Tweet

Measurement Traps

Guest post by: Jim Clemmer

Article Overview: Measuring employee or organizational performance can cut both ways. It can play a valuable role in improving organizations - or it can stand in the way of necessary change. Used effectively, measurement can provide vital feedback that shows whether approaches being used are moving the organization toward its goals. It can assess whether staff training, teamwork, empowerment, process improvement, re-engineering or other trendy ideas are producing real results.

Measurement Traps

Measuring employee or organizational performance can cut both ways. It can play a valuable role in improving organizations - or it can stand in the way of necessary change. Used effectively, measurement can provide vital feedback that shows whether approaches being used are moving the organization toward its goals. It can assess whether staff training, teamwork, empowerment, process improvement, re-engineering or other trendy ideas are producing real results.

But it can also cut into organization morale, slash team effectiveness and wound quality improvement efforts. Here are four of the most common measurement traps I see in organizations:

Managing results. The bottom line is history. It shows today's consequences of yesterday's management decisions, but is an unreliable predictor of how today's decisions will affect tomorrow's results.

Results can't be managed any more than you can turn back time. Like a score, they form a historical record of how you did. In competitive sports you improve your score by improving your play in key strategic areas.

Improvement starts by identifying and measuring the critical few service or product production processes and support systems that have the biggest impact on your results. But if you're driving through the rear-view mirror of bottom-line results, you won't see the swamp until you are sinking in it.

Inside-out measurement. Too many measures are designed to meet internal needs. They may satisfy management's command-and-control paranoia by tracking every activity and minute of the day. Or they're designed to serve accounting, information technology, human resources or other support departments.

What's missing in this measurement mania is the customer. High-service providers measure from the outside in. They begin by measuring what's important to customers. Next on the priority order are the needs of those serving the customers. Then attention shifts to the people producing products or serving the servers. The measurement needs of managers and support departments should bring up the rear of this customer-server-producer train.

The measurement stick. Just as important as what's measured is how the information is used. In many organizations, team members and managers resist measuring accuracy rates, cycle times, rework or customer satisfaction because they've been beaten with this information.

A mountain of evidence shows that 85 to 90 percent of errors originate in the organization's structure, system or process. Yet all too many executives look for who rather than what went wrong.

To counter growing complaints from distributors, one manufacturer began measuring its rate of incomplete orders. Managers discovered mounting back-order levels, wrong parts shipped and clerical errors. More than 60 percent of the "pick orders" didn't match the distributors' invoices.

The solution was to replace the shipping department manager. The new manager promptly disciplined, fired and "motivated" clerks and shippers to shape up. After a temporary improvement, the rate of incomplete orders settled in slightly below their previous level.

The company finally focused its measurement, problem-solving and improvement activities across a wider spectrum. It looked at the entire sales, order-entry, picking-and-packing, inventory-control, accounting and invoicing process. Only then did incomplete orders plunge by nearly 300 percent.

Confusing knowing and doing. Weighing yourself 10 times a day won't take off the pounds. No matter how sophisticated, your measures are only indicators.

Improvement happens by pulling people together throughout your organization to analyze and improve key processes and support systems. What the indicators say are much less important than what's being done with the information.

Measurements that don't lead to meaningful action aren't just useless - they're wasteful.

Measurement is an essential tool for improving organizations. Choosing the right tool is important, but how skillfully the tool is used determines its effectiveness.

Related Articles
  Five Strategies to Help you Break Free of What is Standing Between You and Your Success - A Bit of Context
  How to Achieve Ideal Acoustical Quality in a Room
  Strategic Exit Planning and Strategic Tax Planning to Save Income Taxes
  MIND TRAP: Following Fads and Fashion
  MIND TRAP: Ignoring the Evidence
  MIND TRAP: When we don’t question assumptions
  How to Avoid Business Failure
  MIND TRAP: Heuristic Thinking
  Are You Ready for Next Year?
  Marketing Dashboard Best Practices
  Joining Insightful Marketing Blogs
  How Are You Going To End 2011?
  Time’s a Wasting! What are you doing with it?
  Five ways to use a special offer
  Rut Busting
  The "Customer Experience" versus "Customer Satisfaction"
  Play the Numbers Games with Advanced Search Operators
  Improve Your Team's Performance: Measure for Motivation
  The 360 Degree Trap
  Avoiding the dis-empowerment traps

Article Tags: leadership
Referred by: http://www.searchengineworkshops.com



Related Forum Posts
The 11-7-06 NEFA Meeting went very well! - The NEFA meeting held Tuesday November 7th went very well. The meeting was very well attended and Mary Tomzack of FranchiseHelp, Inc. presented her unique perspective in regards to franchising. Mary also distributed a copy of her book, "Tips & Traps of buying a franchise". The next NEFA meeting is January 23rd, when the IFA Chairman "Doc" Cohen, an American Cookie Company multi unit franchisee with make a presentation. I'll post more information when the date gets closer. Thank you!


Share this article with your friends. Fund someone's dream.

Leave a comment below or share on the left and you'll help support entrepreneurs in Africa through our partnership with Kiva. Over $50,000 raised and counting - Please keep sharing! Learn more.

Newsletter

Get advice & tips from famous business
owners, new articles by entrepreneur
experts, my latest website updates, &
special sneak peaks at what's to come!

Name:
Email:

Popular Articles

What To Do With a Troublemaker?

Business Coach Explains To You How To Add Value

Rumor Has It

Suggestions

Email us your ideas on how to make our
website more valuable! Thank you Sharon
from Toronto Salsa Lessons / Classes for
your suggestions to make the newsletter
look like the website and profile younger
entrepreneurs like Jennifer Lopez.