Tweet

Performance Appraisals and Compensation: A Deadly Mix

Guest post by: Leslie Allan

Article Overview: The annual jostling for pay rises based on employee performance is often described as ineffective by HR professionals, largely dreaded by managers and treated with suspicion by employees. So why do organizations still engage in this annual exercise?

Performance Appraisals and Compensation: A Deadly Mix

Performance appraisals are hated by employees, largely dreaded by managers and often described as ineffective by HR professionals. So why do organizations still engage in this annual exercise?

The primary objective, cited by 66% of respondents to a survey by Sibson Consulting, is to distribute rewards based on individual performance. By comparison, just over half (54%) said greater individual accountability is a primary objective. Only 46% identified talent developmentas the biggest factor.

Rewards distribution is key in other ways, too: It's the biggest reason why employee-appraisal systems are failing to meet expectations. Proponents of tying rewards to appraisals argue that the overall organization will benefit if the best and the brightest see their pay or bonuses increase more than their average or below-average co-workers.

But what if the appraisal system itself is too subjective, untrusted and flawed? The linkage between rewards and appraisals would then only serve to magnify other problems with the performance-management system. And just as the overall organization was supposed to benefit when the evaluation system works, the entire organization suffers when the evaluation system fails.

And that's exactly what is happening. The Sibson Consulting survey, which was conducted in mid-2010 with the HR association WorldAtWork, found rampant mistrust in performance management. The results weren't limited to one country, industry or company. Some 750 people responded, representing a broad swath of industries and organizations around the world. Headcounts of respondents' organizations ranged from fewer than 100 employees to more than 500,000.

Nine out of 10 respondents reported that their organizations have formal systems to rate the performance of individual employees, shape behaviors and, in theory, provide some sort of benefit to the organization as a whole. At the same time, only 43% of respondents rated their organization's system as effective.

This article, which is one of three that looks at the epidemic of dysfunction in systems for assessing employee performance, will explore the fallacy of connecting performance with pay.

First, let's examine what "rewards" are being distributed as part of evaluating performance. According to the Sibson survey, 80% of respondents' companies tie performance to merit pay while 51% link it to short-term incentives and 31% connect it to long-term incentives. At the same time, at 65% of the responding companies, low performers receive significantly lower or no pay increases while, at 42% of the organizations, high performers received significantly fatter pay checks compared with average performers.

The result, besides cementing a dislike of appraisals, pits employees against each other - something that's counterproductive to organizations that want employees to work collaboratively. In addition, employees are more likely to change their behavior to match the evaluation's simplified criteria, which are typically not the overall goals of the organization.

Besides being a recipe for employee and team dysfunction, the connection between rewards and appraisals can strain the organization's finances. Salaries can grow out of control, especially during economic slowdowns and recessions.

The reason? There is a disconnection between individual performance ratings and overall organizational performance. The Sibson survey found that only 20% of respondents said employee ratings declined in sync with the business' overall performance. At first glance, this suggests managers may be inflating ratings. But there is more than meets the eye.

External factors - increased competition and the overall economy, to name a few - always impact a company's performance, and employees can do little to change that. In addition, the business impact of declining performance among employees won't necessarily be felt for a year or more as problem areas are temporarily glossed over by other employees, cash reserves and customers who continue to do business with an organization for no other reason than inertia. When this happens, an organization will find itself doling out more bonuses and pay raises just before revenue craters.

There is one final nail in the coffin of paying-for-performance: Research shows that it is generally ineffective at boosting employee productivity. Stanford University Professors Jeffrey Pfeffer and Robert Sutton, along with best-selling author Daniel Pink, have demonstrated that pay and bonus incentives are particularly ineffective when tasks are complex, require judgment and rely on collaboration with others. Are there any other types of jobs at today's organizations?

The global doubts and dislikes of performance management suggest that systems need to be rebuilt from scratch. The best place to start is the link between rewards and what's checked on the performance-appraisal form. Smart business owners will eliminate that link before it sinks their organizations.



References:

Allan, Leslie, (2010) "Top Leadership Perspectives on Performance Management", Business Performance Pty Ltd

Pink, Daniel H., (2009) Drive: The Surprising Truth About What Motivates Us, Riverhead Hardcover

Pfeffer, Jeffrey, (2007) What Were They Thinking Unconventional Wisdom About Management, Ch. 11, Harvard Business School Press

Pfeffer, Jeffrey and Sutton, Robert I., (2006) Hard Facts, Dangerous Half-Truths and Total Nonsense: Profiting from Evidence-Based Management, Ch. 5, Harvard Business School Press

The Segal Group, (2010) Study on The State of Performance Management

The Segal Group, (2010) Information About the Respondents to the WorldatWork/Sibson 2010 Study on The State of Performance Management

© Leslie Allan. All rights reserved.

