Tweet

The Least Common Denominator

Guest post by: John Grubbs

Article Overview: I have always believed and often teach the virtues of hiring the best person for the job. My naivety has also led me to believe that most "right-minded" managers agree with this simple premise. Organizational talent is the foremost indicator of long-term success in the game of business. The team with the best players will win the most games. Blah, blah, blah!

The Least Common Denominator

I have always believed and often teach the virtues of hiring the best person for the job. My naivety has also led me to believe that most "right-minded" managers agree with this simple premise. Organizational talent is the foremost indicator of long-term success in the game of business. The team with the best players will win the most games. Blah, blah, blah!

I recently experienced something remarkable in my life as a speaker, author and business coach. It was painful like a toothache that just would not go away. I tried to ignore the reality of its presence but simply postponed the inevitable. The existence of this knowledge became something I could no longer ignore. I stirred with this information until I finally had to verbalize my newly formed opinion about the contemporary view of talent in a typical organization.

Like most HR (human resource) types, I had been boiled (as in the frog and the water) to the point of accepting that we always seek the best talent for the team. I had been certain that most managers agreed with this simple idea. I actually wondered why something so vivid in my own mind was cloudy in the mind of struggling leaders. I could not imagine an organization that didn't want the best talent money could buy. After all, the modern resume and behavioral interviewing techniques along with testing and personality profiles all lead us to the very logical conclusion that we are searching for that "one" right and often best candidate to do the job.

And, yes I really believed the hype. Until that day of course! That day changed my thinking completely. I was enjoying a relaxing afternoon by the pool of a beautiful hotel on the Texas coast. I had spoken that morning at a large convention and the reception of my message was very well received by the audience. I was basking both in the sunlight and the success of my work that morning.

While sitting by the pool, I resumed reading the book I had purchased for the trip. I had heard good things about the book by Seth Godin called Linchpin and was enjoying the read. This book changed my thinking and started my figurative toothache about selecting and hiring people. My interpretation of Godin's message is a very powerful and bitter pill for me to swallow.

Since the industrialization of this country one hundred years ago, we have been on a path to find the least common denominator (LCD) in most organizations. In other words, most companies seek the employee with the predetermined maximum amount of knowledge and capability that meets a minimum requirement to perform the work that is needed. This LCD has resulted in the creation of systems that minimize the need for human excellence and in some cases human existence.

From the start of mass production to the robotics and computers of the present, we have slowly become a culture that works very hard to limit our dependence on human talent. In fact, modern manufacturing has so little dependence on the human element that it can be shipped to almost any country in the world where the value of human talent is almost free by most standards.

We avoid the extremely talented individuals because they are more expensive and usually harder to manage. These "Linchpins" as Godin explains are often challenging due to their higher level of capability and talent. They know their own value and are not threatened by the same "stick" and often require a larger "carrot" to perform. We quickly "cull" these candidates as overqualified for the position. We justify the action by stating these people would not stick around or stay with the company very long anyway.

Over and over, the typical company looks for any edge that will allow them to hire a less skilled and often more affordable employee. Higher modern turnover and the generational changes accelerate this thinking. We use pictures on cash registers to count change so the employee need not count. We undervalue the great customer service of days gone by. We have replaced the beauty of the artist with the affordability and predictability of the assembly line. And sadly, we set a budget for wages based upon a theoretical average that is based in accounting or industrial engineering rather than an examination of the potential talent on the team.

I know what you are probably thinking, and you are correct! This is NOT always true. There are companies that do seek and value human talent and creativity. But, you have to honestly admit that these companies are the exception rather than the rule. Finding an organization that places human talent at the core of the competitive advantage is challenging. Examine your own organization for a moment, are the font-line employees truly valued or has the human element (HU) become another commodity that can be easily replaced?

