Tweet

Teacher Perspectives of Classroom Disruptions

Written by: Dr. Derrick L. Campbell

Article Overview: High incidences of classroom disruptions, disrespect towards a teacher, and open defiance indicate that teachers and students have challenges with developing and maintaining positive classroom relationships which ultimately impact school discipline and student achievement. At a high school consisting of 95% White Teachers and 99% of historically underserved students (HUS) interviewed teachers believed teacher student relationships, student attitudes, and student preparation caused classroom disruptions.

Teacher Perspectives of Classroom Disruptions

High incidences of classroom disruptions, disrespect towards a teacher, and open defiance indicate that teachers and students have challenges with developing and maintaining positive classroom relationships which ultimately impact school discipline and student achievement.

At a high school consisting of 95% White Teachers and 99% of historically underserved students (HUS) interviewed teachers believed teacher student relationships, student attitudes, and student preparation caused classroom disruptions.

An interviewed teacher believed teacher-student relationships caused classroom disruptions. "I noticed that there are certain people who have a lot of discipline problems. I watch how they interact with the kids, and they don't have that relationship."

Most White teachers at this school have challenges with developing positive teacher-student classroom relationships with HUS. [HUS] students are more likely to encounter teacher behavior that impedes their progress when compared to White students (Cooper, Baron, & Lowe, 1977; Datta et al., 1968; Dornbusch et al., 1975; Rubovits & Maehr, 1973).

However, [HUS] and White teachers can develop positive classroom relationships. Positive relationships at schools and in the classroom are in many ways the prerequisites for effective learning and behavior (Pianta, 1999). Teacher-student conflicts result from a difference in desires, and even though this difference maybe reduced, it remains in schools (Waller, 1932). The classroom conflict between teachers and students results from the different cultural contexts that students and teachers bring to the classroom (Hall, 1989; McDermott, 1977).

Another teacher believed classroom disruptions begin with student attitudes. The teacher stated: "I have one student in particular. Whenever she has a bad day, she comes in, and she will have the worst attitude. She will not want to do any work, and that could lead to a discipline referral because she is refusing to do [the] work." As children advance in school, they become "less willing to try for fear of making mistakes and being embarrassed in front of their peers" (Haberman, 1995, p. 76). Teachers should encourage and praise students for doing their best, regardless of their work when compared to other students (Ashmore & Project M.E.D.I.A, 1984; Borich, 1986; Good, 1983; Rosenshine, 1983). Encouragement has a positive impact on teacher-student relationships in the classroom. Encouragement from teachers in a school setting may enhance student self-esteem, thereby increasing teacher effectiveness (Sava, 2002). Cunniff (1989) reported that teachers could facilitate the development of student self-esteem by taking a personal interest in students, by rewarding them for all successes, and by equating effort with ability.

Another teacher stated: "You can tell when they [are going to] refuse to participate. Every time I stand in the door, I say hi to all my students. I stand in the door [to] make sure I make contact with every student before they come to my room. Sometimes they do not want to say hi. So I know from the door that there is something wrong." Teachers who engage students one by one in casual conversation before class begin to lose most of the student's interest after 20 minutes (Chappell & McCoy, 2003).

Another teacher believed student preparation caused classroom disruptions. This teacher stated, "The student was tired, not physically ready, or mentally ready to participate in the activity . . . The more I persisted, the more oppositional the student became". While teachers believed that students were the root cause for classroom disruptions students had a different view. References

Ashmore, J., & Project M.E.D.I.A. (1984). A Manual of Instructional Strategies. Unpublished manuscript, Department of Instructional and Support Services Jefferson County Public Schools.

Borich, G. (1986). Paradigm of teacher effectiveness research? Their relationship to the concept of effective teaching. Education and Urban Society, 13(18), 143-167.

Chappell, C., & McCoy, L. (2003). Studies in Teaching. In Wake Forest University (Ed.), Research Digest: Research Projects Presented at Annual Research Forum. Winston-Salem, NC: Wake Forest University.

Cooper, H., Baron, R., & Lowe, C. (1997). The importance of race and social class information of expectations about academic performance. Journal of Educational Psychology, 67(2), 312-319.

Cunniff, E. (1989). Leading students to optimal performance through motivation. Unpublished manuscript, Indiana University South Bend.

