Tweet

Marketing Creativity vs. Analytics

Guest post by: Nate Gibby

Article Overview: It is only responsible for Fast Company to publish an article about a CMO's balancing of creativity and analytics in its most recent issue featuring the top 100 creative people in business. We've seen too many cool and creative ideas and approaches to marketing flounder when it comes to what matters most to business-driving bottom line results.

Marketing Creativity vs. Analytics

It is only responsible for Fast Company to publish an article about a CMO’s balancing of creativity and analytics in its most recent issue featuring the top 100 creative people in business (see June 2010 edition). After all, Serfwerks has been touting the need for using data and analytics to drive the creative process in marketing since its founding. We’ve seen too many cool and creative ideas and approaches to marketing flounder when it comes to what matters most to business—driving bottom line results.

For example, years ago I worked for a design agency that frequently produced outstanding creative work. We had a client who sold candy machines to individuals looking to make a quick buck on the side. Their primary marketing strategy consisted of low-brow advertising in home-based business magazines. When the client engaged us to develop a new ad for them, we had some brilliantly creative ideas (at least so we thought). The best of which consisted of a full-page ad comprised of a beautifully serene photograph of a vacant beach with an empty hammock between two trees (I wish I still had a copy of it). The image was such that you could easily picture yourself in the scene, taking in the beautiful vistas of the palm trees and crystal blue water. A small headline read “Lifestyle brought to you by (Company X).” Of course the company’s contact information was included as well as a small picture of a gum ball machine in the bottom right corner.Of course we thought that the ad was brilliant and sure to distinguish our client from so many other bottom feeders that gravitated to that type of publication.

However, the ad was the client’s worst performing ad to date. Not only did it not perform well, but sales immediately tanked. It was so bad that the client put their old ad back into the edition of the magazine. How could it perform so poorly? Our new ad was more conceptual, better designed and was probably the only ad in the magazine that didn’t have either a starburst or a bulleted list of some sort on it. We sat scratching our heads as to why what we thought was so creative and brilliant had failed so miserably.

It turns out that our brilliantly creative ad was the perfect case study for unbounded creativity, where creativity exists for creativity’s sake and strives for distinction through whit and/or good design rather than seeking to accomplish real-world business objectives. Don’t misunderstand that creativity certainly has its merit. However, in our instance we didn’t understand to whom we were marketing. We over thought our target audience thinking that the aspiration of a better lifestyle was what drove their entrepreneurial behavior. However, they were just looking to make a quick extra buck. As such, the more conceptual, better designed ad had little appeal. It’s also possible that in our efforts to glamorize gum ball machines, we lost touch with reality. Perhaps luxury vacations in exotic beaches is too much of a stretch for a business that lives on spare quarters. Perhaps the strategy could have worked had the client been willing to stick it out and go with a more conceptual long-term strategy. However, their business reality was such that they just couldn’t afford to go another month without any phone calls. As such, we would have served our client much better had we based our marketing efforts on marketing analytics and market data as opposed to simply going for what we thought was cool and creative.

In conclusion, I applaud Fast Company for their contribution to the groundswell that is the need to bind creativity with marketing analytics and market data. We hope that CMOs, executives and entrepreneurs alike will continue to look more to data-driven marketing solutions when developing marketing strategies rather than simply going for what is cool and creative. That is truly the only way in which marketing performance can most effectively impact bottom-line results.

Related Articles
  Marketing Losing its Mojo? Not So Fast
  Article #38 Simple How To Web Analytics
  Google Analytics - Just the Facts
  Marketing Analytics – the 411 on Generating Business Leads
  What is Marketing Analytics?
  How to Use Google Analytics to Gain That Needed Edge Over Your Competition
  Web Analytics For The Uninitiated
  Using Web Analytics for Marketing
  The Importance Of Using Web Analytics
  Google Analytics - How Accurate is it?
  Track Inventory in QuickBooks?
  Google Analytics Overview: A Must Tool for Webmasters To Discover The Insights Of Their Website
  Google Analytics – What is it?
  Integrating Web Analytics into Your Daily Internet Marketing Campaigns
  Free Web Analytics from Google
  Web Analytics that Lie
  Google Analytics
  The Importance Of Analytics In Your Internet Marketing Campaign
  Hitslink vs. Google Analytics
  What is Google Analytics?

Article Tags: chief marketing officer, CMO, creativity, datadriven marketing, Fast Company, magazine, marketing analytics, marketing strategy, unbounded creativity



Related Forum Posts
Re: What I Enjoyed Reading This Week - June 11 - Hi Evan, Thank you for the reading material. I look forward to the general release later this month as outlined in the 'Google Analytics To Add Search Query Data From Webmaster Tools' article. Anything that helps us to understand maximise extra data from Google Analytics can only be of benefit. regards, Mal.
Re: Google Places Review | How to Get a Review on Google Places? - Hi Evan, Yes, I am planning more. I have multiple videos coming out this year on: Social media marketing Email marketing Lead Generation Organic search marketing Conversion rate optimization Analytics Content marketing Paid search marketing I am looking for SEO / Internet Marketing questions people have. I enjoy producing videos answer tuff SEO questions. Let me know if you are any of your members have any they want answered. Jeff
Re: What is your Business? - We are running a Online Marketing Firm and we have some good clients to which we are offering a complete Digital Marketing strategy like Search, Mobile Marketing, Branding and Design. I think in Online Marketing company online presence can be a wining factor for the success of the company.
Essential Leadership skills - Delegate Serve Creativity optimistic smart Focused Reliable honest Good sense of judgment consistent... It all comes from the confidence from within
Re: Ranked #1 in just over 7 weeks - Thanks guys. You're right GT. It's jsut a matter of doing what needs to be done. Analytics is starting to show the results a bit too.


Share this article with your friends. Fund someone's dream.

Leave a comment below or share on the left and you'll help support entrepreneurs in Africa through our partnership with Kiva. Over $50,000 raised and counting - Please keep sharing! Learn more.

Newsletter

Get advice & tips from famous business
owners, new articles by entrepreneur
experts, my latest website updates, &
special sneak peaks at what's to come!

Name:
Email:

Popular Articles

The five pillars of internet marketing strategy

Five Ways to Show Honest Appreciation

WHAT IS MANAGEMENT CONSULTING

Suggestions

Email us your ideas on how to make our
website more valuable! Thank you Sharon
from Toronto Salsa Lessons / Classes for
your suggestions to make the newsletter
look like the website and profile younger
entrepreneurs like Jennifer Lopez.