Tweet

Just My Opinion: Should Companies Not Hire The Unemployed?

Guest post by: Dianne Shaddock

Article Overview: In taking in applicants, is there a vested favor granted to employed applicants? This article discusses the seemingly increasing trend of hiring employed applicants. It also shows the fact that there are a lot of unemployed talents out there waiting to be given a chance.

Just My Opinion: Should Companies Not Hire The Unemployed?

"Have you seen the article that highlights why human resources is skipping over unemployed job applicants in favor of employed job applicants?" "Is this really what HR people are doing?" This was the question posed to me by a very talented, extremely professional, yet unemployed colleague.

"Is this really what HR people are doing?"

I had not read the article before the question was posed to me.

The article, "Out Of Work Job Applicants Told Unemployed Need Not Apply" is all the buzz for those who have seen it in HR circles. It was even shared in an HR group that I'm a member of on Linked In.

I read the article. It describes how companies are posting job listings with the caveat that the unemployed "need not apply" and that this sentiment is growing more popular among recruiters.

As an HR professional and as someone who has recruited, assessed, interviewed and hired, 100′s of employees, the article really touched a nerve. It made me step back and take a look at my hiring practices. Do I have a bias against the unemployed?

I'd like to think that I've assessed every qualified job applicant fairly, but wouldn't we all like to think this way? What if I, or the hiring managers I've supported have held some type of conscious or subconscious bias and what factors are driving the bias? The article provoked some soul searching on my part.

A lively discussion from HR professionals ensued on Linked In. It seems that the majority of commentators felt that this bias does not exist or that it is extremely rare.

I too joined the conversation on Linked In:

"Unfortunately, so many companies use budget cuts as an excuse to lay off their underperforming workers instead of laying off workers based on the job that they perform and how that role impacts the business.

It has become easier for some not to manage and choose to layoff underperforming workers rather than dealing with performance management.

With these types of practices, it's not surprising that you have situations where HR and hiring managers alike are becoming distrustful of the candidate pool.

We as HR practitioners should continue to conduct thorough interviews and thoroughly check references for all potential candidates. We should be using our networks to learn as much as we can about candidates that we are considering and not pre-judge candidates before we have done our homework. And, we should be making sure that we are managing our underperforming employees with the goal of improving performance and behavior within our organizations instead of ignoring issues and taking the easy way out when it's time to eliminate staff.

There are a lot of really good people out there who are unemployed and we are doing them a disservice if we are writing them off even though they are qualified on paper for job opportunities.

Even poor performers deserve a second chance as sometimes it's a situation of job fit, or conflicting styles between the supervisor and the employee that results in an employee being labeled a poor performer.

I'm sure I'm preaching to the choir in most cases, but I feel strongly that we need to take the reigns as HR professionals and do the right thing for our job candidates."

This is essentially my response to my very talented, yet unemployed colleague.

Just my opinion.

Related Articles
  Hiring Incentives to Restore Employment Act (HIRE)
  Quick Tips For Hiring In A Recession
  100 Days of Sodom
  Startups and the Dilemma of the First Sales Hire
  Fake Job Reference Services
  Extending Unemployment Benefits Won’t Prepare People for Jobs
  Unemployed, Great! Time to Find Out who you Really Are
  The Unemployed You: Battling Through the Waiting Game (Part One)
  5.3.4 The unemployed: Public sector training
  Finely Unemployed, The True Mark Of Success for an Entrpreneur
  Money Saving Tips To Rent A Car
  Earnings and Unemployment
  Join an Easy Home Based Business Opportunity - Misleading Government Unemployment Numbers for April
  Discover the Benefits of Applying User Generated Content to Your Online Income Business
  Why Is Business /Life Coaching So Popular
  3 Powerful Excuses for Maintaining Mediocrity in Your Sales Hiring
  How Did We Do? Perfect of course!
  When I Ask Your Opinion
  Unemployed And I Need a Job Today-Best Work at Home Job Reviews-Multilevel Network Marketing
  Earn Extra Money At Home With Online Jobs

Article Tags: best management practices, Employer Responsibilities, Finding the best candidates, Help with Hiring, Human Resources Help



Related Forum Posts
Profiling Famous Women Entrepreneurs - Great suggestion Leanne! The PROFIT Companies are always great sources!
Re: Moderators on vacation - Well what happens if you own a store or bar/restaurant? You're up at the crack of dawn to do prep work, and the last one there late at night closing... open 7 days a week... what can such an entrepreneur do for time off? Hire a trusted manager?
Hiring good people - Thanks everyone. From the PROFIT companies the success formula seems to be: - Give employees responsibilities that make them stretch themselves - Provide them with a good work environment and happy co-workers - Invest in them by giving them training - Build projects with them to give them some ownership of the idea - Make sure they fit your company culture And almost all of them say: Hire slow, fire fast.
How much is social media part of your marketing strategy? - Companies are ready to jump into social media to take "advantage", but what's lacking in most social media programs is an actual strategy. What are your tactics regarding this and how much time and budget do you invest?
Re: Top Banner Help - [quote:35xjo6uq]Good job on the banners BennyBoy![/quote:35xjo6uq] No probs:) I agree Online Marketing and Publicity Search Engine Optimization - Web Design and Programming Blogging also may be... Web Design Tutorials Looking to Hire - jobs section Interesting Articles / websites


Share this article with your friends. Fund someone's dream.

Leave a comment below or share on the left and you'll help support entrepreneurs in Africa through our partnership with Kiva. Over $50,000 raised and counting - Please keep sharing! Learn more.

Newsletter

Get advice & tips from famous business
owners, new articles by entrepreneur
experts, my latest website updates, &
special sneak peaks at what's to come!

Name:
Email:

Popular Articles

Using your social media profiles to drive traffic

2011 Global Brand Trends Letter

The State of the Sustainable Furniture Industry

Suggestions

Email us your ideas on how to make our
website more valuable! Thank you Sharon
from Toronto Salsa Lessons / Classes for
your suggestions to make the newsletter
look like the website and profile younger
entrepreneurs like Jennifer Lopez.