Tweet

Battle Over Health Care Reform Now Reaches U.S. Supreme Court

Guest post by: Julio Portilla

Article Overview: The battle over health care reform has now reached the Supreme Court. The petition that has been filed may be at the leading edge of a wave of litigation over the controversial legislation. It is challenging a June 29th ruling by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 6th Circuit that upheld the so-called “individual mandate” under the landmark health care legislation.

Battle Over Health Care Reform Now Reaches U.S. Supreme Court

The battle over federal health care reform is now before the U.S. Supreme Court.

The Thomas More Law Center today announced that it had filed its petition for certiorari in Thomas More Law Center v. Obama, its challenge to a June 29 ruling by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 6th Circuit that upheld the so-called “individual mandate” under the landmark health care legislation. That provision of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act requires individuals to purchase at least minimum health care insurance coverage.

“Review is necessary to establish a meaningful limitation on congressional power under the Commerce Clause,” the petition argues. “If the Act is understood to fall within Congress’s Commerce Clause authority, the federal government will have absolute and unfettered power to create complex regulatory schemes to fix every perceived problem imaginable and to do so by ordering private citizens to engage in affirmative acts, under penalty of law.”

As examples, the brief asserts that if the individual mandate is upheld in the health care arena, government would feel free to order citizens to take vitamins, join health clubs, or buy General Motors cars.

The petition may be at the leading edge of a wave of litigation over the controversial legislation, challenging the first of several expected appeals court rulings in coming months.

Because the 6th Circuit is the only appeals court that has ruled thus far, the petition could not make what is usually the strongest argument for review by the Supreme Court.

Instead, the brief cites a rule of the Supreme Court suggesting that review is appropriate when “a United States court of appeals has decided an important question of federal law that has not, but should be, settled by this Court.”

The petition cites the line of cases mainly from the Rehnquist Court seeking to limit the power of Congress under the Constitution’s Commerce Clause. Those precedents, the petition states, mean that “before Congress can reach you through the Commerce Clause, you must be engaged in some affirmative activity.”

Two of the three members of the 6th Circuit panel agreed, for different reasons, that the government had made a plausible case that the individual mandate is constitutional because an individual’s decision not to obtain health coverage has economic consequences. The judges were Boyce Martin and Jeffrey Sutton. Sutton’s opinion has been viewed as especially important because he is a respected conservative judge who, as appellate lawyer, often argued in favor of state sovereignty. The dissenting judge in the 6th Circuit case was Ohio U.S. District Court Judge James Graham, sitting by designation.

The petition was filed by Thomas Muise of the Ann Arbor, Michigan-based More Center. David Yerushalmi of the Law Offices of David Yerushalmi in Chandler, Arizona, was also on the brief. Following a reply by the Obama administration, the case would likely be weighed by the justices at the Court’s private conference in late September, though it could also consider the petition during the summer recess.

Related Articles
  Unconstitutional Obamacare Law Declared "Void"
  Small Business Medical Insurance - Six Health Care Reform Questions, and Answers
  Health Insurance Reform Now
  The Uninsured: Don't Fall Through The Cracks
  The Rising Cost of Healthcare…Can Small Business Keep Up?
  Financial Debt: America's New Public Enemy
  Radiology Job Outlook
  Orthopedic Forecast
  California Labor Law Update: Recent Court Decisions Favor Employers
  Bye Bye Business Method Patents
  HR Outsourcing Firms Assist Employers with Changing HR Regulations
  It’s That Time of Year
  Expansion of Employee Retaliation Protection
  3 Lawsuits That Are Changing the California Labor Law Landscape
  Take Personal Responsibility For Your Health
  Betting on Obama healthcare
  Florida Health Insurance Corp Reports Health Care Reform
  AARP Health Insurance - The Insured Guide To AARP
  Health Insurance Basics
  Lesson #2: To Make the Dunk You Need to First Take the Jump

Article Tags: 6th circuit, health care, julio portilla, law offices NYC, NYC attorney, petition, US Supreme Court
Referred by: http://www.3MMediaGroup.com



Related Forum Posts
Re: Are Economic Recessions Good for Franchising? - All we can do is remain wide awake and pay attention to the ebb and flow. My strategy is to be prepared and go with the flow. There could be some rough times ahead... Interestingly, our business has remained strong. I believe it's because we're in such a tight little niche and we're well positioned to sign jobs nationwide, therefore we're not restricted to location. We also target affluent markets that have higher disposable incomes - this we do locally. Here are some Franchise Categories that could weather a good recession... Health and Personal Care Food services like Subway Debt Collection Tax Preparers & Advisors Any other recession proof franchise opps out there?
Re: HI@All - Hi David, Welcome to the forum. Look forward to your contributions here. Take Care, Alan
Home Care Business Opportunity - You should not buy a franchise until you review our Senior Care Business Opportunity... Michael Gultz
Re: Hi Everybody - Hey Tim! Welcome to the forums. We're no stranger, either, and I look forward to the insight and discussions you'll bring here. Take Care, Alan
Re: Hi from Adelaide Australia - Hey Dave, Welcome aboard! Great to have you here. Looking forward to your contributions in the forums. Take Care, Alan


Share this article with your friends. Fund someone's dream.

Leave a comment below or share on the left and you'll help support entrepreneurs in Africa through our partnership with Kiva. Over $50,000 raised and counting - Please keep sharing! Learn more.

Newsletter

Get advice & tips from famous business
owners, new articles by entrepreneur
experts, my latest website updates, &
special sneak peaks at what's to come!

Name:
Email:

Popular Articles

The Pure FUN of Learning & Using NLP

Stay Employed In A Down Economy

International Employment Background Checks

Suggestions

Email us your ideas on how to make our
website more valuable! Thank you Sharon
from Toronto Salsa Lessons / Classes for
your suggestions to make the newsletter
look like the website and profile younger
entrepreneurs like Jennifer Lopez.