Related Articles
  Performance Appraisals
  5 Deadly Decisions in Business and How to Avoid Them
  TIME FOR BUDGETS BUT NO TIME FOR PERFORMANCE MANAGEMENT!
  Improving Annual Performance Reviews
  Are Organizations Utilizing Employee Performance Appraisal Systems optimally?
  Performance Appraisals: Critical Conversations
  No worries mate!
  360 Degree Appraisals
  Human Capital Talent Management Requires to Tell It Like It Is
  12 Deadly Mistakes To Avoid On Your Web Site According To Your Strategic Thinking Business Coach
  Reward and Recognition Pathways and Pitfalls
  Aligning Compensation and Rewards
  How to avoid the 7 deadly sins of business storytelling
  How Top Management Views Performance Appraisal Systems
  BOOK REVIEW: Abolishing Performance Appraisals: Why They Backfire And What To Do Instead (By Tom Coens & Mary Jenkins, Berrett-Koehler, 2000, ISBN #1-57675-076-0)
  Ten Deadly Mistakes To Avoid In E-Commerce
  What the Fair Pay Act Means For Your Business
  Swim Clear of the Compensation Undertow
  Getting those processes in place!
  Designing A Performance Management System

Article Tags: appraisal, employee, HR, human resources, incentive, management, manager, organization, performance, process, rating, reward, survey, system
Referred by: http://www.businessperform.com



