Tweet

Competing motivations creating confusion

Written by: Sue Barrett

Article Overview: How to incentivise and reward sales people has long been a contentious topic. Too many times I have seen businesses set up incentive programs that reward the wrong behaviours which can affect team morale, client relationships, sales, staff retention, and so on. For instance, I recently met the managing director of a medium sized software business who asked me why would his sales people keep selling one version of their product when they had been instructed to also sell in a newer more comprehensive version of the product.

Competing motivations creating confusion

How to incentivise and reward sales people has long been a contentious topic. Too many times I have seen businesses set up incentive programs that reward the wrong behaviours which can affect team morale, client relationships, sales, staff retention, and so on.

For instance, I recently met the managing director of a medium sized software business who asked me why would his sales people keep selling one version of their product when they had been instructed to also sell in a newer more comprehensive version of the product.

I asked him two questions:

1. "How do your sales people get incentivised for each product sale?"

2. "Do they earn most of their income from their commissions or from their base salary?"

It turned out that his sales people earned more commission by selling in the older version than the newer version of his product. And the sales people made the bulk of their income from their commissions rather than from their salaries.

There you have it. What makes perfect sense to the sales person - "If I make more money by selling in one type of product and the majority of my income comes from my commissions I would be stupid selling anything else." does not always work for the organisation or the customer.

Lesson: If you want a different outcome (as did the aforementioned MD), you need to think about what behaviours you want to drive and reward in your people that don't create competing motivations.

And here in lies the issue with certain aspects of the Financial Planning industry.

Much of what is being written about the Financial Planning industry in current and recent times is centering around the issue about competing motivations.

As I see it there are two different models in operation in the Financial Planning industry:

Fee for service model

* Is where you engage an independent Financial adviser to guide you and instruct you in your financial planning and wealth management strategies. These people are in the business of selling their consulting services and their advice. They earn their income purely off their hourly consulting time. Service fees are applicable to the level of service provided. Their focus is on advising on the three keys are of wealth management: Creation, Consolidation and Distribution with no products commission attached to their advice.

Product sales model

• Is where you buy a specific product or suite of products to incorporate into your financial planning and wealth management strategies. In this instance you know you are buying a product via a transactional product sale. You can do this at a bank branch for instance. Some people who run their own self-managed super funds work this way by purchasing only product. Others may use a broker who sells a range of these products and can provide easy access to the right product you need. Brokers usually make their money by getting a commission on the sale of these products. Some brokers also make trail commissions for the life time of the sale which is where you are seeing an increase in complaints. This model is basically the old Insurance Sales model.

There is nothing wrong with these models so long as they are open and transparent and do what they say they do.

Basically, people should know what they are getting i.e. independent advice for a specified fee or product for a specified fee/commission. For instance there are customers who do not want to ‘pay fee for service' and prefer the commission model so these two models offer choice which is only fair in an open market.

However the problems arising for the Financial Planning industry is when people using the ‘product sales model' try to pass it off as the ‘independent financial adviser' model. All this does is create competing motivations like:

• "Do I give my client what is best for them or best for me?"
• "I need to sell more product to supplement my retirement pool not necessarily my clients."

The issue as I see with this approach it is that we are more likely to get products that make the most money for the broker or planner not the best product or solution for us. We are at risk of becoming a vehicle for them to make as much money as possible at our expense as is evidenced by some of the more spectacular business failures in recent times.

Financial Planners who are really only selling product with a commission structure attached as their main source of income cannot truly act in an independent advisory or consulting role.

The competing motivation that can arise is that they can become more concerned with how they could get paid rather than how they can provide better advice for their clients.

This poses some important questions for the industry:

• Why have these competing motivations been allowed to manifest?
• In the industry trying to squeeze a product sales model into a consulting sales model?
• What is the industry doing about creating a client centric model where it's all about the client and the client's outcome?
• What relationships have been created with the product suppliers that may be leading to these competing motivations?

