Like this article? PLEASE +1 it! Evan Signature
Evan Carmichael Top Header
Share for a Cause









The best way to reduce your chances of facing a personal grievance when you dismiss an employee

Written by: Michael Smyth

Article Overview: You know when your partner is upset when your soup lands in your lap and you are left sitting alone with a nearly full bottle of wine, half eaten plate of food and everyone in the restaurant staring at you. You’ve just experienced that lovely emotion we call anger and it is virtually inevitable that you will experience it if you are breaking up with your partner. It is also virtually inevitable when you dismiss an employee. The question is, will that anger turn into a personal grievance?

Free Download - Download a template or see a lawyer? By Michael Smyth
Name: Email:

The best way to reduce your chances of facing a personal grievance when you dismiss an employee

The five emotions of breakup
You will have heard the expression “the calm before the storm”. It is always there however fleeting, so be scared. The calm is that look on your partner’s face just before she reaches for the soup. We call that emotion “shock”, which (sometimes quickly and sometimes slowly) is always followed by anger. Then once the anger is gone, the aggrieved party heads into resentment where he or she feels the victim – “why me?”!
What happens from there depends on the individual. Either the person moves to the next emotion “acceptance” and then from acceptance to “hope” or the agreed person gets stuck in the shock, anger, resentment loop.
So whether you are breaking up with your partner or dismissing an employee, there is a pretty good chance that this sequence of emotions will be triggered. Your job as the instigator is to do your best to get the aggrieved person from resentment to acceptance as quickly as possible.
How to get your employee to accept the dismissal
The problem with any form of emotion is that it makes us become subjective i.e. we view things from our own perspective. A dismissed employee will adopt a very subjective view of the dismissal. Your job as the employer is to help the employee view the dismissal from an objective view point.
To do that, the most important thing you can do is adopt an objective view when making your decision to terminate the employment relationship. It is easy, (as an employer), to get caught up in the emotion of a dismissal particularly if serious misconduct or non performance issues are to blame. However, if you can be objective then you have a better chance of getting your employee to do the same thing.
Coincidently, the law requires you to be objective too.


How to be objective
It’s easier said than done, but you must try. One option is to get legal advice. Hopefully, your legal advisor will force that objectivity upon you. If you don’t then the best advice is to put yourself in the shoes of your employee and ask yourself: “what would I take issue with if I were dismissed in these circumstances?”. If you pause and force yourself to examine the dismissal from that perspective your decision making process is more likely to be robust and you will come across as a fair and reasonable employer. But it doesn’t end there…
Communicate your objectivity
Making your decision from the standpoint of a fair and reasonable employer alone won’t do the trick. You must also communicate that objectivity through the termination letter. The termination letter is probably the biggest weapon in the employer’s arsenal. Get it right, and you could save yourself from a personal grievance. Get it wrong, and can you could find yourself heading to the Employment Relations Authority.
The key to getting it right is to set out your decision making process in a reasoned way. By being reasoned, you will come across as reasonable. This means acknowledging the employee’s feedback by referring to it in the letter, saying what you accept of that feedback and what you reject (and if you reject, why); all before communicating your decision.
By setting out the termination letter in this way, you answer the question, “why me?” (Resentment) and help move the employee to Acceptance without passing the Employment Relations Authority and collecting compensation.
Never ignore the five emotions of dismissal
A dismissal process is not just about following the steps to comply with the law. It is also about moving the employee through the five emotional states of shock, anger, resentment, acceptance and hope, or SARAH for short. To do that, be objective and communicate your decision in a reasoned way. That way you are more likely to avoid the proverbial soup in the lap.

