The Truth About Staff Who Can't Perform

Let me tell you a quick story. When I started my first job as an apprentice engineer, I quickly realised that some of my fellow apprentices shouldn't be in the job. They just didn't have the aptitude or ability for engineering.

Back in those days, and I don't mean Victorian times, staff selection wasn't very sophisticated. All budding apprentice engineers were interviewed by a foreman, and if he liked the look of you; you got the job.
I was lucky enough to be interviewed by a foreman who, in his spare time, was a Captain in the Boys Brigade.  I was a member of another BB company; so guess what, I got the job.
Neither I, nor any of my fellow apprentices were ever tested for our ability, or for any natural talent we might have, for engineering.
Resultantly, many apprentices shouldn't have been there in the first place. However, most of them struggled on and qualified as time served engineers. The problem is, they didn't turn out to be particularly good engineers. And, I also suggest; weren't particularly happy engineers.

I've experienced customer service people who shouldn't be let anywhere near a customer. Secretarial assistants who couldn't spell or type fast enough; engineers who couldn't read blueprints and plumbers who couldn't plumb.

If you have someone in your team who is unable to do the job and is unable to learn, then you need to transfer them into something they can do, or advise and help them to find other employment. Now I know that may seem harsh and it's not always easy or feasible to release people, however, you'll never achieve your outcomes with the wrong person in the job.
The business may suffer and you're in great danger of de-motivating the other members of your team. They won't want someone on the team who can't do the job.

A client of mine realised that the customer service person, they'd recently employed, couldn't handle the pressure of difficult customers and situations. They realised that training wouldn't solve the situation, so they transferred her to a job where she produced quotations and didn't have to speak to a customer.
What you need to do is get people who can't do the job, into a job that they can do or get them out of your team.

I joined three companies as a manager and in each case I inherited team members who didn't have what it takes to do the job. I'd usually find three categories of people in the teams - The first group were the 'good guys,' the ones I knew could do the job and wouldn't give me any hassle.
The second group consisted of people who needed a bit of looking after, watching closely and definitely some coaching.
The third group were the ones who didn't have either the skills or the characteristics to do the job and no amount of training, or anything I could do, would change that.
I would often find that these people, due to their lack of success, weren't exactly happy in the job anyway and were sometimes only too pleased to be transferred to another position.

I hear you saying - "easier said than done Alan" and you're right. But the Motivational Manager needs to address these issues and 'bite the bullet' for the good of the team and the business.