Tweet

Is It Training or Education?

Guest post by: Patrick T. Malone

Article Overview: The word Training has been used to describe so many activities that the word has lost its meaning and value. In reality, most of the training in corporate America is education. Education provides knowledge but training provides the enhanced ability to perform. Consider this: Which gives the greatest return on investment – Education or Training – when it comes to leadership, teamwork, supervision, coaching sales and service? Training is the process of bringing a person to an agreed standard of proficiency by practice and instruction. Yet what is actually performed is mostly instruction with little to no practice.

Is It Training or Education?

The word Training has been used to describe so many activities that the word has lost its meaning and value. In reality, most of the training in corporate America is education. Education provides knowledge but training provides the enhanced ability to perform. Consider this: Which gives the greatest return on investment - Education or Training - when it comes to leadership, teamwork, supervision, coaching sales and service? Training is the process of bringing a person to an agreed standard of proficiency by practice and instruction. Yet what is actually performed is mostly instruction with little to no practice.

If you really wanted to be talented and proficient at something, would you:

1. Hire a motivational speaker?

2. Read a book?

3. Watch a video?

4. Attend a seminar?

5. Take an online course?

6. Practice with an expert coach?

If you wanted to dance, drive a car, play golf, tennis, ride a bike, play a musical instrument, etc. undoubtedly you would choose option six, coached practice. Here is where the difference between true training and education occurs. The first five options are education and what many companies invest in for management development, leadership skills, sales skills, supervision training and customer service training.

However, only through coached practice will you obtain a level of competence, an agreed to standard of proficiency. The reality is what most people call training today is nothing more than education. The performing arts, martial arts and athletics are activities that conduct true training. Those engaged in each of these endeavors are measured by their proficiency.

If the measure of competence is to know about the subject, then education is fine. Role-play is a simulation that gives the participant a deeper understanding. For some, role play is simply willingness to try it. How often has it been said, "I wonder if it will work in the real world?" For instance, if your loved one needed CPR, would you be comfortable using a person who had only taken an online course, or someone who had real CPR training?

For education and role-play, all training is self-induced. You make an attempt on your own and achieve a result. You modify the attempt until you achieve a result that satisfies you. For most, when this point is reached, training is finished and that is the difference between amateurs and professionals. Amateurs practice until they get it right; professionals practice until they can't get it wrong. Your best performers are continually practicing. Your average performers practice until they succeed once or twice, and your poor performers give up after a couple of attempts.

In a difficult economy, training is the first budget to be cut and usually the last to be restored or increased when the economy improves. Why? The general perception is that training doesn't work or last.

Coached practice is enough repetitions to get the feel of performing the task well and then the standard is raised to "how well" you can do it. In sports this is commonly referred to as "muscle memory." In business, practice should be tied to an agreed upon standard directly linked to a business metric. You learn to play notes on a musical instrument by high repetition to play a song well, so why shouldn't this same axiom be true for sales, leadership, management, supervisory or customer service skill

Most organizations have some level of ‘training' in the essential elements of business. Like any other ability, until they can be broken down into distinct skill elements that can be practiced through repetition, the expected results will continue to be disappointing.

Without defined measurable skills, field coaching will not be successful either. Unless the coach and the learner have a defined level of skill and agreed to measure of competence, how does the coach coach? To what standard does the coach coach?

Organizations in the training industry have been and continue to be part of the problem. Unfortunately, fads and entertainment are common within the industry. e-Learning is only popular because less time and money is wasted. Worse yet in some so-called training exercises, some participants have been put at risk, and some are actually injured, all in the name of business training. This is unconscionable and reflects poorly on the entire industry.

At The PAR Group, we admit to being guilty of developing our own e-Learning. With our PAR e- University, our primary goal was to create a blended learning so that time in the classroom was maximized for practice. However, we do know that some will just take the online course. What our firm learned is that if we did not have this option available, some clients pushed back on the amount of classroom time required. Once the e-learning option was available, the push back was for more practice time. By giving people a choice, they always choose the option for more coached practice.

So if you are charged with increasing the proficiency of your workforce to an agreed standard of performance, choose wisely. In a difficult economy, your job could hinge on understanding the difference between education and training.

Related Articles
  How To Get The Best Internet Marketing Education! ~GUARANTEE YOUR FORTUNE
  Driver Training: Which Types Are Best For Insurance?
  How To Find The Best Internet Marketing Education - Success Secrets Revealed
  6.3 Participatory skill development: For-profit and NGO training activities
  Did you know: NIIT Franchise was present in Malaysia in 1997?
  10.0 Training – business management and technical skills: Support for Growth-oriented Women Entrepreneurs in Tanzania, 2005
  Does Availability of Educated Workers Increase Enterprise Training?
  Where Do You Get an - Internet Marketing Education?
  1.5 Skills development for sustainable livelihoods: Working Out of Poverty
  7.5.6 Women and disabled persons: Institutional design and capacity building
  Top 10 reasons for NOT providing sales training and education
  Make Money From The Internet With A Powerful internet Marketing Education
  The Importance of Further Training and Education for Employees
  7.3.4 Labour market reform: Mainstreaming skills development for the poor
  Training vs. Coaching
  7.3.2 Training as a basic social service: Mainstreaming skills development for the poor
  How to Explode your Business Financial Opportunity
  Effective Sales Training Looks At Time as An Investment Not a Cost
  Allow your Marketing Business thrive with Training and Support
  7.4.4 Donors

Article Tags: investment education, leadership, proficiency, return on investment, word training



Related Forum Posts
7 words or less for Structogram - Some "7 words or less" (more or less) for Structogram for your comments: Training to get your message across(6) Secrets to get your message across (6) Training so people will listen to you (7) Helping you get your message across (6) Training to learn to get your message across (8) Communications training for yourself and your team (7)
Ivy League vs. Affordable school - To play devils Advocate .... Prestigious school vs. Education I can afford? Does going to a prestigious school gaurantee success? I'm sure it helps - imagine the contacts made - powerful I assume. Also there is the pressure of being an alma mater of a school where everyone else is driven to succeed by thier parents. But, what if you got the "Education you can afford". It's still education. You are forced to analyze, engage in relationships, manage your school mates, and deliver on deadlines. What's the common denominator when you get out of school? Is it the ability to take action? The ability to see the big picture and then take the necessary actions to bring a project to completion? There's that action word again! what do you think?
Re: Internet Marketing is the best business in the world - 17. Education is freely available
Budget. - I believe the biggest barrier is related to budget. Training tends to be a normal practice for a big company. But I have to consider it seriously as an entrepreneur.
Re: 10 ideas to make you money in 2010 - I think Education would be hard to break into. Baby Boomers, Life Support and Trading Down, however, seem like good markets. As for Green technology goes, I don't think the business has to be entirely based on Green ideologies, but rather a business that embrace Green philosophies and use that as a marketing tool.


Share this article with your friends. Fund someone's dream.

Leave a comment below or share on the left and you'll help support entrepreneurs in Africa through our partnership with Kiva. Over $50,000 raised and counting - Please keep sharing! Learn more.

Newsletter

Get advice & tips from famous business
owners, new articles by entrepreneur
experts, my latest website updates, &
special sneak peaks at what's to come!

Name:
Email:

Popular Articles

Steps For Starting A Small Business

When Your Smiling

Do You Pretend To Listen To People?

Suggestions

Email us your ideas on how to make our
website more valuable! Thank you Sharon
from Toronto Salsa Lessons / Classes for
your suggestions to make the newsletter
look like the website and profile younger
entrepreneurs like Jennifer Lopez.