Tweet

The Ranking Question in Coaching & Why it is Flawed

Written by: Angus M Main

Article Overview: The Ranking Question, 'so, from zero through to ten how much...' and variations is used very often by practitioner coaches to help the coachee calibrate their experiences, motivations and commitments. However, it can be flawed. Here's why!

The Ranking Question in Coaching & Why it is Flawed

Many coaches use questions of the type, "so, from nought to ten, how motivated are you". This Ranking Question can be a helpful tool for both coach and coachee but it can be a flawed device - sometimes it is severely limiting. Here we identify its weakness and a methodology for improved use.

The Ranking Question was developed to provide a rough measure of coachee state and to provide a focus for 'gap management' where the desired state and present state differ. For example, it is very often used to quantify the level of:

• commitment
• motivation
• perfection in revisiting a previous (psychological) state
• exquisiteness in taking on a perceptual position
• reality in reaching a future-desired state
• ability in creating an anchored state

In its most simplistic use, a coach may ask, "so, nought to ten, how exquisitely do you now feel that you in the University Great Hall in 2009?" and the answer, "ten" or "totally" might reasonably be accepted by the coach as adequate enough to move on. Many coaches in group settings will accept an eight or nine as being good enough to draw a line. The more able the coach, then the more associated information is being gathered to enhance their understanding of the coachee's answer. Body language and auditory qualities in the voice provide clues for example. And, how authentically to they appear to be? Whenever the coach has doubt, this is checked with the coachee by posing another question and checking it out with them.

Some years ago I was observing a coaching session in which the coachee responded to the Ranking Question with the answer "seven", The ensuing few minutes led to a number of dead-ends because the coach had not realized that seven happened to be the coachee's maximum on a scale of zero to ten; they never scored anything higher than seven in any context[1]. Subsequently, in a similar situation, I tend to ask another question such as:

And what is the highest level you can imagine achieving?

The answers people give vary enormously but so far all have fallen between six and ten[2] with the majority between eight and nine. I now feel that a better question than the Ranking Question might be:

If there was a scale or numbers that measured a very low motivation to the highest you can imagine, what would that scale be and where are you now on that scale?

It is rather too complicated and it would run contrary to your objective if you were attempting to preserve 'state' in your coachee. Their state would likely be broken because of the sheer amount of processing needed by them to interpret the question, ponder upon that interpretation and then compose an answer! So, after all, it may be best advised to stick with the familiar Ranking Question and use the additional question if needs must.

Gap Management and Commitment to Goals

When the Ranking Question is used for an early assessment of the coachee's likelihood of reaching a goal you may still find a gap between their current level and the highest level of commitment that they can imagine. Naturally the coach wants to resource the coachee and close the gap. Typical NLP methods include time-lines or Sensory Journeys, Away-Froms and Towards, state anchoring, metaphoric transformations and so on. Personally I do not stick to the Ranking Question over time, the crunch question is often a blunt but effective instrument:

So, will you have achieved that by 2pm this Thursday or not?

Clearly it is not just the answer or body language that provide certainty but the speed and energy of the response that provides confidence.

---

[1] It is very common to find such recalibrations of the 0-10 scale however I often discover that an individual coachee has different maxima in different contexts.

[2] I have now used this several hundred times over about three or more years.

Related Articles
  Why Every Internet Marketer Need to Know How Alexa Works
  ••••••>GetMeOnTop SEO Website Surpasses Facebook, Microsoft, Fortune and Hotjobs. Google just 1 point higher!
  "If I'm Perfect, No One Will Reject Me" - Healing Perfectionism
  Tips for Improving Website Search Ranking
  Coaching A Perfect 10

Article Tags: coaching, commitments, improvement, motivations, ranking question



Related Forum Posts
Re: Alexa Ranking Goals - Thanks Jeremy - here is my updated goal: Goal: 10,000 Original Ranking: 14,830
Question of the Week: What's the first thing you do every mo - Question of the Week: What's the first thing you do every morning to get ready for the day?
Question of the Week: What's your favorite productivity tool - Question of the Week: What's your favorite productivity tool? Please share below - I'd love to see what everyone is using!
Harsh reality - I am a patent agent and an entrepreneur. Two questions. Question 1: Are you willing to invest $60K and two years into this invention? If YES Question 2: How can you protect your investment? This may seem harsh but if you don't invest who will. In my opinion, a patent has zero value, (and is in fact a liability), until the invention that it protects is generating or dang close to generating revenue, with a chance for profit. A patent is an insurance policy. Like every insurance policy, you have to buy before you know what's going to happen. My typical patent preparation fee is $6-9K. Is it worth it? That depends. Is your life insurance policy worth it? That depends. The real value in any invention is the business that is built around it. If you have what it takes to build a business around an invention then filing a patent is a business decision. Like all business decisions you make it and you keep going. If it was a bad decision, you deal with it.
Famous Entrepreneur Question? - First name to come to mind was Sam Walton. After reading his aoutbiography, I feel so connected to him. My one Question would be...(after getting on one knee) "Would You Mentor Me?''


Share this article with your friends. Fund someone's dream.

Leave a comment below or share on the left and you'll help support entrepreneurs in Africa through our partnership with Kiva. Over $50,000 raised and counting - Please keep sharing! Learn more.

Tweet

Newsletter

Get advice & tips from famous business
owners, new articles by entrepreneur
experts, my latest website updates, &
special sneak peaks at what's to come!

Name:
Email:

Popular Articles

2011 Global Brand Trends Letter

Five Ways to Show Honest Appreciation

Unharnessing Creativity in Business

Suggestions

Email us your ideas on how to make our
website more valuable! Thank you Sharon
from Toronto Salsa Lessons / Classes for
your suggestions to make the newsletter
look like the website and profile younger
entrepreneurs like Jennifer Lopez.