Tweet

Dealing With Resistance: The 4 + 2 Method

Written by: Ian Cook

Article Overview: Six steps for responding to resistance. Combines principles from both Aikkido and Gestalt Psychology into a practical approach that first acknowledges an employee's resistance (and power not to cooperate) and then opens him/her up to consider and accept the rationale for your position or performance expectations.

Dealing With Resistance: The 4 + 2 Method

We’ve all lived this before. Sally, the manager, asks her employee Gary to prepare a market analysis report for next week. Gary moans and says he doesn’t think he can do it by then... too much work and, besides, why not give it to Sherry who has a marketing background. The manager detects the “I don’t wanna” whine and feels the heavy inertia of Gary’s heels digging in.

At that moment what Sally really wants to do is to respond in the old style of leadership, with both barrels blazing: “I don’t want any excuses, Gary, just see that YOU have that on my desk by Tuesday!” or the much more subtle “There you go again, Gary. Don’t you think it’s about time you showed some initiative around here?”

In fact, this is a common, yet absolutely critical, point of choice for any manager. Does Sally or does she not choose to assume responsibility for making Gary change his behavior and attitude? She does when she decides to challenge the resistance by overpowering it or manipulating Gary with guilt or threats.

Tempting as it might be, this approach does not really accomplish what Sally, the leader, wants. It might generate Gary’s short-term compliance but what she sacrifices is his longer-term commitment, creativity and productivity. By trying to make the resister do her bidding she will shift herself into the parent position and maneuver him into the role of the child.

In Gestalt psychology this situation is called the “Top Dog/Under Dog” dynamic. The Top Dog is the boss, the master, the authority figure, the one who seeks a certain behavior from the other person. The Under Dog is the– ostensibly–powerless one, the slave, the victim and the one from whom the behavior is being demanded. But who has the real power in the long run? The Under Dog does. It is he/she who ultimately determines whether or not cooperation will be forthcoming.

So, if browbeating a resister just heightens the resistant force, what’s a leader to do? The answer lies in understanding what the Under Dog truly wants. The resisting Under Dog wants to be acknowledged, to be heard, to have his or her point-of-view honored–not necessarily agreed with.

This last point is critical for leaders to grasp. When someone resists your will no one expects you to just cave in and abdicate your responsibility for performance results. At the same time, if you can make the resister feel heard and truly understood by you, he/she will be more inclined to consider your position and buy into it. Remember, one of Stephen Covey’s famous “7 Habits” is “Seek first to understand and then be understood.”

Here is a “cutting edge” approach that draws from both Gestalt psychology and the martial art of Aikido. I call this the 4 + 2 Method. There are six steps: the first four focus you on the other person. With the last two you assert your own needs.

1. Consciously acknowledge to yourself that you are encountering resistance.
2. Center yourself. (Use deep breathing or even a brief meditation, if you have time.)
3. In your own mind, consciously grant them permission to take the position they are adopting.
4. Explore, investigate, become curious about their resistance. (Use questions to find out about the source of their opposition.)



5. Declare your own perceptions, expectations, requirements and rationale.
6. Resolve/decide/act as you see fit. (Here you exercise your ultimate responsibility for performance results.)

Try it out on the next time you encounter a low-risk situation of resistance. Notice the response of the resister and how your own stress is reduced. With practice you will be surprised at how often you turn resistance into genuine support.

Related Articles
  The Enemy in Sales
  3rd of the 10 Kurlan Sales Competencies that are Key to Building a Sales Culture
  Managing Resistance
  The Art of Zero Resistance Allowing Your Business to Flow
  12 Steps to Implementing Anything in Your Business: Step Nine: Use Persuasion Skills

Article Tags: dealing with resistance, ian cook, performance expectations, resistance
Referred by: http://upwardaction.com



