Tweet

BOOK REVIEW: Abolishing Performance Appraisals: Why They Backfire And What To Do Instead (By Tom Coens & Mary Jenkins, Berrett-Koehler, 2000, ISBN #1-57675-076-0)

Written by: Ian Cook

Article Overview: Abolishing Performance Appraisals boldly presents the skepticism shared by a growing number of managers, human resource professionals, consultants and researchers: appraisals don’t do what they are purported to do and they cause a lot of other damage in the meantime. As the authors make a strong case for getting rid of formal appraisals altogether, they also address obvious concerns around rewards, compensation, and documentation to support legal action. This is a provocative and convincing read. Prepare to have your paradigms poked.

BOOK REVIEW: Abolishing Performance Appraisals: Why They Backfire And What To Do Instead (By Tom Coens & Mary Jenkins, Berrett-Koehler, 2000, ISBN #1-57675-076-0)

Nobody likes to do performance appraisals (PA’s). Nobody! Not even the Human Resources department. For them, it is a constant struggle to get line managers to complete them correctly and on time.

And there has scarcely been a client of mine that wasn’t in the process of revising their PA process. It always “needs updating,” or “we’re moving to a competency-based approach,” or “our objective this year is to update the form.”

So, why do so many organizations do (or at least go through the motions of doing) them? Well, they will tell you, a PA fosters better individual performance...it enhances communications and understanding between the manager and her staff...it motivates people...it enables the manager to coach and develop his employee... without it how would we determine compensation?...besides, we need documentation in case we have to discipline or fire an employee.

Abolishing Performance Appraisals boldly presents the skeptical position of a growing number of managers, human resource professionals, consultants and researchers: PA’s don’t do what they are purported to do AND they cause a lot of other damage in the meantime. Coens and Jenkins may be right. Perhaps PA is a toxic process for people—especially employees—to go through. Maybe the emperor is, in fact, wearing no clothes! Take a look at their case:

First of all, they list a number of false assumptions underlying the PA process, such as:

• A mandatory, organization-wide, onesize-fits-all annual face-to-face feedback process is effective for just about everyone in all functions and groups
• All our managers have the requisite interpersonal skills and sensitivity to give feedback accurately and counsel around emotional reactions to the feedback
• The boss has the prime responsibility for ensuring the employee performs and develops himself
• Ratings are objective enough to be perceived as fair and to motivate effort
• PA’s are objective enough to stand up in court
• People will withhold performance if they are not appraised and rewarded annually (i.e., they need their PA “fix” or they won’t continue to produce)

The authors’ chief contention is that the PA is a controlling, boss-driven, demeaning, and dependence-building device that, if anything, stifles intrinsic motivation in your employees. Furthermore, since systems and processes, not individual skills or effort, determine the bulk (W. Edwards Deming said 94%) of performance results, PA has too narrow a focus.

The authors make a strong case for getting rid of formal PAs altogether. They recommend replacing them with a work culture where the employee takes responsibility for soliciting feedback on her own performance and development. Removed from the emotional baggage of “the big appraisal meeting,” the manager/coach’s input will be more readily welcomed and acted upon. It should be noted, however, that the manager still has a responsibility to implement a formal process, if it becomes necessary, to address unsatisfactory performance.

What about compensation? Without performance ratings, how do you assign merit increases? They recommend you simply stop awarding merit increases, except for truly exceptional performance results, a situation that applies only to a handful of your employees. A merit component of 1–3% motivates only a few and upsets almost everyone else. Why? Because 98% of your people regard themselves as performing in the top half of the employee group and 80% place themselves in the top quarter. Instead of merit amounts, pay everybody a competitive market rate and timely cost-of-living increases plus team-based bonuses, gain-sharing, company- wide profit sharing, and the like.

As for PA documentation as a firewall against legal challenges to dismissal, Coens & Jenkins find formal appraisal information is frequently too inaccurate and inconsistent to support the employer’s case. Instead they counsel you, when required, to implement a formal corrective action process, including progressive discipline steps backed up by the requisite “paper trail” documenting meetings, critical performance incidents, and assistance you give the employee to remedy the situation. After all, the vast majority of your employees are good workers. Why force all of them to go through a performance appraisal in order to cover yourself against the very few?

So, how do you go about abolishing your PAs? Start with an honest look at your current appraisal process, how it is regarded, the results you are getting (e.g., motivated staff, increased communication with management, more accountable employees, performance turnarounds), and the assumptions about people, work, trust, motivation that underlie it. Then develop alternative processes to handle the major outputs of PA (coaching for development, performance feedback, compensation, motivation, promotions and downsizing, legal documentation). The book provides a thorough step-by-step process to gradually wean your organization off appraisals. However, it cautions that this constitutes a major change in the very culture of your enterprise and can take some time, even several years.

