Tweet

Unions Complify Business

Guest post by: Robert Whipple

Article Overview: This article highlights some of the inefficiencies and costs that result from having a union operating between line workers and management. It represents a cost that we can no longer afford to bear.

Unions Complify Business

I have coined a word to describe the impact of unions on organizations. They "complify" the situation. "Complify" is my pet word for the opposite of simplify. In a time where every organization is struggling to remain viable, the presence of a third party between management and workers is an inefficiency we can no longer afford as a society. I believe the automobile industry got that message last year.

In addition to complifying things, the unions add non value adding management jobs, which raise the costs of things. They also create significant work for lawyers, who we all know make a pretty good buck. You have to pay the salaries of the union officials and the people who work for them, including the lawyers and the people who work for them. That cost is paid out of union dues, which lower the standard of living for the workers. So, the union officials bid up the salaries to allow the workers to not take the brunt of their expenses, but that makes the organization less able to compete - i.e. the automobile example.

Here is a note from a student of mine in an online class. This scenario is so typical it has been mentioned by numerous people who work in a union setting.

"Well we have a union at the Post Office for the carriers, but honestly other than if you get fired, they don't seem to interfere or help out too too much. And yes I think rewards and pay should be based on the quality of the work you do. Too much with the unions is based off of seniority. You can be lazy, but if you've been there longer than someone else, you get most everything over them. I don't think that is right. Unions need to have some sort of penalties and accountability for their members who don't pull their weight."

I once worked in a union factory as a non-unionized engineer. I witnessed some of the ways this system drains money and time away from the vital work of the organization. The workers got to vote on which union to have represent them every three years. When I was there, it was time for an election.

The campaign seemed similar to a High School election where people were putting up posters and giving out trinkets supporting their candidate. It turns out this election was unusual because there were normally only two groups running (Party A, and Party B). In this election there was a third Party C that was known to be linked to a communist organization. The Party C group had infiltrated the society for several years preparing for this moment to take control of the factory. By this time, they had placed some highly capable people in key slots within the organization. The campaigning was fierce, and there was a lot of mud being slung around.

The election day came, and when the votes were counted, Party C had the most votes at 41%. The rest were split between Parties A and B. The plant manager was highly disturbed that a known communist group had taken over his operation, but was powerless to do anything about it because the election was done according to the rules. But this plant manager was clever enough to go back and re-read the rules one more time very carefully. He picked up a loophole that the lawyers had inadvertently placed in the contract.

The plant manager summoned all workers to a large meeting to announce the winner. He got up and said. "In this election, Party C received the most votes at 41% while Party B got 31% and Party A got 28%. That leaves us with a large problem because the Union rules in paragraph 4.3.b state that ‘There shall be an election every three years, and the party which receives more than 50% of the vote will be the ruling Party for the succeeding three years.' Unfortunately, none of the parties in this election received more than 50% of the votes, so this election is void according to the Union Bylaws. We will have another election in two weeks to see if one Party can gain more than the required 50% of the votes."

Of course Party C shouted all kinds of foul language at the manager, but he had the upper hand because he was only going by the contract. Starting the next morning the HR manager of the plant took the leaders of Party C one by one into the office and told them their services were no longer required at this plant. For months thereafter, there were people carrying signs outside the plant about unfair practices.

I am sure this particular situation hardly ever comes up, but my observation is that there was a lot of dither and wringing of hands that took the focus off the critical work of the plant for months. This would not have happened if there was no union in the organization. While this example is rather extreme, I think it is illustrative of how the existence of unions, serves to "complify" things in an organization. That raises costs and lowers efficiency at the very time when organizations are feeling the competitive pressures from global competitors like never before.