Related Forum Posts
HRPreneur - Hi everyone, I am new to the forum and I recently started my own Human Capital (HR) consulting firm called HRPreneur Inc. HRP focuses on making human capital a strategic differentiator for SME's. Below is a summary about HRP; Who We Are: HRP is a Human Capital consulting firm with 30 years of experience that becomes an extension of your company by providing a full array of services to help you create a highly engaged workforce focused on achieving strategic results in order to build a long lasting great company! Mission: HRP provides small and medium sized businesses a Strategic HR Business Partner to increase employee engagement, resulting in cost savings, increased productivity and results at an affordable rate! Vision: To inspire and warrant SME's reach their full competency! Cost Effectiveness: We provide over 30 years of experience at a fraction of the cost at a strategic executive HR business level You will save between 50% to 60% in costs per year on salary, bonus, benefits, training, office space alone We will provide you additional cost efficiencies through our services Services: • Strategic Human Resources Planning • Organizational Redesign • Change Management • Organizational Culture Development • Employee Engagement Programs • Leadership Assessment and Development • Compensation Design • Talent Acquisition • Assimilation and On-Boarding • Performance Management • Talent Management & Succession Planning • Human Resources Due Diligence • Human Resources Audit • Full Service HR Outsourcing
ARTICLE: Performance coaching in the workplace - To create lasting performance change it is necessary to first understand the positive and negative influence that a person’s personal behaviors has on their execution and what impact these have on their ability to achieve success. Only when we fully understand a person’s behavioral patterns and create positive self-managing coaching strategies can we assist a person to create lasting performance change. The vast majority of employers believe coaching can deliver significant benefits to both individuals and organizations. The majority of employers plan to increase the use of coaching over the next few years, according to a new survey by the Institute of Personnel and Development. Nearly nine out of ten interviewed companies expect their managers and supervisors to deliver performance coaching as part of their day-to-day work. In another large industry-wide study it was found that most managers reported that they were confident in their ability to coach. However, the study also showed that the managers’ actual skills levels as coaches were typically poor. As a consequence they were not nearly as effective in their coaching as they believe themselves to be. Often times, they believed that coaching consisted of just providing 1-to-1 instructional feedback to their staff members on what to do in a given situation to perform better. Many recent studies have shown that technical skills only represent at best 20% of the contribution into our performance. The remaining 80% comes from our ability to choose or make a decision, assertiveness, commitment to grow, ability to concentrate, honesty, optimism, persistence, ability to perform well under stress and so on. These traits are commonly called our soft skills or attitude. Few managers understand just how deeply rooted their own behavior patterns are, let alone how to positively change them in other people. Performance coaching is frequently confused with other types of coaching, such as Executive coaching and Life coaching. Performance coaching is a form of Directive coaching. Executive coaching and Life coaching are both forms of Non-directive coaching. Directive coaching is usually more suitable for a manager who sometimes acts as a coach. Performance coaching in the workplace has developed immensely from what it was only 4 years ago. To choose the right coach will make a huge difference. You also better make sure to know what you want. If your coach knows what (s)he is doing – you will get on your way to get it! [i:38tu5pgr]- Peter J Karlsson[/i:38tu5pgr]
Compensating your Advisory Board - Hey! Happy Monday. With regard to stock options, I am of the belief that 1-2% is appropriate historically. Personally, I would be open to considering any amount based on the level of expertise and time they are willing to give me. Although I did have one gentleman ask for 20%. I told him no. I have 7 members on my advisory board currently and I am starting to build one for my women's leadership business. I have thought about adding it to the existing 'agenda' but I need different skills and resources. Compensation varies and is kept very confidential at our board. Everyone knows they have 'skin' in the game per say, and I am very careful not to abuse that trust. For one thing, sometimes I find myself thinking that a more formally 'paid' member should be doing more legwork....that kind of stuff. Its a bit challenging but so far the dynamics work.
These maybe the coldest franchises out there: - Here are the worst 15 performing franchises in regards to having the highest Small Business Administration (SBA) loan failure rates. The list is dotted with sub sandwich shops, fitness centers and car shops. WORST FRANCHISE LOAN FAILURES Failure % 1 OBEE'S SOUP SALAD SUBS 55.56% 2 LADY OF AMERICA 41.94% 3 COUNTRY CLUTTER (BED & BREAKFAST) 41.18% 4 COPY CLUB 36.36% 5 ALL TUNE AND LUBE 35.71% 6 PICKERMAN'S 35.71% 7 PHILLY CONNECTION 35.59% 8 ROLY POLY ROLLED SANDWICHES 34.78% 9 COTTMAN TRANSMISSION 34.48% 10 HAIR COLOR EXPRESS 33.33% 11 LEE MYLES AUTOMOTIVE TRANSMISSIONS 33.33% 12 GODFATHER'S PIZZA 33.33% 13 SMOOTHIE FACTORY 33.33% 14 BLIMPIE 31.39% 15 GOLF U.S.A. (RETAIL GOLF EQUIP.) 30.77% Source: Small Business Administration, SBA Loan Performance Within Franchise Code for the Period of FY 2001 - 2005
Success Strategies - How to get the results you want now? Success Strategies and Action Steps I have used are: The Power of Choice Where you are at this present moment, is exactly perfect from the choices you have made. If you want to be somewhere else, you have to decide clearly what that is (your goal/outcome) and create action steps to achieve this. The Power of Focus The book "The Power of Focus" by Jack Canfield, Mark Victor Hansen and Les Hewitt, is one of my treasures in my Entrepreneur Library. If you focus on what you want versus what you do not want, your conscious and sub-conscious mind will direct attention to this. The movie, What the Bleep, Down the Rabbit Hole, explains this in detail about quantum physics and what we create in our lives. The Power of Commitment This is not about commitment to others. The first step is the commitment, your word, you make to yourself. Accountability and responsibility are additional success strategies and ingredients to creating the success, defined by you, that you want. The commitment to others reflects your integrity, your word and the team you work with. Co-workers, clients, yoru family, friends and community. My Success Acronyn in Success Breakthroughs(c) is: S pecific & self-directed U nlimited opportunities & possibilities C reate powerful outcomes C onsistent measureable results E xperience pwoerful transformation S olution and action-oriented S uccessful habits and outcomes Break Through to Powerful LIfestyle & Performance Choices Moira


Share this article with your friends. Fund someone's dream.

Leave a comment below or share on the left and you'll help support entrepreneurs in Africa through our partnership with Kiva. Over $50,000 raised and counting - Please keep sharing! Learn more.

Newsletter

Get advice & tips from famous business
owners, new articles by entrepreneur
experts, my latest website updates, &
special sneak peaks at what's to come!

Name:
Email:

Popular Articles

The Importance of Master Data Management (MDM)

Fighting the Saw-Tooth Affect

Clues to Increase Sales -- Listen to the Buyer

Suggestions

Email us your ideas on how to make our
website more valuable! Thank you Sharon
from Toronto Salsa Lessons / Classes for
your suggestions to make the newsletter
look like the website and profile younger
entrepreneurs like Jennifer Lopez.