let's explore the reasons why and start at the top - with senior management. The survey found widespread support for performance evaluations from senior management. In fact, 74% said executives at their organization support the system. Still, that leaves 26% of all organizations with non-supportive top-level executives. Those, however, do not fully explain all the problems with performance-management systems today.

Something is getting in the way of the widespread support of senior management. The answer, it turns out, may very well be the performance-management system itself. According to the survey, a full third of senior executives "strongly" or "mostly consider" the evaluation system to be business-critical. And a third of the respondents reported their leadership viewed employee appraisals as an exercise in pencil-pushing.

We're now at the heart of the problem. Executive support isn't being converted into executive action. For example, senior management required completed appraisals for all employees at only 65% of responding organizations.

An even more dismal number: Only 40% of respondents said their senior leaders were models for the right behavior. They agreed with this statement: "Leaders model performance management through evaluation and coaching of the direct reports." (30% disagreed with the statement.)

Senior executives who are outright avoiding or skimping on performance evaluations are probably facing the same challenges as lower-level managers. Only a little more than a third of managers complete thorough evaluations, according to the Sibson survey's respondents. A third openly disagreed. And only 46% said the system was worth the time and effort required to conduct and write up the evaluations.

The HR survey respondents cited three primary challenges:

• Appraising managers lack the courage to have difficult performance conversations with their direct reports (63%).

• Appraising managers viewed evaluations as an administrative process not critical to business success (47%)

• Appraising managers do a poor job setting goals at the start of each appraisal cycle (36%).

These are big challenges that will require the support and the actions of senior executives to overcome.

But why bother?

The answer lies in an analysis that ran with the survey results. Sibson Consulting split the companies into quartiles based on return-to-shareholder value over three years. For 87% of respondents at companies working at the top companies, they felt that senior leadership publicly supported the performance-evaluation process. That compares with 66% at the bottom quartile of companies.

More telling is an examination of responses from companies where senior leadership did not support the appraisal process. Only 3% of respondents from the top quartile felt senior management was unsupportive. That compares with 14% at companies in the bottom quartile.

This analysis did not find a huge gap, but the numbers are significant enough to suggest support at the top for appraisals is making a difference. The challenge for HR managers is to figure out how to convert verbal support for the system into actions that not only drive thorough, fair and effective appraisals, but also overall organizational performance.

References:

Allan, Leslie, (2010) "Performance Management Survey Votes Down Employee Appraisals", Business Performance Pty Ltd

The Segal Group, (2010) Study on The State of Performance Management

The Segal Group, (2010) Information About the Respondents to the WorldatWork/Sibson 2010 Study on The State of Performance Management

© Leslie Allan. All rights reserved.

Related Articles
  How To Run A Staff Appraisal
  360 Degree Appraisals
  Designing A Performance Management System
  THREE FACTORS MAKE PERFORMANCE MANAGEMENT A SUCCESS
  Getting the Performance Appraisal Right
  Organizational Readiness To Performance Management
  A Guide for Employee Appraisals
  Dropped Balls
  Performance Appraisals
  Are Organizations Utilizing Employee Performance Appraisal Systems optimally?
  Employee Performance Management: Time to Reinvent the Wheel
  The overuse of "people" as competitive advantage
  What Is Wrong with Performance Appraisals?
  Performance Appraisals and Compensation: A Deadly Mix
  Achieveing Fair Financial and NonFinancial Rewards
  What have I learned in 6 months of management? Part 3
  No worries mate!
  The #1 Guide to Performance Appraisals
  Performance Appraisals
  How to make vibrant organization based on performance appraisal system

Article Tags: appraisal, employee, executive, HR, human resources, leadership, management, manager, organization, performance, study, support, system
Referred by: http://www.businessperform.com