Related Forum Posts
Young Entrepreneur in International trading - I just turned 21 last week, and I currently own a international trading company doing trades between China, Taiwan, Thailand, and west coast of US and starting out in Canada soon. Dealing with gift items and general merchandise. We are also trying to sell some of the stuff we import as retail and wholesale products on the internet and to retail venders as we do have a lot of extra pallets that gets left over from our buyers.
Depressed Entrepreneurs - Thank you for your feedback. It seems to be the weather, isolation and some unfavourable projects getting my clients down. I personally find myself feeling quite grey with the weather. So much so that I spend as little time in my Vancouver office as I need to - it so slow and depressing there for me. In any case, thank you. Perhaps this is an issue we should be more proactive about in our entrepreneur resources. Dealing with the emotional issues of entrepreneurship. Thanks Kevin for the articles. The one was the exact one I was looking for. Must of been having a blonde moment in my searches
Simple way to avoid Cold Calling - Gary, A chiropractor I work with hates cold calling (me too!) and he uses a technique to warm people up to using his services - it's so simple! In Sales your dealing with 3 pools of people: 1. Strangers 2. Prospects 3. Returning Customers You need to move people from one pool to the next. We'll concentrate on #1 and #2 as it's most relevant to your question. My Clients does the following (you just have to tailor it to your situation - be creative). My Client (we'll call him Bob) Bob leverages his time and resources to only get people that need his offer (pain relief) to put their hand up. Dealing with Strangers can get expensive and they don't like to be told what to do as they have no trust or relationship built with him. So to get Strangers to put their hands up he writes up an offer with a free report on a particular pain relief - let's say lower back pain (note: he can simply just change lower back pain to neck pain and have a new report). and uses multiple marketing vehicles to promote the Free report - magazines, newspaper, forums, postcards, private clinics etc. The only people picking up this information are the very people Bob would like as customers as they have Lower back pain. Bob's Free report ends with him stating his services and includes a Free in-house Consultation with no obligation. You'd be surprised at how easily Bob converts Strangers into Prospects. Note: They become prospects when they ask for the Free Guide and in exchange provide their contact details. This gives Bob unlimited opportunity to contact them for the Free in-house consultation with no obligation to continue using him. At this stage Bob's ability to close the sale lies in his office providing good customer service, Bob's ability to help the prospect and provide value at the free in-house consultation. Notice, he hasn't had to pick up the phone to COLD-CALL his Stranger pool or his Prospect pool. Hope that example helps to increase your prospecting!
Self Development Tips - I find this old article about self development and very liked it. I think here a lot practical rules! As long as you are still alive, you are capable of changing and growing. You can do anything you want to do, be anything you want to be. Listen to some positive thoughts on how to continue your self development and then apply them in your own life. 1. Accept personal responsibility for your own growth; no one can do it for you. What you do today will determine your readiness for tomorrow. 2. Take time every day to do something for yourself. 3. Take classes to stay current in your field of expertise. The world is changing rapidly and you must learn to manage change to avoid obsolescence. The way Will Rogers put this was that "Even if you are on the right track, if you just sit there you will get run over." 4. Listen to cassette tapes on personal and professional growth topics. 5. Never look back to the past - you only can control your actions in this instant, so what should you be doing right now? 6. Learn from "other people's experience" rather then having to try everything for yourself. It shortens the time needed to learn. 7. Dealing with a problem helps you learn patience and strengthens your management skills; it is good mental exercise. 8. Analyze, in a non-judgmental way, mistakes in which you were involved. It will help you to prevent these in the future. 9. Reward yourself when you catch yourself working on the most important priorities. 10. Never say something can't or won't be done. Keep looking for ways to do it. 11. After attending a seminar, report to your boss or other people in your organization, what the most important things are that you learned from the program. 12. Eliminate one time waster a week from your life. 13. Read a minimum of one chapter of a book a day. 14. Read a minimum of one book a month. 15. Be hungry for what life has to offer and go for it. 16. Decide what you really desire to do - then do it. 17. When you have the option of reading a book or listening to the cassette tape version of the program, listen to the tape. It will be more to the point and can be done while you are driving, jogging/walking, or getting other routine things done. 18. Develop a "master mind" group of four or five people with whom you can openly discuss ideas in a nonjudgmental way. 19. Develop yourself as a resource for others by networking. Find out who does what, when, and for whom. You may find excellent contacts for your future needs and for the needs of others you meet. 20. Work for balance in your life goals: family, financial, professional, social, spiritual, recreational. 21. Always keep your goals in mind as you start a new activity. 22. If you do a lot of work with the calculator, run the machine with the hand you don't use for writing. 23. Do not be afraid of failing at something. You can learn and change as a result of it. 24. The most difficult projects are opportunities for your biggest successes just as the most difficult people could become your strongest allies. 25. Put up pictures of your dreams and goals where you will see them frequently. They will remind you and aid you in focusing and visualizing your goal. 26. We all have the same 24 hours in a day. Learn from those people who get more done than you do. Perhaps you can find a way to improve what you are doing. 27. Find a nonjudgmental mentor who will help you by providing feedback, suggestions, challenges and support. 28. Identify some "models" and observe their style and actions. Do not copy them but learn from their experiences. 29. Learn from the errors you see others make as well as from their successes. 30. Fill your mind with positive ideas, thoughts and inspirations and you will have no room left for the negative. 31. Trade jobs with someone so you gain additional experience. 32. Ask for and accept lateral moves in the organization so you learn more about the entire operation. 33. Do more than your "self doubts" say you can. 34. Have confidence that you can get through and learn from anything and everything you experience. 35. Reward yourself with a treat when you have completed a learning objective. 36. Keep a daily journal, recording your thoughts, ideas, feelings and personal growth progress. 37. Ask questions, listen, then ask more questions. You will learn as well as help others learn. 38. Ask yourself, "How can I manipulate my fate?" 39. Do things with someone you respect. They will be supportive of you and you will learn from interacting with them. 40. Seek new information on projects for which you have responsibility. Look for new "ah ha" ideas all the time. 41. Challenge yourself to learn something new every day. 42. Remain flexible and constantly adaptable. 43. Be open to others and sincerely interested in them. You can learn from everyone you meet. 44. Mentally rehearse a new skill. Your subconscious does not know the difference between actual practice and mental rehearsal. 45. Keep a record of what you accomplished the previous day(s)/week. If you did not accomplish as much as you wanted, it gives you extra incentive to do better in the next time period. 46. Make notes of the questions you want answered. Then as the answers come to you, jot them down next to the question. 47. Work on overcoming personal, nonproductive habits; for example: overeating, smoking, gossip. 48. Keep an "Idea File" ring binder or notebook in which you record all new ideas. At least once a week in a standing appointment with yourself, review your ideas. Very interesting to know other practical self development tips.


Share this article with your friends. Fund someone's dream.

Leave a comment below or share on the left and you'll help support entrepreneurs in Africa through our partnership with Kiva. Over $50,000 raised and counting - Please keep sharing! Learn more.

Tweet

Newsletter

Get advice & tips from famous business
owners, new articles by entrepreneur
experts, my latest website updates, &
special sneak peaks at what's to come!

Name:
Email:

Popular Articles

Download a template or see a lawyer?

Halloween Howl Seven by Author Paige Agnew

Track Your Time for Increased Productivity

Suggestions

Email us your ideas on how to make our
website more valuable! Thank you Sharon
from Toronto Salsa Lessons / Classes for
your suggestions to make the newsletter
look like the website and profile younger
entrepreneurs like Jennifer Lopez.