Tweet

Is the U.S. Government or a competitor in charge of the Congressional hearings involving Toyota

Guest post by: Jon Hansen

Article Overview: Today's Business Thought Leaders segment with author and industry expert Bill Michels was incredible. Of the several noteworthy observations Michels provided, his revelation that the current Congressional hearings regarding the Toyota recall has the Japanese manufacturer actually giving testimony before a competitor raises a number of red flags. The moment that the U.S. Government became a majority owner of General Motors through its $30 billion “investment,” hearings such as the one involving Toyota are no longer arms length. In short, if a conflict arose in a judicial hearing where the judge and the defendant had a similar-type relationship to the one between the U.S. Government and Toyota, the judge would have to step down in the interests of justice.

Is the U.S. Government or a competitor in charge of the Congressional hearings involving Toyota

Today's Business Thought Leaders segment with author and industry expert Bill Michels was incredible. Of the several noteworthy observations Michels provided, his revelation that the current Congressional hearings regarding the Toyota recall has the Japanese manufacturer actually giving testimony before a competitor raises a number of red flags.

The moment that the U.S. Government became a majority owner of General Motors through its $30 billion “investment,” hearings such as the one involving Toyota are no longer arms length. In short, if a conflict arose in a judicial hearing where the judge and the defendant had a similar-type relationship to the one between the U.S. Government and Toyota, the judge would have to step down in the interests of justice.

Besides raising the question as to whether Toyota can receive a fair hearing from a government which owns a majority stake in one of the company’s competitors, several questions of even greater significance center on whether the government forfeited its right to convene such a hearing and, if they have, what legislative body could legitimately assume the mantle of representing the public interest in a forum that would be above reproach?

Looking down the road, and again referencing the judicial system, if Toyota feels that they did not receive a fair hearing, should they not be afforded the same rights as an accused who would have a solid basis for having a judgment overturned based on a similar conflict of interest.

The fact is that over the years Toyota has had an overall impeccable reputation for quality, that is now being scrutinized by a competitor. While there are certainly issues that have to be addressed by the company internally, ones in which Bill touched on during the course of the show including the emergence and effective utilization of advanced analysis tools, however unintended one cannot help but wonder if the U.S. Government has fallen down on its own platform of fair dealings and objective decision-making.

Related Articles
  Brand loyalty drives higher ROI and stock price
  What can we learn from the Toyota crisis?
  Customer Loyalty, Brand and Expectations
  Toyota Brakes and Toyota White Gloves
  Market Value is Not Determined by Wall Street
  Six Recurrent Benefits for Social Response Capitalists: Some Surprising Solutions
  Renewing Limited Government: Term Limits
  Problems First
  Why Should I Care About the SBA?
  Too Big To Fail: Part Of The Story
  Why Should I Care About the SBA? - Mash Bonigala
  Mubarak Abdullahi’s home-made helicopter takes Nigeria’s Kano Plains by storm
  Change starts with you
  The Toyota lesson, risk management and your business plan
  The Recession and Canadian Government Grants For Business
  Share of Mind Leads to Share of Wallet
  Glossary of National Labor Relations Board Terms
  Entrepreneurs and the “Oh! No!” Trap
  Success: The Collaborative Win
  Should You Continue Looking for a Lucrative but Easy Home Based Business Opportunity as the Economy Improves?

Article Tags: Toyota, US Congressional Hearings



Related Forum Posts
Re: How do I find a direct mail list of potential customers - Hi WhyNot, Is it possible there are websites about the Federal Government. It needs to delve into it to find the key person. Listening for once to the news could pinpoint who is really in charge of this department. I wish you wisdom to connect with the right people. Nothing is too difficult, if you put your mind to it. Maybe some one else has a supportive idea.
Re: Can someone explain Search engine optimization to me? - Hi, Ask yourself, "What is the goal of a search engine like Google?" A search engine's goal is to provide the most related (or best) web page results when someone searches. Do you think people are searching for "Auction Cars Government" or "Government Car Auction." In fact type those keywords into Google with the quotation marks. You will find that Google gives different results for each keyword phrases. Granted you get many of the web pages ranking the same but there is a difference. My answer is, use "Government Car Auction" or even "Government Seized Car Auction" because that is what people are searching for. That is how the majority of the indexed pages use. That is what makes sense when you read the phrase. Jeff
Comparisons - Hi Jessica - that is enviable having only one competitor. Then you should look at companies that are offering approximately the same kind of service (i.e. retail, etc), seeking the same kind of investment and look at what they charge and what they offer. Cheers
Re: The Flaw In Personal Branding...? - Last time I posted, in the same week, Michael Jackson died. Then I thought about something-- If you remember Michael, he was far from flawless. Yet the biggest pop icon of all time. Having said this, the flaw in personal branding can exist as long as they're not hurting what people perceive you to be. In other words, if say... Toyota begins producing average quality cars, it'll eventually start to change the way the rest of the world thinks of Toyota. That's very dangerous. What's most overlooked though, is big companies wanting to become everything for everybody. Every time they do this, they give into the middle of the curve. What if Subaru said they'd give up AWD just so that they could sell more sedans? That wouldn't be good. If Porsche starts selling more SUVs (they already have) then get even more greedy by trying to sell trucks or vans? That would be the end of Porsche for me, by then, they're not the sports car company.
Research & Development Tax Credits - If anyone is involved in any sort of R&D I have a contact that can submit an application for you to the Government of Canada to get back upto 80% of expenses you may have incurred. Best of all - all this at no cost to you. She's worked with companies of all sizes and part of her services, which are included is how to structure yourself in the future to continue to receive these Government Tax Credits. She can even go back to the last three years in your books to get Tax Credits refunds as well. Email me and I can share her details with you.


Share this article with your friends. Fund someone's dream.

Leave a comment below or share on the left and you'll help support entrepreneurs in Africa through our partnership with Kiva. Over $50,000 raised and counting - Please keep sharing! Learn more.

Newsletter

Get advice & tips from famous business
owners, new articles by entrepreneur
experts, my latest website updates, &
special sneak peaks at what's to come!

Name:
Email:

Popular Articles

10 Steps to Excelling at Franchise Sales

Build Corporate Credit for Your Small Business

Induction – your first management job

Suggestions

Email us your ideas on how to make our
website more valuable! Thank you Sharon
from Toronto Salsa Lessons / Classes for
your suggestions to make the newsletter
look like the website and profile younger
entrepreneurs like Jennifer Lopez.