Related Forum Posts
CMS - Speaking of Content Management Systems, which one are you going with? I've stubbornly held off going to a CMS, but each time I change something on my pages, such as the Navbar, I have to go back through everyone and cut and paste and it does get time consuming. BUt I like the freedom to alter a single pages layout if I need to to accomodate a certain type of article...
HRPreneur - Hi everyone, I am new to the forum and I recently started my own Human Capital (HR) consulting firm called HRPreneur Inc. HRP focuses on making human capital a strategic differentiator for SME's. Below is a summary about HRP; Who We Are: HRP is a Human Capital consulting firm with 30 years of experience that becomes an extension of your company by providing a full array of services to help you create a highly engaged workforce focused on achieving strategic results in order to build a long lasting great company! Mission: HRP provides small and medium sized businesses a Strategic HR Business Partner to increase employee engagement, resulting in cost savings, increased productivity and results at an affordable rate! Vision: To inspire and warrant SME's reach their full competency! Cost Effectiveness: We provide over 30 years of experience at a fraction of the cost at a strategic executive HR business level You will save between 50% to 60% in costs per year on salary, bonus, benefits, training, office space alone We will provide you additional cost efficiencies through our services Services: • Strategic Human Resources Planning • Organizational Redesign • Change Management • Organizational Culture Development • Employee Engagement Programs • Leadership Assessment and Development • Compensation Design • Talent Acquisition • Assimilation and On-Boarding • Performance Management • Talent Management & Succession Planning • Human Resources Due Diligence • Human Resources Audit • Full Service HR Outsourcing
No B.S. Time Management - A great book I read on Time Management is No B.S. Time Management for Entrepreneurs by Dan Kennedy.
Seek Venture Capital & Funding - Hello, Greetings from India. I am Seeking Venture Capital for Offshore Software Company Start-up. Need advise along with Business Model Sample. I have a basic outline for an offshore company. 1. Technology - like Microsoft Dot Net, Java, LAMP 2. Talent Team - Found Good Technology Developers. 3. Where I can get the leads/potential customers - Leads have been identified who are willing to move forward offshore projects. 4. I do not have resources like funding. It is a very critical factor to me Industries: Manufacturing, Real Estate, Retail, Insurance, Distribution & Logistics, Healthcare, Industry Associations and Software Product Development, Agricultural Industries and Etc. Services: Offshore Software Development Company. Offices to be located: Hyderabad, Andhra Pradesh, India and USA. Products/Services/Applications in areas like POS & Billing, Sales & Distribution, Production Planning, Material Management, Inventory Control, Plant Maintenance, Purchasing, Accounting and Logistics. Dynamic Web Programming with Database Driven Content Management Systems, Online Stores for E-Commerce, B2B Solutions, Community Portals, Website Redesign and Development, Custom ERP with Enterprise Wide Functional Modules such as Marketing, CRM, Accounting, Inventory Control, Sales & Distribution, Production Planning, Purchase & Stores, Logistics and Supply Chain. Seek your further questions and help. Thank you, Best Regards, Jayapratap.
ARTICLE: Performance coaching in the workplace - To create lasting performance change it is necessary to first understand the positive and negative influence that a person’s personal behaviors has on their execution and what impact these have on their ability to achieve success. Only when we fully understand a person’s behavioral patterns and create positive self-managing coaching strategies can we assist a person to create lasting performance change. The vast majority of employers believe coaching can deliver significant benefits to both individuals and organizations. The majority of employers plan to increase the use of coaching over the next few years, according to a new survey by the Institute of Personnel and Development. Nearly nine out of ten interviewed companies expect their managers and supervisors to deliver performance coaching as part of their day-to-day work. In another large industry-wide study it was found that most managers reported that they were confident in their ability to coach. However, the study also showed that the managers’ actual skills levels as coaches were typically poor. As a consequence they were not nearly as effective in their coaching as they believe themselves to be. Often times, they believed that coaching consisted of just providing 1-to-1 instructional feedback to their staff members on what to do in a given situation to perform better. Many recent studies have shown that technical skills only represent at best 20% of the contribution into our performance. The remaining 80% comes from our ability to choose or make a decision, assertiveness, commitment to grow, ability to concentrate, honesty, optimism, persistence, ability to perform well under stress and so on. These traits are commonly called our soft skills or attitude. Few managers understand just how deeply rooted their own behavior patterns are, let alone how to positively change them in other people. Performance coaching is frequently confused with other types of coaching, such as Executive coaching and Life coaching. Performance coaching is a form of Directive coaching. Executive coaching and Life coaching are both forms of Non-directive coaching. Directive coaching is usually more suitable for a manager who sometimes acts as a coach. Performance coaching in the workplace has developed immensely from what it was only 4 years ago. To choose the right coach will make a huge difference. You also better make sure to know what you want. If your coach knows what (s)he is doing – you will get on your way to get it! [i:38tu5pgr]- Peter J Karlsson[/i:38tu5pgr]


Share this article with your friends. Fund someone's dream.

Leave a comment below or share on the left and you'll help support entrepreneurs in Africa through our partnership with Kiva. Over $50,000 raised and counting - Please keep sharing! Learn more.

Newsletter

Get advice & tips from famous business
owners, new articles by entrepreneur
experts, my latest website updates, &
special sneak peaks at what's to come!

Name:
Email:

Popular Articles

When Your Smiling

The five pillars of internet marketing strategy

Are You Fulfilled

Suggestions

Email us your ideas on how to make our
website more valuable! Thank you Sharon
from Toronto Salsa Lessons / Classes for
your suggestions to make the newsletter
look like the website and profile younger
entrepreneurs like Jennifer Lopez.