Tweet

Employment Reference Checks - Providing and Receiving

Written by: Dinah Bailey

Article Overview: It’s becoming more and more challenging for companies to conduct employment reference checks on potential new hires. It’s not only frustrating to those doing the hiring but also to those looking to be hired.

Employment Reference Checks - Providing and Receiving

It's becoming more and more challenging for companies to conduct employment reference checks on potential new hires. It's not only frustrating to those doing the hiring but also to those looking to be hired.

Gone are the days when a former employer openly shared insights into a departed employee's performance and productivity. These days, your lucky to confirm the basics such as job title and employment dates. A company's Human Resource representative is more likely to only share the bare minimum of information required.

Contacting a potential new employee's former managers, coworkers and even character references will hopefully produce the results you require but not always. Some people are very hesitant to provide any information at all!

One of the reasons for this shift is due to tighter privacy legislation resulting in a reduced comfort level that once may have existed in sharing feedback on performance - employers aren't sure what they can and cannot say for fear of reprisal.

Increased litigations are another cause for alarm in providing input on former employees. There have been reported cases where employers/managers have given inaccurate or even negative references, which ultimately prevented employees from getting hired.

As well, employment reference checks fall under a legal category of "qualified privilege" where the candidate is protected under claims where the chances of being hired were depleted due to a former employer not providing a reference of any kind.

Even if a former employer is willing to respond to questions, at times the only response is you may get out of them is a "yes" or "no" answer. From the candidate perspective, this can be viewed as a hindrance in getting made the job offer as usually employment is pending on successful reference checks.

Here are some helpful tips to remember when providing and conducting employment references:

• If possible, have the same representative from your company conduct reference checks to maintain consistency in questions being asked and to avoid miss-use of information collected
• When giving a reference check on a former employee, answer questions honestly, even if negative, as employers can only be sued if the responses provided are false and dishonest
• Ensure the person providing the reference doesn't have an axe to grind with the former employee as this may result in inaccurate information and potential litigation issues
• As part of the hiring process, request the candidate sign a waiver stating they agree to release contact names and numbers for reference checks so as not to have any miscommunication with whom to contact for feedback
• Refer to the reference check as a "conversation" when calling the reference in order to open up the conversation with a more informal approach
• Ask open ended questions to avoid the straight yes and no responses
• Never gain a reference from anyone the candidate hasn't given authorization to contact - again use a waiver to protect both the company and the candidate
• Prepare questions in advance and be consistent with each candidate to avoid discrimination issues if the person isn't hired based on the reference results
• Be objective and not overly anxious to hire the first candidate to walk through the door - do the homework to avoid costly repeat hiring
• Probe to get more detailed responses to your questions if you aren't satisfied with the answer.

Reference checking is time consuming and often frustrating. It's a task that many don't enjoy conducting or will sometimes leave out of the hiring process all together. It's a small amount of time spent to persevere through this hiring step, as the outcome is valuable in ensuring productive members are added to the team.

Related Articles
  Don’t Avoid the Chance to Check Job References
  Employment References Are So Important
  The Employment Tests Myth
  The Background Credit Check Under Fire: Fair or Not?
  Where Do You Stand on Employment Background Checks?

Article Tags: bare minimum, character references, coworkers, employment dates, employment reference, employment references, helpful tips, hindrance, human resource representative, job offer, job title, legal category, negative references, new hires, privacy legislation, privilege, productivity, reference checks, reprisal, ul class



Related Forum Posts
Marketing a company - Jeff, I know who my target market is: Defense contractor doing business with the Federal Government My product is: Providing security consulting services for companies that must abide the National Security requirements. How can I inform theses contractors about my services? Thanks Diane
Startup Challenges - Kevin - it's a great read - you should pick it up! John - what kind of services are you offering? Your signature says "Providing Big Business Resources to Small Businesses" I have always found big companies to be hard to work with and slow to make decisions but smaller companies are more risk-tolerant and understand the online world.
Re: Looking for partners to start career consulting business - Hi Mike, 1) I'm moving this to the Looking For section 2) I think a good start would be to seek out local, potential competing or related organizations/companies in your area. Universities, job centres, head hunters, HR professionals...etc. [quote:34k2gxrf]It will target professionals who want to start working at executives or higher level positions but lack necessary experience.[/quote:34k2gxrf] And I think it'll definitely help if you align your products/services with your target customer group. i.e. How do you plan to seek out this group? -------> Find the necessary talent that can accomplish this. i.e. Providing internship --------> Training in-house? Or training outsourced? Again, seek talent that aligns with your objectives. Break down what your business operations would be like, then seek the appropriate talent to cover that area. Of course, you don't want to give up too much equity by seeking out too many partners. Usually lower number of founders the more likely the start-up will survive. Good luck
Referral strategy - Hi Andy - here are some of my thoughts: 1) It could work depending on the demographic. Sometimes incentives work very well to generate referrals and other times they don't. I remember when Intuit announced a cash referral program for their customers. The reaction was not positive. Customers said they are happy to refer their friends on because they loved the product and did not want to feel like they are "selling" their friends. Others, however, love being affiliates and base their entire business on this type of model. Test it and see the reaction. It may work out and it may not. It will probably be a nice add-on but I wouldn't rely on it as my main marketing strategy. 2) Why limit it to 2? Like any other community you're going to have people who really take to your idea and others who won't. You want to create champions of the customers who refer so why limit it to 2? Providing an ongoing revenue stream to your referral partners is a great way to bring in new business. 3) I agree about them paying up front first. By "credit" do you mean he'll be paying them $300 cash or does it go towards other products / services he is offering?
Re: Politeness! - [quote="Alan Mater":2azwy72a][quote="mbrand2222":2azwy72a][quote="Alan Mater":2azwy72a] All we can do is be a light in this dark world and lead by example. Alan[/quote:2azwy72a] Providing an incentive is a great way to teach children manners and politeness. I remember back when I was in 4th grade our teacher gave us prizes for sitting still and being quiet right before the end of school. Throughout the year it was just out of control, so she decided to reward those that behaved. Eventually you had every kid sitting still and being quiet. There's something about earning something that makes kids listen. This is the same basic idea, and it's great to see how you used it to teach kids to say please and thank you. Those two phrases will get them very far in life.[/quote:2azwy72a][/quote:2azwy72a] I used to have a system called Brand Bucks that would allow them to earn tokens that they could buy prizes with. I gave them out for positive actions and took some back for negative. It worked really well. They hated giving them up because they each had a prize they were saving for.


Share this article with your friends. Fund someone's dream.

Leave a comment below or share on the left and you'll help support entrepreneurs in Africa through our partnership with Kiva. Over $50,000 raised and counting - Please keep sharing! Learn more.

Tweet

Newsletter

Get advice & tips from famous business
owners, new articles by entrepreneur
experts, my latest website updates, &
special sneak peaks at what's to come!

Name:
Email:

Popular Articles

The Right Job - Part Five 'Compensation'

Why Small Businesses Don't Survive

Entrepreneurs and the “Oh! No!” Trap

Suggestions

Email us your ideas on how to make our
website more valuable! Thank you Sharon
from Toronto Salsa Lessons / Classes for
your suggestions to make the newsletter
look like the website and profile younger
entrepreneurs like Jennifer Lopez.