Tweet

Passion Trumps Engagement...And Annihilates Satisfaction

Written by: James R. Lucas

Article Overview: Employee satisfaction may not be a bad thing, but it could be a huge distraction from giving people what they really need at the core - to make a difference, to do valuable work, to count. And it could be a bad thing if it shrinks people's souls and the organization's performance. With regard to people, passion does indeed trump engagement. And it annihilates satisfaction. And really, everything else.

Passion Trumps Engagement...And Annihilates Satisfaction

#1 The Problem:

The "buzz" in organizations for a long time has been around the concept of "employee satisfaction." In a way, it makes sense; it became a parallel for "customer satisfaction." There are companies making a good living off of measuring, assessing, and reporting on this supposed driver, "employee satisfaction."

But this metric is defective for a number of reasons - two of which I will mention here:

• There is no apparent connection between employee satisfaction and organizational performance. In spite of years of use and mounds of data, there is no convincing correlation between this metric and better results.
• People can be satisfied because we're paying them well or they have good benefits or they like someone at work or the logistics are easy - none of which mean anything for their commitment to deliver value. At the low end, they can be satisfied because we're taking care of them and not expecting much in return.

Employee satisfaction may not be a bad thing, but it could be a huge distraction from giving people what they really need at the core - to make a difference, to do valuable work, to count. And it could be a bad thing if it shrinks people's souls and the organization's performance.

Perhaps because of some of these defects, some firms have begun promoting "employee engagement." Now, this is certainly an improvement, if we're looking to have more productive employees and better results. The concept of people working hard at their jobs because they have a strong connection with their work makes a lot of sense. But if our goal is a better organization producing better results, we still have problems. I will name just a few:

• The focus is too narrow. People can work very hard at their jobs without seeing how those jobs relate to other areas, help them (or not), or create value (or not).
• People's interest in a specific job can dissipate over time. What happens to their engagement when the inevitable boredom and fatigue set in?

Engagement gets the edge over satisfaction, but they are fighting for a distant second place. You can go for first, for the gold medal that some organizations have already won.

#2 The Principle:

In a joint survey done by Luman Consultants International and the American Management Association, people in 755 organizations were asked to evaluate a list of potential drivers of high performance.

The highest-rated factor? Well, it wasn't strategic planning - that came in second. Goals with measurement scored third place, while reward & recognition programs garnered fourth, and compensation & benefits landed fifth. But the winner by far was a committed workforce.

I've heard leaders say, "people first, strategy second," many times over the years. Well, now you have the proof that this proverb is on solid ground. But "people first" isn't coddling people or worrying about hygiene factors or trying to motivate them one play at a time. It's having a committed team, people who have the passion and focus to drive to victory, and a determination to never surrender.

So what is this "passion," the passion that leads to commitment?

We define passion as a choice to be wholeheartedly committed to achieving results and adding value. It is working with enthusiasm and energy and vigor to build something excellent. Although passion can include emotion, it is more of a choice than a feeling - people can be quiet and still quite passionate. Passion is characterized more fundamentally by focus and intensity and persistence and care than it is by externally observable behavior such as constant activity, high animation, or simply putting in long hours. Passion is the great differentiator in the people side of any organization.

As the only firm working in the "passion and commitment" space - and we've been working in it for 25 years - I can say categorically that these are the difference-makers. We've had public-company clients go from fourth to first quartile in 18 months, from trailing behind their peers to being best in their peer group. We've had (very) former double-digit growth companies find a new way - to sustainable growth. They succeed because they tap into the best of what it means to be a human being.

I recently had a senior executive put his division's current "satisfaction" scores in front of me and ask, "If our scores are so good, why is our performance so bad?" He knew instinctively that good scores on bad metrics yield...nothing.

So how do you become a Passionate Organization? How do you trump engagement and satisfaction with a winning hand?