Datta, L., Schaefer, E., & Davis, M. (1968). Sex and Scholastic Aptitude as Variables in Teachers' Ratings of the Adjustment and Classroom Behavior of Negro and Other Seventh-grade Students. Journal of Educational Psychology, 59(2), 94-101.

Dornbusch, S., Massey, G., & Scott, M. (1975). Racism Without Racists: Institutional Racism in Urban Schools. Stanford: Stanford University Publications

Good, T. (1983). Classroom research: A decade of progress. Educational Psychologist, 18(3), 127-144.

Haberman, M. (1995). Star teachers of children in poverty. West Lafayette, IN: Kappa Delta Pi.

Hall, E. (1989). Unstated features of the cultural context of learning. The Educational Forum, 54(1), 21-34.

McDermott, R. (1977). Social relations as contexts for learning in school. Harvard Educational Review, 47(2), 198-213.

Pianta, R. (1999). Enhancing relationships between children and teachers (1st). Washington, DC: American Psychological Association.

Rosenshine, B. (1983). Teaching Functions in Instructional Programs. The Elementary School Journal, 83(4), 335-351

Rubovits, P., & Maehr, M. (1973). Pygmalion black and white. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 25(2), 210-218.

Sava, F. (2002). Causes and effects of teacher conflict-inducing attitudes towards pupils: a path analysis model. Teaching and Teacher Education, 18(8), 1007-1021.

Waller, W. (1932). Sociology of Teaching. New York: John and Wiley and Sons.

Related Articles
  Student Perspectives of Classroom Disruptions
  Connect for the Success of Your Child
  Steering the Organizational Change Process
  “Market Research” Story
  Self Employment as an Alternative Career to Teaching

Article Tags: classroom disruptions, student relationships, teacher perspectives, teacher student