Related Articles
  How to get an employee to resign
  The employee complaints department...
  Is slash and burn the right strategy for your business?
  Go Green, Live Rich
  Personnel Policies and Procedures for Nonprofit Organizations

Home > Legal > Michael Smyth > The best way to reduce your chances of facing a personal grievance when you dismiss an employee
Article Tags: dismiss, grievance, termination

About the Author: Michael Smyth
RSS for Michael's articles - Visit Michael's website

Six years old sounds a peculiar time to start to legal career, but that's the first memory I have of going to my Dad's law firm located in the heart of legal London. So, with law running in the family, the natural choice at University was a law degree. I also had a keen interest in Sports Law and obtained a Post Graduate Certificate in the subject from Kings College London. I came to New Zealand for a year, but like a lot of people I quite liked the place, and I'm still here practising law as a self employed barrister and running three businesses: Approachable Lawyer, Sportscounsel and The Sports Risk Management Group (the last two even allow me to combine my passion for law with my passion for sport). So in my 11 or so years of practice I have read numerous cases, helped many clients out of the mire and set up a number of businesses. That means not only am I a lawyer with an expertise in employment and sport, but I am also a businessman. This gives me a good insight into a number of problems my clients face. I also like to pride myself on my approachability - But don't take my word for it, visit my website http://www.approachablelawyer.com/profile.htm

Click here to visit Michael's website
Dashed Line

More from Michael Smyth
How to decide when you need a written agreement and when you dont
How to get rid of the employee that doesnt fit
How to get an employee to resign
How directors can prevent themselves being liable for their companys debts
Three important checks every business owner should make before choosing their trading name


Related Forum Posts
Re: Franchise of a popular call center Re: Franchise of a popular call center - If you have knowledge in running a call center and know how to manage it effectively then it sounds like it’s a good business for you. Workforce management relates to employee matters like payroll, HR, and employee training. Knowledge management relates to research, strategies, innovations and the effective use of technology. In both cases your prime clients are corporate sectors especially those who want to reduce their cost and increase performance at all levels.
Document Your Processes Document Your Processes - Make sure that when you do plan on hiring an employee that you document your processes for that employee to follow, even the common sense ones. I recently interviewed a Starbucks employee and was advised that everything including menial tasks were all documented by thier Manager in thier training manual. They very seldom have to ask for clarification. This is important if you plan on having an employee inhouse or even outsourcing. When outsourcing it is more advising about your minimal acceptable standards.
Re: Improving Cash Flow Re: Improving Cash Flow - Hi aquinm78, Those are 10 excellent tips you shared for businesses to reduce debt and increase cash flow. Thanks for the detailed post as I'm sure many of us can put these to good use for both our business and personal lives. Take Care, Alan
A regular employee or a contracted employee? A regular employee or a contracted employee? - Is it more valuable to hire a regular employee or a contracted employee? When taking into account wages, unemployment insurance and training in a company, which is better to hire?
Working with Suppliers Working with Suppliers - Hi Mary, You're facing a very common issue for entrepreneurs. 2 suggestions I have for you: 1) Develop a personal relationship. Get to know your potential suppliers and meet with them face to face. If it's a meeting you set up or you find them at a tradeshow, etc get to know the people and they're much more likely to cut you a break. People want to work with people they know and like. 2) Have you considered smaller, local suppliers who see your business as more important?


Recommended Article for You close

  How to get an employee to resign

Share this article with your friends. Fund someone's dream.

Leave a comment below or share on the left and you'll help support entrepreneurs in Africa through our partnership with Kiva. Over $50,000 raised and counting - Please keep sharing! Learn more.



Featured Article


Bottom Footer
Share for a Cause












Newsletter

Get advice & tips from famous business
owners, new articles by entrepreneur
experts, my latest website updates, &
special sneak peaks at what's to come!
Name:
Email:
Popular Articles

The Death of the Sales Magazine

Executive Blind Spots

What If You Had a 100% Success Rate?

Suggestions

Email us your ideas on how to make our
website more valuable! Thank you Sharon
from Toronto Salsa Lessons / Classes for
your suggestions to make the newsletter
look like the website and profile younger
entrepreneurs like Jennifer Lopez.