In my opinion the terms Financial Adviser or Financial Planner have been poorly defined and often misused by the industry potentially leading to misunderstandings, confusion, and in some cases distress and financial loss for some customers because they did not get what they paid for.

In my opinion, those who sell product should be called a Financial Product Specialist or Financial Products Broker.

And those who truly practice legitimate Fee for Service models can rightly call themselves a Financial Adviser or Financial Planner.

Clearly this issue will not go away until the industry finds the best way to legitimately define Financial Advising or Financial Planning and stop creating opportunities for competing motivations which only serve to devalue their industry and its potential for a truly professional model that works for all. More work to be done here .

Remember everybody lives by selling something.

Related Articles
  Are you creating competing motivations in your sales force?
  Confusion - Time to Refocus
  How Useful is Confusion?
  Stop Taking the Bait of Projection!
  Sales Coaching Action Plan

Article Tags: base salary, behaviours, client relationships, commissions, contentious topic, financial planning, incentive programs, income comes from, independent financial adviser, managing director, models, motivations, perfect sense, salaries, sales person, sales staff, service model, software business, staff retention, team morale



Related Forum Posts
Re: How to be a Sales Superstar by Mark Tewart - I was able to listen to the show without even knowing of these forums, and I must say it was fantastic dialogue. Mark obivously has a masterful understanding of success, and his motivations in his writing inspire many of us to do better and be better in our quasi-sales careers.
TimeZone - Hi Andy, If you go to the homepage of the forums you can see what the official forum time is so there is no confusion. Looks like you are well ahead of the pack for April!
Franchising Brokers vs Franchising Consultants - I'm betting some of you more seasoned franchise experts know more about this than I do. I wasn't aware of the big divide between these two job descriptions, [i:1nz0q76x]and the potential conflict of interests[/i:1nz0q76x], until recently. If you're a prospective franchisee and you hire a franchise consultant / broker, do you know what you're getting into? You might find that your broker has motivations to steer you into a few select franchises where he gets a sizable bonus... clever little scheme. How do you prevent this from happening to you? ..
Re: Prizes for referrals - [quote="OmnivoreInk":1yqw36kb][quote:1yqw36kb]If we were to email the members what could we do to motivate them to actually bring a friend on board?[/quote:1yqw36kb] It's been a while since I signed up so I don't remember the details, but couldn't you add a "referred by" box? Then, if that person makes 5 posts of value, the referrer gets a free tie (if a guy) or a box of chocolates (if a gal)...[/quote:1yqw36kb] Hi Barbara, That's a good suggestion, but would you know of any programs or phpBB mods that could help keep track of referrals? And I think another problem would be ensuring that new members properly identify the people who referred them. For instance, one of my friends would probably say "Kevin" or "Kevin Lee" referred them, while they should list user "BuzzAroundBooks" to avoid confusion. Furthermore, what would prevent a current member from creating 5 new email addresses, 5 forum accounts and writing 25 posts of value to win the prize?
Re: Highly Informative Free SEO Tools - Thank you very much. I just want to point out though that since no one exactly knows the search engine algorithms some (but by no means all) tools must be taken with a grain of salt. Tools that count links etc. are very helpful because they are what they are and as long as they work there is no room for confusion. I am checking all of these links out thanks again for the advice!


Share this article with your friends. Fund someone's dream.

Leave a comment below or share on the left and you'll help support entrepreneurs in Africa through our partnership with Kiva. Over $50,000 raised and counting - Please keep sharing! Learn more.

Tweet

Newsletter

Get advice & tips from famous business
owners, new articles by entrepreneur
experts, my latest website updates, &
special sneak peaks at what's to come!

Name:
Email:

Popular Articles

How to Improve Your Time Management

Effective Leadership

2011 Global Brand Trends Letter

Suggestions

Email us your ideas on how to make our
website more valuable! Thank you Sharon
from Toronto Salsa Lessons / Classes for
your suggestions to make the newsletter
look like the website and profile younger
entrepreneurs like Jennifer Lopez.