Tweet

Beyond Manipulating and Motivating to Leading and Inspiring

Guest post by: Jim Clemmer

Article Overview: We've known for decades that money doesn't motivate most people to higher levels of performance. In his seminal 1959 book, The Motivation to Work, Frederick Herzberg identified money as a "hygiene factor." If we feel we're not fairly compensated, lack of money can de-motivate. But once we feel we're treated fairly, the promise of more money doesn't sustain higher energy and mobilize inspired performance.

Beyond Manipulating and Motivating to Leading and Inspiring

"People do work for money - but they work even more for meaning in their lives. In fact, they work to have fun. Companies that ignore this fact are essentially bribing their employees and will pay the price in a lack of loyalty and commitment." - Jeffrey Pfeffer, "Six Dangerous Myths About Pay," Harvard Business Review We've known for decades that money doesn't motivate most people to higher levels of performance. In his seminal 1959 book, The Motivation to Work, Frederick Herzberg identified money as a "hygiene factor." If we feel we're not fairly compensated, lack of money can de-motivate. But once we feel we're treated fairly, the promise of more money doesn't sustain higher energy and mobilize inspired performance.

Numerous studies over the last few decades have shown that when it comes to understanding what really energizes and mobilizes, there's a huge we/they gap between managers and frontline people. For example, in an article entitled "Mastering the ABCs of Organizations," John R. Throop cites a study of computer programmers who were asked to identify the top 10 factors that provided the highest degree of motivation in their jobs. The programmers' top three were: full appreciation for work done; feeling that they were in on things; and, sympathetic help with personnel problems. The programmers' managers, when asked what these factors would be, predicted rather different priorities: wages, working conditions, and fair discipline.

When confronting morale problems, managers will often succumb to the Victimitis virus and blame the declining work ethic, attitudes of entitlement, softening values, the welfare state, or any number of societal factors. But these factors - which are mostly about doing the least work for the most money - are more imagined than real. Studies show that people's real needs are much less mercenary than most managers believe. People want to take pride in their work, belong to a winning team, and be part of an organization they can believe in.

In fact, the morale crisis so prevalent in organizations today is primarily the result of disappointment in these needs not being met. Ultimately, the problem is a leadership vacuum. The hand-wringing, teeth-gnashing managers, frustrated by their organizational energy crisis, often ask "why don't people want to work any more?" But that's the wrong question, based on the wrong assumptions. The question to ask - with a long gaze in the leadership mirror - is, "why don't people want to work here?"

Managers try to motivate. Leaders inspire. Managers try to understand how to motivate people. Leaders try to understand why people aren't feeling motivated. Managers try to add more drivers to increase mobilization and energy. Leaders try to identify, prioritize, and remove the biggest resistors.

Internal vs. External Motivators

Most managers recognize that one of their key roles is "motivating" others. They also recognize that a key to motivation is empowerment. But it's too often a lot of empty "leaderspeak." For all that the popular "E" word has been bandied about in the last few years, not much has changed in many organizations.

There are many reasons why empty empowerment rhetoric is so widespread today. One of the most common is confusion about (or misapplication of) intrinsic or internal motivation (leadership) versus extrinsic or external motivators (management). In his article "Empowerment: The Emperor's New Clothes," Harvard professor Chris Argyris outlines this difference: "If management wants employees to take more responsibility for their own destiny, it must encourage the development of internal commitment. As the name implies, internal commitment comes largely from within...by definition, internal commitment is participatory and very closely allied with empowerment. The more that management wants internal commitment from its employees, the more it must try to involve employees in defining work objectives, specifying how to achieve them, and setting stretch targets."

The power of using employee involvement to build internal commitment is both measurable and impressive. One organization made a massive effort to involve everyone in their planning process. (In our consulting work, there's an old adage that we frequently quote to clients: "If they help plan the battle, they won't battle the plan.") A year later, the company's absenteeism dropped by 300% - and saved millions of dollars!

Related Articles
  Why Listen To Debtors
  Communicate your vision
  Climate Scientist Cleared: Deniers Deprived of Misinformation Strategy
  Do I need to learn tips for Public Speaking?
  Leadership Style and Motivating Employees
  Book Review - A Whole New Mind by Dan Pink
  Leadership with Mind Mapping
  Balance the art of leadership with the science of management and watch your profits soar
  You Can Be A Leader With A Vision
  The Difference Between Management And Leadership
  Inspirational Leadership: Do It Your Way
  Changing Your Ideas about Employee Motivation
  The Best Leaders Are Inspired People
  Internet Marketing Specialist Can Help Your Business Grow
  The Truth about Managing and Coaching
  Change management is an oxymoron
  Great Leadership Requires Inspiration, IX
  Inspirational Leadership: The Happy Accident
  Accountability: The Missing Link?
  Developing Your Management Team

Article Tags: business, leadership, management
Referred by: http://www.searchengineworkshops.com



Related Forum Posts
Re: $8 website turns into a million-dollar empire - I’ve read about this girl… Very Inspiring and motivational. Great Post for Newbies
Re: How to Promote a MLM Business? - I have to agree with several of the previous posts here. Having your own site so that you can get it ranked is a big one. Also, as stated above, using a "passive" recruiting style works really well. Leading by example, people will naturally want to follow you over time if you prove yourself a leader. Bottom line, if you are promoting your opportunity or products, you are losing sales. About 85% of the population hates to be sold. Promote YOU, build relationships and let the business fall in place after that. Bill
And the speakers for the Nov 1 event - Inspiring speakers will share their stories of launching, living and dreaming. Speakers include: Kathleen Matthews: Executive Vice President Global Communications and Public Affairs, Marriott International, Inc. and former award-winning producer, reporter and news anchor who covered news in Washington, DC for 25 years Mei Xu: Founder and creator of CHESAPEAKE BAY CANDLE and Blissliving Home Julie Lenzer Kirk: President of Path Forward International and author of The ParentPreneur Edge: What Parenting Teaches About Building a Successful Business Jennifer Buddin: Co-founder of "The Little Black Book for every busy woman" Victoria Colligan: Founder of Ladies Who Launch Frances Crespo and Nicolette Pizzitola: Ladies Who Launch Washington, DC Leaders Educational workshops and information gathering Invaluable exchanges, introductions, business contacts and referrals Exclusive discounts, free consultations and access to original products and services Lunch and spa services An opportunity to become a "Featured Lady" on Ladies Who Launch Valuable GIFT BAG guaranteed with pre-registration


Share this article with your friends. Fund someone's dream.

Leave a comment below or share on the left and you'll help support entrepreneurs in Africa through our partnership with Kiva. Over $50,000 raised and counting - Please keep sharing! Learn more.

Newsletter

Get advice & tips from famous business
owners, new articles by entrepreneur
experts, my latest website updates, &
special sneak peaks at what's to come!

Name:
Email:

Popular Articles

Setting Goals for your Home Based Business

Inspiration for troubled times

Unspoken Yet Important Rules for Book Proposals

Suggestions

Email us your ideas on how to make our
website more valuable! Thank you Sharon
from Toronto Salsa Lessons / Classes for
your suggestions to make the newsletter
look like the website and profile younger
entrepreneurs like Jennifer Lopez.