Related Forum Posts
Re: Soul Crushing Cubicles - There are lots of "crushing cubicles" in Japan too! Last Saturday I had three hours to kill in town and rented a cubicle in a cyber-cafe, drank coffee, checked my email and snoozed in the reclining chair. Very pleasant! But for some people cyber-cafe cubicles are their only homes. Another "crushing cubicle" experience is a "capsule" in a "capsule hotel". The guy in the first photo reminded me of the kind of desk space occupied by some "ALTs" (Assistant Language Teacher) in Japan. Japanese school staffroom desks are notorious for being cluttered with junk and endless piles of papers and forms. I was a part time ALT for a while and enjoyed the experience - but full time? No thank you!
Meet Kim Kleeman - Shakespeare Squared: Named one of Inc.'s - THIS IS PRETTY INTERESTING. WISH I'D THOUGHT OF IT FIRST!!!! Meet Kim Kleeman: Shakespeare Squared: Named one of Inc.'s 500 Fastest Growing Private Companies in America. Recognized as one of Working Mother magazine's 25 Best Small Companies. Awarded the title of Illinois Family Business of the Year. Lofty accomplishments for company founder Kim Kleeman, a woman who just a few short years ago swore she would never own her own business! Having grown up the child of business-owner parents, Kleeman knew well the stresses and demands that entrepreneurial life can place upon a family. She met her husband, Jay, on the first day of college, and together they earned their teaching degrees and started making plans for a modest but happy life. When Jay's stint as a student teacher strained the family budget, though, they both started doing subcontract work proofing elementary school textbooks. Before long, they were taking on bigger jobs and hiring other teachers to freelance on various projects, and from that point on, they never looked back. In 2003, the couple founded Shakespeare Squared, an educational development company that employs an army of freelancers to write and edit materials such as textbooks, lesson plans, teacher guides, activity workbooks, and test-preparation materials. Initially a home-based business managed by Kim while Jay continued his work as a high school teacher, the company now has a full-time staff of 20 and is branching out in new directions, publishing its own materials and offering an educational editing certification process. In three years' time, the company has grown by an incredible 815 percent, bringing in $2.3 million in revenue last year. What we learned from Kim: That the most incredible resource for launching might very well be your own friends and family. Kim started this business with her husband; her best friend since high school is her director of human resources; her sister is a remote project coordinator; her lawyer brother weighs in on various matters; her mom is a managing editor; and her parents are her de facto advisory board, with whom she meets every morning to share a cup of tea and conversation in their backyard. Words of Wisdom "Trust your instincts and empower your people." From Teacher to Tycoon "I don't know if I had a big 'aha' moment about starting a business; our growth was really organic. After my second child I immediately got pregnant with my third and there was no turning back, because we weren't going to be able to afford day care for two babies on two teachers' salaries. I had been working from home and continuously had one or two projects going, and I set a goal of having 10 projects running simultaneously. So after my son was born, I enacted my own guerilla marketing plan and e-mailed every editorial director at the big publishing companies, looking for projects. We soon landed our first big client, HarperCollins Children's Books." Not About the Money "I just wanted to make the best company that I could and be happy doing it. If that included millions of dollars, great, but that wasn't really the goal. I didn't know at first how much work we would end up getting, but I think the extensive classroom experience of our people sets us apart in this field. As teachers ourselves, we understand the needs of our clients and we deliver on that." It Takes a Village "We employ over 400 freelance writers. Most are former teachers but we pull from publishing, journalism, and other fields as well. We developed a writing test that covers everything from copyrighting to educational taboos, and prospective freelancers must earn at least a B+. A nice plus with our business is the opportunity we can offer teachers for life beyond teaching. I really promote teachers in the classroom, but if the classroom just isn't your thing and you're still passionate about education, there is a place for you here." Those Who Can, Teach "Educators in this country are getting a bad rap. We ask them to perform many roles and yet we're not supporting them as a society. Prospective teachers must student teach to become certified and are expected to not work while doing so, but there are so many people from diverse backgrounds who would love to teach-and who would be great teachers-who can't afford to do that. The Shakespeare Squared Foundation helps pay for prospective teachers to student teach. My passion is to get the right teachers in place, because that makes all the difference for students." The Best and the Brightest "It is definitely a challenge to find and retain the best talent, because I am up against large publishers. I have to provide a different culture and be creative in the way I offer benefits. We really believe in the work/life balance and offer such things as flex hours, remote work capabilities, and a working-parents room in the office. We've been recognized for these efforts, and because of them, our turnover is very low." Networking 101 "You have to go into a networking situation with the idea in mind that there will be one person in the crowd who can make a difference to you, and you have to find that person. You may be talking to someone who makes shoelaces and has nothing in common with your business, but she may know someone in your field or know about an interesting business practice that could translate to your own. But the bottom line is that if it's not the right conversation, you politely cut it short and move on." Strength in Numbers "There is so much value in the process of incubating an idea with other women. I am always looking for women who are coming together creatively and collaboratively because things flow from it that you would never dream. When women support other women, we empower each other to take charge of our lives, whether by owning our own businesses or making a career change or making decisions about our families." Best Advice "I read in Working Mother magazine that women CEOs need to take the ability that they have in their work life to delegate responsibility and create a management team and apply that to their home life as well. So I really try to think of running my household the same way I run my business; whether it's cleaning ladies or repairmen, I find people I trust and have them take care of tasks that I don't need to spend time on. This has relieved a lot of guilt and allowed me to focus on the things that are really important." Most Rewarding Moments "Winning the Working Mother award as one of the 25 Best Small Companies felt pretty great because it showed that having a unique workplace does pay off. But even better is realizing that your message is getting across to your people. I love seeing quotes at my team's desks about goals and achieving your dreams, all of the exact things I say to empower them. It's cool to realize that there isn't a lot of cynicism, and that people are really buying into these ideas and making them their own." Parting Thoughts ... "My secret weapon is the news articles that I send to my team." "I will retire when I have no more dreams to accomplish." "I will always think of myself as a teacher." "My greatest strength is my enthusiasm." This featured lady was profiled by Noelle Pechar Hale, a freelance writer living in Los Angeles.


Share this article with your friends. Fund someone's dream.

Leave a comment below or share on the left and you'll help support entrepreneurs in Africa through our partnership with Kiva. Over $50,000 raised and counting - Please keep sharing! Learn more.

Tweet

Newsletter

Get advice & tips from famous business
owners, new articles by entrepreneur
experts, my latest website updates, &
special sneak peaks at what's to come!

Name:
Email:

Popular Articles

Work at Home Moms and Their Bad Rap?

WHAT IS MANAGEMENT CONSULTING

Local Marketing: 3 Simple Low-Cost Strategies

Suggestions

Email us your ideas on how to make our
website more valuable! Thank you Sharon
from Toronto Salsa Lessons / Classes for
your suggestions to make the newsletter
look like the website and profile younger
entrepreneurs like Jennifer Lopez.