#3 The Practice:

Become a Passionate Organization by transforming these seven areas of infrastructure:

1. Design. A Passionate Organization isn't achieved by motivational schemes or rah-rah speeches. It's a matter of designing a passionate culture using the 10 Key Elements of a Passionate Organization. If you've got them, you will see the fire. If you're missing even one of them, a passionate organization will be out of your reach.
2. Human Investment. Traditional HR/OD approaches to people as "resources" or "assets" are well-intentioned. However, using investment thinking dramatically changes the nature of the conversation about people and gives us a whole new way to attract and retain "winners and believers."
3. Commitment. The passion needs to be converted to sustainable commitment. This can be done using a variety of PMATs (Practices, Mechanisms, and Tools). Undirected passion won't get the job done. All true commitment is the result of directed passion.
4. Motivation. What gets talked about more than "motivation"? And yet, 95 percent of the material out there on the subject is either superficial (cheerleading, feel-good retreats, etc.) or schematic (reward and recognition, short-term incentives, etc.). Even talking about "self-motivation" won't get us where we want to go, unless we surround that powerful concept with principles and PMATs to make it real.
5. TeamsBuilding. Peter Drucker often said that most teams were failures. If we define "failure" as "not achieving your potential," then very few teams would be called a success. Converting passionate people into passionate teams is anything but automatic. Getting the right people onto the right kind of team, and launching it with passion, requires a little bit of work and a lot of smarts.
6. Emotional Management. Emotion is far and away the most powerful driver of human action, and yet most organizations do little or nothing to harness it. Just knowing about "personality types" and "emotional intelligence" is inadequate for building a Passionate Organization. It's possible to encourage strong, positive conflict, to discourage weak, negative consensus, and to use human emotion to drive results.
7. Emotional Firepower. Passionate organizations have a high level of Passion Capital, as measured by the Passion Intelligence Quotient. A high level of Passion Capital gives us something to draw on to develop new products and services, exploit new opportunities, solve big problems, and overcome even gigantic challenges.

With regard to people, passion does indeed trump engagement. And it annihilates satisfaction.

And really, everything else.

Related Articles
  4 Myths That Sink Most Sales Presenters
  What is Passion
  LEADER REDEFINE SUCCESS.
  Business and Entrepreneurship Passion not required
  Start With Passion!

Article Tags: apparent connection, buzz, correlation, customer satisfaction, distraction, employee engagement, employee satisfaction, job, jobs, li li, logistics, long time, mounds, nbsp, organizational performance, productive employees, spite



