Tweet

9 Ideas to Reduce Cliques at Work

Guest post by: Robert Whipple

Article Overview: My thesis is that cliques at work have some helpful components, but they often do more harm than good by being exclusive elements in the culture. Top performance in any organization requires the best effort of the entire team, and when parts of the group are fragmented into insular cells, all kinds or gremlins creep into the structure. In the extreme, cliques can be hurtful to the mission of an orgnaization. But cliques are as natural as pancakes for breakfast. They form spontaneously and have their own unwritten bylaws that serve the members very well. How can leaders reduce the negative impact of cliques? Here are 9 ideas that can help reduce the problem.

9 Ideas to Reduce Cliques at Work

Most organizations need to build higher levels of trust. One significant trust buster that is evident, even in the best organizations, is the presence of cliques. These informal groups continuously drain the trust from the larger organization by fostering a culture of exclusivity. Since joining together with like-minded people has been human nature back to the "Clan of the Cave Bear," how can an organization reduce the negative impact of these insular cells? It is a function of leadership to set the tone of any culture. If leaders either condone cliques or encourage them by participating in them, the cells will continue to enjoy their exclusivity at the expense of the larger organization. The conundrum is that cliques are highly prized by the people in them. The support structure allows all members to poke fun at others who are outside the fence and create their own set of norms. This builds in a kind of polarization that is as uncomfortable to the outsiders as it is gratifying to the elite.

What can leaders do to discourage the formation of cliques?

1. Be Aware of Cliques - The first line of defense is to recognize what is going on. I would wager that your work place has numerous little groups of people that form naturally and insulate themselves from others for several reasons. You can see manifestations when the same people sit together in the break room - often in the same seats - every day for years. There is nothing wrong with friends sitting with other friends, but if it becomes an exclusive club, then it can build barriers to effective teamwork. Another easy way to spot cliques is to watch how people on a shift arrange themselves during a shift meeting. E-mail distributions are other dead give aways that there are cells of people communicating with each other and not with the general population. Leaders canuse many techniques to encourage a more homogenous population.

2. Encourage an inclusive culture regularly - If leaders would continually stress that our power is in the diverse thoughts of the entire population and everyone's input is important, it will send a subtle message that insular groups are not always helpful. Caveat: It would backfire if the leader put a ban on sub-groups because that would either drive them underground or embolden them based on the forbidden fruit logic. Rather, the leader needs to demonstrate by actions and words that a broad representation is most often in the best interest of everyone.

3. Take a few king pins aside - In any society there are informal leaders who establish themselves as"Grand Poobahs" of the group. Their words carry the most weight, and they have more than their fair share of say in who is allowed to join the group. All these pecking order considerations are informal, but they are all in play as the group carries on daily activities. As a leader, you can befriend the informal leaders and ask them to open up the club to new members. I think one way to make progress is to enroll the informal leaders by seeking their advice on how to reduce exclusivity in the organization. These conversations will be tricky, but if handled properly, you can woo these people into becoming forces for the good in your organization.

4. Mix things up in meetings - You might have some kind of rotation in seating arrangements or some other mechanical way to get people to mingle in different social arrangements. One way to do this naturally is to have some team building events where the team selection is objectively random. People will accept an arbitrary team assignment if it is obvious there is no particular agenda in the selection process. If you prescribe the seating arrangement to specifically break up a clique, people will push back.

5. Transplant people - This is a kind of last resort if all else fails. You can move the job assignments so the exclusive social interfaces are broken up by time and space. Caveat: arbitrary work assignments designed to break up cliques are often unpopular, and you may cause more damage than you eliminate if you use a heavy hand. One antidote is to espouse a strong philosophy of cross training individuals to improve bench strength and provide development opportunities. People generally appreciate these objectives even if they tend to break up historical social groupings.

6. Inject new blood - Sometimes the addition of a new strong personality will have the effect of breaking up an existing structure and allow the creation of a new order. Of course, the cure could be worse than the disease, so you need to keep alert that you are progressing rather than retrogressing by bringing in new people.

