Tweet

Leaders and Managers

Guest post by: Robert Whipple

Article Overview: My HRD students often get into discussions with me about the differences between leaders and managers. How do you like to describe the difference between these two entities?. Usually in books and articles, I see lists of side-by-side comparisons with things like: "Managers do things right" while "Leaders do the right things." There are a dozen or so comparisons like this on these typical lists. Personally, I like to describe the difference from a mind-set point of view. This article describes my thesis on this topic.

Leaders and Managers

There is a lot of information on the contrast between leaders and managers. Typically we see a side by side comparison with items such as:

"Managers do things right" while

"Leaders do the right things."

I like to take a different slant on describing the differences because I believe a pure manager comes to work with an entirely different mindset from a pure leader. Of course, there really is no such thing as a pure manager or leader, it is always some kind of a combination of the two concepts. Here is how I describe the differences.

The Manager

The manager wants everything to go smoothly. He or she wants every process to run the way it should and get the maximum productivity. There should be no waste. The manager wants everyone to follow all the rules and be there every day motivated to do good work. In essence, the manager wants to stabilize things and clone everything to be exactly right. The manager is all about doing things right, and is most closely associated with the mission of the organization (what they are trying to accomplish). The manager works with the process, the equipment, the schedule, and the people in terms of what they should be doing. Managers are now oriented.

The Leader

The leader is often a destabilizing force. He or she is most interested in where the organization is going rather than just optimizing today's processes. That may mean making people unhappy for some time in order for the greater good. If people are too complacent and do not see the dangers, the leader is there to create a burning platform. Leaders are sometimes very unpopular. The idea is to do the right things, which may mean some pretty difficult decisions. The leader is all about the vision of the organization (where they are trying to go). The leader works with the balance sheet, the strategic plan, the product line, and the people in terms of what they can become. Leaders are future oriented.

The Leader/Manager

This person is able to combine the best of both worlds and act in both roles. All of us act as leaders and managers at times, but each of us favors one mode or the other. A good balance between the two extremes is the best place to be. In general, the world has far more competent managers than competent leaders, so if you have leadership tendencies, that is a good thing to have.

Really great leaders do not mind being average managers. They recognize their weakness and surround themselves with outstanding managers to handle the details.

Related Articles
  Are you building bridges or walls?
  The Difference Between Management And Leadership
  Workplace Leaders Don't Need Leadership Titles
  Are You Genuinely A Leader Or Merely A Manager?
  Please Please Listen to Us
  Are You a Breakthrough Leader?
  Sales Strategy and Tactics - Thoughts from the Super Bowl
  Focus on Positive Leadership - When Things Go Wrong
  Define Leadership - The Missing Key Success Factor in Change Management
  Train Your Workers, Develop Your Leaders
  Balance Self-Confidence and Uncertainty
  But I'm a Sales Guy - The Story of Motivation and Compensation
  what is the role of leader in the organisation.?
  The Differences Between Management and leadership
  CEO Speak Out
  Attracting Holding Good Trade Show Traffic
  Blogging
  Ten Characteristics of Leadership
  Managers & Leaders -Why CEOs Need a Leadership Pipeline
  Coaching Skills inspire new managers to be better leaders

Article Tags: clone, destabilize, Leader, manager, mission, stabilize, trust, vision



Related Forum Posts
Re: March 21 Triple Crown Update - Congratulations to the first three Leaders in the Forum category. Keep it up.
Re: Forums Question - Ok guys - the This Month's Leaders should now be working - thank you for pointing this out!
Re: Forums Question - test post to check for This Month's Leaders - no need to reply
Re: Forums Question - test post to check for This Month's Leaders - no need to reply
Re: Forums Question - test post to check for This Month's Leaders - no need to reply


Share this article with your friends. Fund someone's dream.

Leave a comment below or share on the left and you'll help support entrepreneurs in Africa through our partnership with Kiva. Over $50,000 raised and counting - Please keep sharing! Learn more.

Newsletter

Get advice & tips from famous business
owners, new articles by entrepreneur
experts, my latest website updates, &
special sneak peaks at what's to come!

Name:
Email:

Popular Articles

What I Really Want Is...

Are You Listening?

Business Coach Explains To You How To Add Value

Suggestions

Email us your ideas on how to make our
website more valuable! Thank you Sharon
from Toronto Salsa Lessons / Classes for
your suggestions to make the newsletter
look like the website and profile younger
entrepreneurs like Jennifer Lopez.