Evan Carmichael Top Header about About About facebook Twitter YouTube Google+

BOOK REVIEW: Why Pride Matters More Than Money: The Power of the World’s Greatest Motivational Force (By Jon R. Katzenbach, Crown Business, 2003, ISBN #0-609--61065-1)


Guest post by: Ian Cook
Become an Author

Free PDF Download
BOOK REVIEW: Drive: The Surprising Truth About What Motivates Us (By Daniel H. Pink, Riverhead Books, 2009, ISBN# 978-1-59448-884-9) - By Ian Cook

Name: Email:


Here is the author’s thesis, in a nutshell: an intrinsic feeling of pride based on the relentless pursuit of worthwhile endeavors is a lasting and powerful motivating force. By “pride,” he means that wonderful feeling of well being when your employees think they have done something worthwhile...and people whom they respect agree.

In 1991 a GM corporate official told the 3500 workers at the Wilmington Car Assembly Plant, “ To reduce costs, we’re shutting you down in three years. I’m afraid there’s nothing you can do to affect this decision.” When the official had left, Plant Manager Ralph Harding challenged his employees to make headquarters regret their decision. Harding galvanized the plant by creating problem-solving teams, sharing progress data on quality and costs, and engaging the union and the workers’ families. All of this activity was fueled by a rallying cry, “be the best.” The plant became the lowest cost producer of all GM plants. Auto dealers began requesting cars built in Wilmington. In the end, the fateful decision to close was reversed.

Why did they try? Why did they bother? The employees knew there was no hope, but they excelled anyway. It became a matter of pride, says Jon Katzenbach, the most powerful–yet strangely neglected–motivator available to managers today. Pride gets results. He quotes data from the Manufacturing Managers Council at General Motors. Their twenty best “pride builders” plants outscored other plants on safety (83, vs. 65), quality (53, vs. 47), cost (69, vs. 65) and people satisfaction (79, vs. 69).

Now, our left-brained, numbers-driven leaders do pay lip service to pride. They evoke it in speeches and in annual reports. They talk a lot about it but generally don’t really value it. And they fail to tap into its immense power. What a shame. What a wasted opportunity. Why? Because pride…

So, says Katzenbach, use good salaries and cash incentives to attract and retain good employees but evoke pride if you want them to excel. He goes on to say that this concept is not an easy one for executives whose efforts and behavior typically are driven by more rational motivators such as increase in shareholder wealth, return on capital, market share, and (not to be forgotten) power/position/influence.

Lower down in the organization closer to the front line, however, these bottom-line indicators don’t translate readily into factors that make sense to most employees. And such corporate metrics certainly tend not to be emotionally engaging to staff. This reality often puzzles and frustrates senior managers: “Don’t they realize that without profits and growth, they won’t have a job at all?”

The author says that, for most employees, motivation must include a strong emotional component. Major pride-instilling factors turn out to be:

Katzenbach’s research suggests ways to instill in your employees what he calls “institution-building pride”–where personal goals mesh with organizational goals and local team accomplishments support key business results. He recommends creating a scorecard of indicators that capture the attention and enthusiasm of your workers.

For example, Marriott has a Guest Service Index that shows how each employee is rated by the customers with whom he or she comes into contact. Employees know their individual GSI scores, their unit’s scores and how they compare with similar units at other Marriott properties. General Motors, with union involvement, created a scorecard that measures safety, people (absenteeism/training/suggestions), quality, responsiveness (time order in through to time product leaves the plant) and cost.

While this book offers ideas for instilling pride in peak performance work environments, its good news is that it is entirely possible to do the same thing in more traditional workplaces.

But the point that most caught my attention was an intriguing angle Katzenbach uncovered about pride as a motivator. The anticipation of feeling proud is just as strong a motivating force as experiencing the pride itself. This means you don’t have to achieve a tangible success before the power of pride kicks in. You can activate pride (“Imagine how great we’ll feel about ourselves and our contribution when we have…”) at the front end, before the effort has generated successful results!


