For many people, both in and out of business, one of the hardest things to do is listening to experts. Why? Because experts generally give advice that runs contrary to what people want to hear. Experts are not always right, but their opinions are worth consideration, especially if all you have to go on is a gut feeling.
There are two television shows where people generally ignore the experts to their own detriment. On Cops, as police officers try to sort out circumstances, they continually tell people, “Sit down and be quiet.” But as Blue Collar comic Ron White says about his own arrest, “I had the right to remain silent . . . I just didn’t have the ability.” On Cops, people ignore police advice, even after several warnings and are finally hauled off to jail.
On the antique show Bargain Hunt, David “Cheap as Chips” Dickinson provides two separate teams with two hundred pounds and an expert. The teams then have an hour to roam around a flea market and purchase two or three items, which are sold at auction a week later. The team that makes the most money gets to keep the profit. However, there usually isn’t very much profit because the teams don’t listen to their experts all that much.
On a recent episode the two women of the Blue Team came up with a child’s chair. The expert suggested a different child’s chair for about the same price of 20 pounds. The expert’s chair was from the previous century, had “turned” rather than “straight” supports, and had some worn spots that gave the chair character. The Blue Team chose the one they found rather than the expert’s find, because they liked it.
Next the team came back with a metronome, which wasn’t that old and made odd sounds. The expert voiced disapproval and gave his reasons. His opinion was ignored. Finally, the Blue Team approved the purchase of a wooden collection box the expert suggested for only 11 pounds. I think the Blue Team approved it because they felt guilty. The expert seemed relieved.
The Red Team didn’t take all of their expert advice either, but they listened enough to make a 24 pound profit. The Blue Team made a profit of 14 pounds, which mostly came from the expert’s collection box. The box sold of 28 pounds, making a whopping profit of 17 pounds, but that wasn’t enough to offset the Blue Team’s combined loses with the child’s chair and the metronome.
When given expert advice, the first thing we need to do is listen. The second thing to do is evaluate. If an expert’s opinion runs completely against what we want to do, then we should consider changing our opinions. We should remain silent and make our final decisions based on facts and reasoning, not on our hopes and feelings.
Bargain Hunt: Listening to the Experts - To learn more about this author, visit Don Doman's Website.
Like this article? Share it with your friends
|
|
Don Doman's
Complete
List Of
Human-Resources
Articles
|
|
|
If you enjoyed this article, get Don Doman's Complete List of Human-Resources Articles For FREE!
|
| |
|
|
|
![[Get Copyright Permissions]](http://license.icopyright.net/images/icopy-w.gif){kind=small}
Have you heard of the concept called “disrupt-then-reframe”? The theory is that you introduce a non-sequitur or unexpected element into your pitch and then immediately inject a call-to-action. The disruption theoret...