7. Reorganize - Many leaders use a kind of "shake and bake" reorganization philosophy when trying to reduce inbreeding. A new organization really does break up the old gang, but just like transplanting individuals, it is often not welcomed. An effective reorganization takes a lot of study, and you need to have a good justification for making the move other than to break up cliques. Making reorganizations successful requires a lot of energy, communication, planning, and involvement of the people. Do not just throw out a new structure as a way to mix things up. Maybe a good analogy here is a garden. If you have a nice flower garden but some of the plants have become root bound, you want to carefully thin things out, not just roto-till the entire garden.

8. Reward inclusion - One good way to prevent exclusion is to talk about and reward inclusion at every opportunity. Make it a value for the organization and highlight good examples through the usual communication channels.

9. Sit with them - I often found that just sitting with a clique in the break room a few times a week would send a signal that they are not an exclusive club. As a manager you have the right to sit with your people for purposes of getting to know them better. It may feel uncomfortable at first, especially if the clique has an activity to keep them insulated (like a bridge game or something). Just keep looking for ways to interface with the group in ways that show you are interested in their opinions and ideas. Eventually you can gain their confidence, and your presence will be welcome rather than an intrusion. Then you can invite another person to join the discussion. This method takes time, but it does work.

Reducing cliques in the working world or in social groups is delicate work. Keep stressing that the ideal organization taps into the good ideas of all people. It is the interplay of ideas that creates a healthy organization.

Related Articles
  Top 7 Reasons Why Business Networking Organizations Fail
  E-Mail Tip #32 - Peer Pressure in E-Mail
  Entrepreneurship Part 2
  R1 for Business
  Ten Reasons Why America's Public Schools Are Like America's Prisons
  Small Steps to Reduce Climate Change
  Why Improve Your Communication Skills?
  Spread The Word Your Word
  Looking For Smart Business And Ideas
  Reduce Your Debt So You Can Save for Your Future
  Work at Home and Pass Gas On Earth Day April 22
  Going Green = saving money
  Where to Find Ideas
  The First Law of Building Trust
  1.7 Conclusion: Economic Report on Africa 2007
  15 Ways to Improve Net Cashflow
  SMEs - SMEs and labour rigidity
  How to be more creative in business
  Helping SMEs meet the requirements of formal financing - Increasing SME Access to Finance: A Four Pronged Approach
  How One Big Idea Can Reel In The Customers

Article Tags: Cliques, Cross Training, culture, groups, Inclusion, Leadership, Orgnization, reinforcement, reorganize, reward, teams, training, Trust, values



Related Forum Posts
Re: Interested in Pinterest? - This means pinterest is here to stay and this is what ideas is all about. Ideas make the world go round. Ideas is the fuel of this economy.
Re: A Post About Posts - Great to be here with you Ideas
Re: Internet Users Hbk http://www.internetscamsanonymous.com - Thanks for the thought Ideas
Re: What's your top tip for balancing your business and taking t - Proper Work management meeting your all deadlines....
Re: Five Personality Traits of Successful Business Owners - 1. Focus 2. Ability to Adapt 3. Hard Work 4. Good planning 5. People Skills


Share this article with your friends. Fund someone's dream.

Leave a comment below or share on the left and you'll help support entrepreneurs in Africa through our partnership with Kiva. Over $50,000 raised and counting - Please keep sharing! Learn more.

Newsletter

Get advice & tips from famous business
owners, new articles by entrepreneur
experts, my latest website updates, &
special sneak peaks at what's to come!

Name:
Email:

Popular Articles

Executive Blind Spots

How do you keep it together on a daily basis?

Ten Things You Can Do To Be a Better Leader

Suggestions

Email us your ideas on how to make our
website more valuable! Thank you Sharon
from Toronto Salsa Lessons / Classes for
your suggestions to make the newsletter
look like the website and profile younger
entrepreneurs like Jennifer Lopez.