Related Forum Posts
Re: Some attractive terms in advertisement - [quote="lane_hug":sqdmyojl]Some terms can make the advertisement look more attractive, like unlimited, free, life time guarantee, and more. These should be definitely incorporated to ensure fast sales.[/quote:sqdmyojl] You've got to be careful with such terms, though. Take as an example the poor Korean dry cleaners who had the words "Satisfaction guaranteed" on their storefront window. They lost (supposedly) a pair of slacks from some loony judge, who proceeded to sue them for MILLIONS of dollars (over a $100 pair of slacks) because they did not provide him with satisfaction. [If the sign had said "Satisfaction guaranteed or your money back" perhaps none of it would have happened...] These days more and more people are apt to sue at the drop of a hat, and if you promise them something even though common sense says you wouldn't have meant what you said (for example Pepsi got in trouble because their commercial for Pepsi points, at the time the movie True Lies came out, featured a Harrier jet as in the movie. A few looney businessmen bought up all the points the could to get that jet, although they were told it had just been dramatic license, and ended up suing Pepsi for misleading advertising. The suit was dismissed, but the fact that the guy was able to find lawyers who'd even take the case on is scary. To cut a long story short, be careful what terms you use, and think to yourself what you'd have to do if people took them literally.
Hi Everyone! Looking for great mathy entrepreneurship books - I'm a young entrepreneur who's primarily interested in sustainable technology. As an engineer, I'm also fascinated with the math and statistics behind entrepreneurship. We all hear the scary numbers about how many companies last 5 years, but that's like saying that .1% of baseball bat swings lead to a home run- there's so many nuances that have an important (How good are most players? Are they even attempting to hit a home run? How many swings do most people take, total?) Two of my favorite books on the subject are: -Illusions of Entrepreneurship (affiliate URL removed by admin) which does a great job of breaking down the statistics by education, original income level, ect. The high-tech startups that dominate the headlines make up a vanishingly small percentage of total entrepreneurship (and very few entrepreneurs are Zuckerberg-aged) -Action Trumps Everything (affiliate URL removed by admin) (or free through Babson College: (affiliate URL removed by admin)) which is like 'entrepreneurship philosophy'. It goes beyond 'Illusions' dry stats and talks about strategies that are appropriate for such an unknowable world Does anyone else have suggestions for great entrepreneurship books?
Re: On taking Action - [quote="jvprosperity":1hd0zjku]I was surprised to not see the words along the lines of taking deliberate action within the article. Do yo think it's an important part of the 6 points Evan summarized from the article or is it implied?[/quote:1hd0zjku] Hi Andy, I think taking deliberate action is implied in the six points. For instance, I interpret them as follows: 1. Set your sights on where you’re going - Write your goals down on paper. 2. Educate yourself - Read everyday about your field and even take courses on it. 3. Passion pays off - Enjoy what you're doing. 4. Grow your money - Invest your money. 5. No guts, no glory - Go out and sell your product/service/self everyday as if it were last. 6. The Biggest Secret? Stop spending. - Put aside as much money as you can into savings your account/retirement fund.
The Old Girl's Network - (2003) - Haven't read this one yet... Contents A business of one's own: setting the stage Passion: Turning what you love into a real business Vision: Bringing Your Idea Into the World Pioneering Spirit: Discovering new frontiers Tenacity: Passions Bulldog Raising Capital: Translating your vision into dollars and cents Focus, feedback and flexibility Leadership lessons Life after the survival stage: Managing onward There's a Took Kit in the back that has lots of good stuff, including: Outline for competitive analysis: the basic issues to address before starting your company Outline for executive summary and business plan, with sample summary Explanation of non-disclosure agreement Milestone setting "Do you have what it takes" quiz Sample financing term sheet Due Diligence checklist Sample advisory agreement Process and systems review Outsourcing overview
The 7 Greatest Truths about Successful Women - Picked up a few books on my weekly trip to the library, thought I'd share their tables of contents. The 7 Greatest Truths about Successful Women: How You Can Achieve Financial Independence, Professional Freedom, and Personal Joy, by Marion Luna Brem. From the inside cover: In 1984, battling both cervical and breast cancer, and facing $500,000 in medical bills and a disintegrating marriage, Marion Luna Brem was desperate to find a way to support herself and her two young sons. With more than a few strikes against her, she started knocking on doors, looking for a job. Seventeen doors later, the blunt speaking manager of a car dealership in central TExas declared, "I've been thinking of hiring a broad." And with that invitation, Marion took her own first step on the road to financial independence, yada yada yada Today, this "broad" owns two automobile dealerships, an advertising agency, and a stake in a local bank. She sits on the boards of several businesses, etc. etc. 1. Who Wants to be her own boss? 2. Ladies, Start your engines 3. Resiliency 4. Nurturing 5. Intuition 6. Creativity 7. Passion 8. Self-Value 9. Sensitivity 10. Leadership 11. Balance


Share this article with your friends. Fund someone's dream.

Leave a comment below or share on the left and you'll help support entrepreneurs in Africa through our partnership with Kiva. Over $50,000 raised and counting - Please keep sharing! Learn more.

Tweet

Newsletter

Get advice & tips from famous business
owners, new articles by entrepreneur
experts, my latest website updates, &
special sneak peaks at what's to come!

Name:
Email:

Popular Articles

How To Be Happy at Work? Acknowledge Yourself

The Neglected Art of Receiving

What is the bottom line to you?

Suggestions

Email us your ideas on how to make our
website more valuable! Thank you Sharon
from Toronto Salsa Lessons / Classes for
your suggestions to make the newsletter
look like the website and profile younger
entrepreneurs like Jennifer Lopez.