Related Articles

  Leadership Styles - 5 Tips From the Guru
  Money & the Meaning of Life (Part 1)
  PRIDE IS AT THE BOTTOM OF LEADERSHIP:
  Money & the Meaning of Life (Part 2)
  Motivational Speakers For Your Company
  Zig Ziglar's Legacy to the Sales World
  Make money telling your story!
  Love And Happiness Work And Play, Dream On
  Streetwise Complete Publicity Plans
  Car College: Learn while you drive
  Core Desires Ignite the Conquering Force
  Achieving Peak Performance
  The Secret - Ancient Scrolls and Their Impact on the Sales Force
  Managing Cross-Cultural Conflicts – Expressive or Instrumental
  Letting go of our rule books
  Filling the Sales Pipeline Whos to Blame
  4.0 The state of women’s enterprises in Tanzania: Support for Growth-oriented Women Entrepreneurs in Tanzania, 2005
  Leadership Eureka
  Leading Cross-Cultural Conflict Resolution
  Creating An Environment of Trust Support and Teamwork in Your Business

Home > Leadership > Ian Cook > BOOK REVIEW Why Pride Matters More Than Money The Power of the Worlds Greatest Motivational Force By Jon R Katzenbach Crown Business 2003 ISBN 0609610651 >
Referred by: http://upwardaction.com
Free PDF Download
BOOK REVIEW: Drive: The Surprising Truth About What Motivates Us (By Daniel H. Pink, Riverhead Books, 2009, ISBN# 978-1-59448-884-9) - By Ian Cook

Name: Email:

About the Author: Ian Cook

RSS for Ian's articles - Visit Ian's website
Ian helps managers become the "best bosses" their employees ever had.

Through his keynote presentations, highly interactive training workshops, team building facilitation and individual coaching, he helps his clients develop strong leaders at all levels of their organization.

Ian works primarily with managers, mid-level to executive. His programs introduce cutting-edge skills and concepts around

- transforming managers into leaders
- fostering superior team performance.

Ian began his training and consulting firm, Fulcrum Associates Inc., in 1988, following seventeen years of corporate experience in both the high-tech manufacturing and transportation industries. He has a Bachelor of Commerce from McGill and a Masters degree in the field of Human Resources Management from Cornell University. Ian holds the Certified Speaking Professional (CSP) designation and is a presenter to Vistage International groups.
Click here to visit Ian's website.
Dashed Line

More from Ian Cook
BOOK REVIEW A Leaders Legacy By James M Kouzes Barry Z Posner JosseyBass 2006 ISBN 9780787982966
Dealing With Resistance The 4 2 Method
Want Greater ROI From Your Meetings Six Questions That Will Make The Difference
What if We Brought in a Facilitator
Ouch It Hurts To Think This Much Communicating Performance Targets

Related Forum Posts

Help me with my Publishing Empire Help me with my Publishing Empire
How to valuate a business How to valuate a business
Re: Help me with my Publishing Empire Re: Help me with my Publishing Empire
Re: Stay positive! Re: Stay positive!
Re: What the Best CEOs Know by Jeffrey Krames Re: What the Best CEOs Know by Jeffrey Krames

Share this article. Fund someone's dream.

Share this post and you'll help support entrepreneurs in Africa through our partnership with Kiva. Over $50,000 raised and counting - Please keep sharing! Learn more.
Share for a Cause
Featured Article



Worksheets
By: Evan Carmichael

Do you have what it takes to be an entrepreneur?

8 Powerful Steps to Finding Your Passion

Does your pitch suck?

Create a plan of attach to launch your new business.

8-Cover

Like this page? PLEASE +1 it! Evan Signature
Bottom Footer



Newsletter

Get advice & tips from famous business
owners, new articles by entrepreneur
experts, my latest website updates, &
special sneak peaks at what's to come!
Name:
Email:
Popular Articles

Six Easy Steps to Creating a Killer Ad Campaign.

How to Start a Dry Cleaning Business

What Is Counselling, What Is Psychotherapy?

Suggestions

Email us your ideas on how to make our
website more valuable! Thank you Sharon
from Toronto Salsa Lessons / Classes for
your suggestions to make the newsletter
look like the website and profile younger
entrepreneurs like Jennifer Lopez.