Related Articles
  Bad Habits
  How to Choose the Best Web-based Project Management Service for Your Business
  Entrepreneur Education: Become Pattern Aware
  Entrepreneur Strategies: The Home-Work Connection
  Goal Setting is SMART Business
  How Discipline and Attitude Can Make the Difference in Your Life, even in these Difficult Times
  21 Management Benefits Of Saying 'No'
  Easy Online Money Making System for Dummies
  Leadership Truth #2 - Great Leaders Live Their Vision
  Applying the Long-tail to the African Mobile Space
  Always Have a Winning Hand!
  Niche Branding
  A Positive Mindset is Critical for the Success of Your Home Business
  The Search for Normality
  Write Your Own Story
  The Power to Influence Your Employees
  Is your Practice Getting your Share of the Federal Governments Electronic Medical Records Stimulus Package? Check out Three Easy Steps to achieve Meaningful Use
  What Makes You Think You Have a Sales or Recruiting Process?
  Deciding On What Home Based Business Services You Will Offer
  Five Steps To A Powerful Presentation

Article Tags: game, games, job, least common denominator, long term success, naivety, premise, virtues
Referred by: http://www.thetrainingbank.com/



Related Forum Posts
Reality in Television - [quote="SueB":2xhla35c]I've been watching Cashmere Mafia but not Lipstick Jungle. What I like about CM is that these incredibly powerful and success business women are imperfect and older. Kudos to Hollywood for hiring 3 lead actresses who are actually 39-40 vs 25 playing older. The 4th is early-mid 30's.... I'm not sure how old the actresses were in Sex and the City when it aired... Imperfect in that they do have challenges balancing the various aspects of their lives. Take Juliet for instance. She's this high-ranking if not head of some large company (I don't really know what she does) yet she let her husband take care of the money! She probably knows the cash flow particulars for her business though. Common error that many women make but that you wouldn't expect a power woman to make. In this week's episode I thought it was rather interesting and perceptive of the Mia character to realize that her ex-fiancee Jack could only be with her if he was on the same level career-wise. Otherwise his self-esteem took a beating and he left. Her fear being that this is a pattern that would continue. Mind you, her character didn't do anything to support his self esteem when they were competing for the same position. Just a few thoughts...[/quote:2xhla35c] Interesting how they are incorporating real life mistakes that many women make and having their characters do the same things. You gave a couple of very good examples. I can't believe the people - male or female - who turn their paychecks over to their spouse or significant other and have no clue where it goes. I have an aunt that did that for 10+ years and then he husband left - with a large chunk of money she didn't know "they" had. Then she got married some years later and did it again. I wonder sometimes what it takes for people to learn a lesson. Shri
Re: HOw to market a B2B consulting company - How about providing a white paper on Common security holes (only mention the ones that the prospect can easily and inexpensively fix themselves). Towards the end explain that there are other greater security flaws that exist and that you provide a "Free Security Consultation and Report". They could use this report to get cheaper quotes but you are getting so much more... you get face time with the company and get to build rapport with them. I know of a company here in Toronto that does Energy Audits on your home and provide you with a report on ways you can save energy- they also also offer to fix it for you through their suppliers. they had a story run on them on Earth Day this year and they were bombarded with over 200 calls in one day to have these audits done. The audits are done for free. You could write up a shocking story on Security and holes that exist within businesses today and submit this story to the newspapers business edition or to a Trade Magazine written for the industry you are trying to serve. Most journalists may pick up this article and feature it or interview you directly. Also, I would redesign your site to be more Information-based to educate potential prospects (how to solve common security issues) rather than it being all about the company - people are more interested in solving their problem and often aren't searching the internet for a particular company by name unless it is well established. So give them juicy information freely. note: When I first heard this idea of giving away free information about solving a problem I was hesitant to use it in my web design business. I gave it a try anyways and the amazing part was that even the easy inexpensive things I advised them they could fix in their websites they offered to pay me to do it for them - from there I was able to upsell them on greater improvements. I've since sold this company - but it was fun!


Share this article with your friends. Fund someone's dream.

Leave a comment below or share on the left and you'll help support entrepreneurs in Africa through our partnership with Kiva. Over $50,000 raised and counting - Please keep sharing! Learn more.

Newsletter

Get advice & tips from famous business
owners, new articles by entrepreneur
experts, my latest website updates, &
special sneak peaks at what's to come!

Name:
Email:

Popular Articles

Are You Listening?

What Aweber Can Do For Your Online Business

Suggestions

Email us your ideas on how to make our
website more valuable! Thank you Sharon
from Toronto Salsa Lessons / Classes for
your suggestions to make the newsletter
look like the website and profile younger
entrepreneurs like Jennifer Lopez.