Tweet

Don't Bite the Invisible Hand That Feeds You

Guest post by: Matt Harrison

Article Overview: The anti-capitalist is a curious breed. They take a variety of different positions, but all share one common theme: the general belief that the market is an inherently evil force. They pass along such canards as "The free market doesn't work," "Capitalism is the exploitation of the worker," and "There is no such thing as the American Dream," among many others. They are often found writing for outlets such as The Nation and Harpers, as well as self-righteously demonstrating against free trade agreements and French labor proposals, inter alia.

Don't Bite the Invisible Hand That Feeds You

The anti-capitalist is a curious breed. They take a variety of different positions, but all share one common theme: the general belief that the market is an inherently evil force. They pass along such canards as "The free market doesn't work," "Capitalism is the exploitation of the worker," and "There is no such thing as the American Dream," among many others. They are often found writing for outlets such as The Nation and Harpers, as well as self-righteously demonstrating against free trade agreements and French labor proposals, inter alia.

Their position is wholly unconstructive. By their ideological hatred, these anti-market characters should be distinguished from all of those who simply wish to regulate certain aspects of the market to improve its otherwise beneficial performance. Many moderate conservatives or libertarians, such as this organization, are pro-market but still support various regulation and spending policies. And many leftists, such as the original German SocialDemocratsseek regulation and intevention, but still view the market as a generally positive force.

The anti-capitalists, however, have little or no such appreciation of the market. They instead focus on the market's harmful effects as their predominant theme. Naomi Klein, one of their most popular literary agitators, cites thousands of cases of disingenuous business behavior in her sundry anti-market tomes. All she proves in the end, though, is the well-known reality that humans are fallible creatures who have the capability of acting immorally and unethically.

But her argument does nothing to successfully indict capitalism, any more than the millenia of recorded history showing kings, rulers, politicians and other powerful figures slaughtering, enslaving, and defrauding millions does indict the idea of a government ruling a country. The anti-market position is steeped in illogic. Businessmen violate their moral and legal obligations just like politicians do. If we were to be logically consistent in our aversion of human malice, we would have to do away with not only capitalism, but government as well.

Anarchy notwithstanding, the rational citizen is not anti-state any more than he is anti-capitalism. He only finds specific faults in each and attempts to rectify them. He knows without the government he would be living a fearful life in an anarchic state ofnature, and that without the market he would be living a destitute life in an miserable state of abject poverty.

The question of whether the free market generally benefits society is obviously answered in the affirmative. It is mostly on the level of questions such as whether grass is generally green or a bear generally defecates in his native forest.

As you read this, you are reading off of a personal computer, a capitalist innovation that has transformed the world's sharing and dispensation of information. You are likely sitting in a house or office with consistent power, air conditioning, quality building materials, and a variety of other conveniences, all exclusively offered by greedy, profit-seeking companies. You will eat your lunch at one of a nearly limitless number of small-business restaurants, or will make food that you have conveniently purchased at a corporate grocery store offering an endless array of choices. Either way, you'll do it cheaply - free trade, mortal enemy of the anti-capitalist, has kindly cut the relative cost of food by two-thirds since 1957.

Per capita GDP, for another example, had been nearly constant at about $400, since about 1 million B.C. By 1850, the world had managed to barely raise it to only about $700. Then came along the Great Satan, free-market capitalism, and it exploded. By the year 2000, global per capita GDP was over $6,000.

Even the have-nots benefit from this sustained economic growth. Worldwide poverty has fallen more in the past 50 years, the much-maligned golden years of globalization and Multinational Corporate Exploitation, than in the previous 500 years of human history. As John F. Kennedy once put it, a rising tide lifts all boats.

Here's an example that hits home. In 1900, an American housewife spent an average of seven hours a week doing laundry. In 2006, she has a washing machine from Big Laundry that lets her spend only about 30 seconds doing the exact same task, freeing up time to break glass ceilings. Gee, doesn't the market make life miserable? Down with capitalism, comrade!

The anti-capitalist position is clearly worthless. But the market will still always have its flaws. Many people are rightly concerned about unscrupulous business exploitation of regulatory loopholes, environmentally-damaging malfeasance, and hypercommercialization. But more moderate critics of the market have intelligently proposed constructive regulatory policies while still recognizing the market as the superior economic system.

The free market is not anarcho-capitalism. It is not absolutely free in the sense of being devoid from regulation any more than free speech is devoid of any legal restriction. Oliver Wendell Holmes once famously remarked that even the most resolute protection of free speech would still not permit a man to shout fire in a crowded theatre. Likewise, the most resolute promotion of the free market should not permit a business to defraud a crowded theater, either.

Unfortunately, the anti-capitalists are gaining traction, and the West is beginning to turn its back on the very market that gave them the commodious and productive lifestyle it enjoys. The West was recently asked if it thought the free market was the best system available. 71% of Americans correctly thought so, as did 66% of the British. Only 55% of the Italians do, though, and only 36% of the French are so aware.