Related Articles
  Supreme Court Ruling May Lead To More Unionization
  Police in Uganda Investigate Front Page Micro Finance and Three Other Microfinance Firms
  What You Don’t Know about the NLRB Could Hurt You and Your Employees
  Ten Truths About Employee Communication In A Unionized Environment
  Happy Labor Day!
  Unions Can Benefit Organzational Change
  COMPENSATING BALANCE LOANS FOR BUSINESS/REAL ESTATE
  5.13 Gender: Working Out of Poverty
  Helping Others Helps You
  Employee Free Choice Act: An Opportunity for Employers to Choose their Future
  Indiana Joins as 23rd Right to Work State
  Lesson #2: Play By Your Own Rules
  Union Avoidance
  How to Get a Used Auto Car Loans Using 4 Effective Tips
  Getting a Competitive Car Loans Interest Rates
  Searching For The Best Car Loans Interest Rates
  Searching for the best car finance interest rates
  How to Prevent Your Employees from Becoming Collateral Damage in the Labor-Management Battle
  What is a Microfinance Institution (MFI)?
  Overview of Human resource management factors

Article Tags: election, Leadership, Trust, Unions



Related Forum Posts
Re: Unions Ruining America? - Unions Ruining America? Unions ruining the world! As much as I respect bargaining rights and considerations of unions, I'm sick and tired of seeing others held hostage when unions go on strike to forcefully see their demands come to fruition - regardless of their longer term impacts on their business or economy. It erks me when I see government officials on strike too. They have the most cushiony jobs in the entire economy, and still find reason to complain about their situation. What about the poor people working 80 hour weeks just to feed their family? Something has got to give - we cannot continually exceed expectations without inflation or diminished returns affecting us.
My entry - 1. The Best Business Books Ever: The 100 Most Influential Business Books You'll Never Have Time to Read - this is a fascinating book about the history of Business theory, and I'd recommend it to anybody. 2. The Big Book of Small Business: You Don't Have to Run Your Business by the Seat of Your Pants, by Tom Gegax. Ditto. 3. PADI: The Business of Diving Book Okay, so this book won't be of use to anyone who doesn't want to start a scuba store, but I did, and this book was of course invaluable to me in reaching that goal.
Exclusive: Interview with Results - Hi Forum Members, I'm helping start up a Business Coaching and Consulting company here in Toronto, Ontario, Canada (a Subsidiary of RSC Business in Los Angeles). As a Research and Development Intern I am required to practice my listening and interview skills by surveying Small and Medium Businesses on thier Business. This Survey is designed by RSC Business to also assist the Business being interviewed more insight into their own business. I am looking to interview about 30 businesses across North America over the span of 3 months. At the end of these interviews I will be publishing a report of the results and they will be made available for free to the Interviewees. The Report data will include responses from a minimum of 100 interviews. I would like to extend this opportunity to members of the Forum. If you would like to have this short 20-30 minute interview conducted on your Business and you reside in North America please send me an email or PM. Please contact me at andy[at]jvprosperity[dot]com to arrange our interview and to get free access to the results when they are published.
Banks Vs. Credit Unions - [quote="Takuya":28s7wgy0] Credit Unions (they hate to be called banks) are more conservative. Although they typically offer the best terms, they are more concerned about people's abilities to repay the loan. [/quote:28s7wgy0] So it would be best to visit a credit union to try an obtain a loan before going to a bank? Or are credit unions looking for people who have a more matured business since they'll have a greater chance of paying off the loan?
Best Month For Getting Financed? - I would think that November and December would be bad, as most people are busy racking up debt in the holiday season... has there ever been a study on what are the most popular months for people getting loans? Although, with the current breakdown in banks, I suppose all the old paradigms are going to be trashed, and new ways of doing things will have to be learned. Quite a few large comapanies seem to be built on nothing but smoke and mirrors, with nothing to back them up... Much as I hate to see thousands of people thrown out of work just before Christmas, the Unions have way too sweet a deal wth the Big 3 Automakers. Laid off workers get paid 95% of their paycheck, indefinitely? Ridiculous!


Share this article with your friends. Fund someone's dream.

Leave a comment below or share on the left and you'll help support entrepreneurs in Africa through our partnership with Kiva. Over $50,000 raised and counting - Please keep sharing! Learn more.

Newsletter

Get advice & tips from famous business
owners, new articles by entrepreneur
experts, my latest website updates, &
special sneak peaks at what's to come!

Name:
Email:

Popular Articles

Inspiration for troubled times

Executives and Elevators Perfecting That Pitch

How do you keep it together on a daily basis?

Suggestions

Email us your ideas on how to make our
website more valuable! Thank you Sharon
from Toronto Salsa Lessons / Classes for
your suggestions to make the newsletter
look like the website and profile younger
entrepreneurs like Jennifer Lopez.