This volume serves us the way books such as In Search of Excellence and Stewardship have done. It challenges our status quo thinking. Does our traditional performance appraisal approach in fact perpetuate employee dependency on the “boss” and discourage self-motivation, initiative, creativity, accountability and enthusiasm- all hallmarks of today’s successful, high performance organizations?

This book is a must read for Human Resource professionals and for managers who care about accessing the full potential contribution of their employees.

Related Articles
  THE APOSTILLE PROCESS
  Improving Annual Performance Reviews
  Performance Appraisals
  Employee Review Writer
  TIME FOR BUDGETS BUT NO TIME FOR PERFORMANCE MANAGEMENT!

Article Tags: employee performance, human resources, performance, performance appraisals
Referred by: http://upwardaction.com



Related Forum Posts
Help me with my Publishing Empire - I'm currently compiling an ebook from the various articles I've written for my webzine, The Thunder Child. I'm not sure how many pages it's going to be.... But I've got a question. In doing research, I found a website that says if I want to sell my book online, I need to have an ISBN number, and it costs $225 (at the present moment) for 10 numbers. That's no problem... But, do I really need an ISBN number at all? I plan to take money via Paypal, and sell the book from my website and perhaps offer it for sale on Ebay. If it's less than a certain number of pages.... is an ISBN necessary? Or should I just get an ISBN regardless? I do intend to publish several more ebooks in the coming years....
Re: Help me with my Publishing Empire - [quote="OmnivoreInk":34mnyf36]I'm currently compiling an ebook from the various articles I've written for my webzine, The Thunder Child. I'm not sure how many pages it's going to be.... But I've got a question. In doing research, I found a website that says if I want to sell my book online, I need to have an ISBN number, and it costs $225 (at the present moment) for 10 numbers. That's no problem... But, do I really need an ISBN number at all? I plan to take money via Paypal, and sell the book from my website and perhaps offer it for sale on Ebay. If it's less than a certain number of pages.... is an ISBN necessary? Or should I just get an ISBN regardless? I do intend to publish several more ebooks in the coming years....[/quote:34mnyf36] Hey Barabara If you plan to add it to the major ebook distribution sites like Mobipocket (then tranferred to the Amazon Kindle program with the proper agreement in place) and Fictionwise - then you need an ISBN. One side note (unless policy changed lately) you need to have 10 ebooks to start an account on Fictionwise. But, to sell it yourself on your site and eBay etc - its not necessary. If it hits the big time, you could always release the 2nd edition and add an ISBN, but at this point, I don't see you need one. I'm working on a few ebooks that I will offer the same way myself and have no plans to buy ISBN's. Only the ones my publishers release have them and they buy them in bulk. Shri
Re: What the Best CEOs Know by Jeffrey Krames - [quote="ideasuniversity":w31gke82]Where can I get this book? Two of my mentors are in the book[/quote:w31gke82] I would check where ever you normally buy books. I checked Amazon and they have new, used and Kindle editions. These are the book details - # Paperback: 250 pages # Publisher: McGraw-Hill; 1 edition (September 19, 2005) # Language: English # ISBN-10: 007146252X # ISBN-13: 978-0071462525 Lots of great content and lots of useful info. Shri
Re: help wanted in u.k. - sorry for lack of input to post up until now to be honest i am not really a business person, and all the business terminology etc. disheartens me, What i need is someone to take a personal interest and share the believe in my invention and to take the patenting or manafacturing process on a little further, there is nothing worse i think than people trying to talk about business when it is something they know little about, (people often have no option i know) but i avoid that. My patent pending needs to be filed in the states before nov 2008. $2000 dollars i got as a quote (high i think) I am broke but i have got these valuable (i believe valuable) patenting rights. 2000 is not a big sum if it were to lead to patent rights in usa, "money for old rope" as they say brendan
Re: What About A Cumulative Story - As Jenkins got out of the elevator on the 17th floor that morning, little did he know what was about to happen. He would never look at a skinny double latte the same way again. This was because staring across the hallway was his rival, the same person who stole his business idea and made millions all those years ago. [i:ly7nqtzc]That skinny latte was just the weapon he needed as he walked across to confront Julian Webster, but just as he was about to throw it theatrically...[/i:ly7nqtzc]


Share this article with your friends. Fund someone's dream.

Leave a comment below or share on the left and you'll help support entrepreneurs in Africa through our partnership with Kiva. Over $50,000 raised and counting - Please keep sharing! Learn more.

Tweet

Newsletter

Get advice & tips from famous business
owners, new articles by entrepreneur
experts, my latest website updates, &
special sneak peaks at what's to come!

Name:
Email:

Popular Articles

Why Use an Advertising Agency

The State of the Sustainable Furniture Industry

What If You Had a 100% Success Rate?

Suggestions

Email us your ideas on how to make our
website more valuable! Thank you Sharon
from Toronto Salsa Lessons / Classes for
your suggestions to make the newsletter
look like the website and profile younger
entrepreneurs like Jennifer Lopez.