Being reflexively opposed to the market is a foolish position incompatible with the facts of human history, and completely unnecessary to alleviate the market's sporadic flaws. The anti-capitalists, ever great in number and cacophonous in rhetoric, simply don't get it. It is never wise to bite the Invisible Hand that feeds you.

Related Articles
  Profitable Online Business Ideas and the Recession Part 2
  Why Use Feedburner for Feeds
  What is the best way to develop my sales skills?
  ••••••>SEO Tip of the day by GetMeOnTop: Using RSS Feeds for Best in Class #1 SEO
  Contribution
  Using RSS Feeds to Increase your Exposure on the Web
  How can you make more of your customers open your emails?
  Know your magic numbers
  Social Networking or Social Distraction
  Bite Your Tongue
  Would You Have More Career, Workplace Success if You Had Superpowers?
  Seeing the truth when it might be invisible
  Waxitaxi, the taxi for your candels
  A to Z of RSS Feed
  RSS - the forgotten tool
  Developing Systems to Permanently End Procrastination
  More crazy customers!
  How You Can Get Your Blog Featured in CNN, New York Times, Wall Street Journal, and Other Major Media Outlets
  Even In Small Bites, Spending Is Hard To Swallow
  Trolling For Topics - On Autopilot

Article Tags: american dream, capitalism, free trade agreements, invisible hand, matt harrison
Referred by: http://www.westwindcos.com



Related Forum Posts
Re: THE SECRET TO SUCCESS IS ALL IN YOUR HEAD...RIGHT NOW!!! - Success = Thinking (Head) + Heart (Feeling / Interest) + Hand (doing/ action). Success - H3 Robert
Facebook and Beacon - What Do You Think - This landed in my inbox. Any thoughts???? Personally, I think they really overstepped the bounds of maintaining personal privacy with this one. Facebook Signals Changes With Beacon David A. Utter | Staff Writer The ringing outcry against Facebook Beacon, which posted people's online purchases to their friends' News Feeds, led to Facebook altering the program. Facebook founder Mark Zuckerberg's aggressive move into referral advertising through the Beacon technology ran into a brick wall of user discontent. After days of complaints that spread throughout the media world, Facebook has changed their Beacon policies. "Users now have more control over the stories that get published to their Mini-Feed and potentially to their friends' News Feeds," the company said. Other details of the changes have been published in the Beacon FAQ available to Facebook members: "If you are logged in to Facebook and visit a Beacon Affiliate, an action you take (like writing a review or purchasing an item), may trigger that website to want to publish a story to Facebook. Before that happens, a notification will display in the lower right corner of your screen. If you click "No Thanks"...no stories or information will be published anywhere on Facebook. If you click "Close" or ignore the story, the story will be sent to Facebook, but not yet published." The previous version of Beacon would go ahead and publish details of a purchase or other conversion activity on a participating website directly to the Facebook user's Mini-Feed, which would then appear on the News Feeds of friends tracking that Mini-Feed. Some people complained that the notification appearing on a Beacon partner site of the pending publication did not appear. Facebook said people were leaving pages before the notification dialogue could be fully displayed, and they have changed the process to confirm the full notification has been shown to the person. Chris
Website Ranking Optimization - There are many myths about SEO but I want to tell you the plain truth. The do-it-yourself person can accomplish just as much as the professional. You must be willing to do many tasks of Website Optimization if you want to succeed. There is much information on the Internet on SEO. Some will tell you that the secret to high rankings is creating and submitting many RSS Feeds. Others will tell you that you need quality reciprocal links. Is there just one way of gaining first page on Google? [link removed by forum administrator]
Re: How to Promote Your Blog – The Definitive Guide to Promoting - Great Post! Dont forget to put your blog in Anchor Text For SEO purposes for the keywords you want when getting backlinks (for example with article marketing)...Very important. You can conquer quite a few small Niches and get your site on the number 1 spot in Google!
Re: Due Diligence, Market Research.. Ahead of the curve. - Congrats! A few months ago I wrote extensively on market research. Check in the Inventors corner for the posts. Let me know if I can help further! Dont spend a dime on a protype or advertising until you do some research! Jude


Share this article with your friends. Fund someone's dream.

Leave a comment below or share on the left and you'll help support entrepreneurs in Africa through our partnership with Kiva. Over $50,000 raised and counting - Please keep sharing! Learn more.

Newsletter

Get advice & tips from famous business
owners, new articles by entrepreneur
experts, my latest website updates, &
special sneak peaks at what's to come!

Name:
Email:

Popular Articles

Ten Reasons to take Notes during Sales Meetings

African Technology Development

Small Business Internet Marketing

Suggestions

Email us your ideas on how to make our
website more valuable! Thank you Sharon
from Toronto Salsa Lessons / Classes for
your suggestions to make the newsletter
look like the website and profile younger
entrepreneurs like Jennifer Lopez.