Tweet

Recent ISM, CAPS and Kearney Report Perpetuates Dangerous Supply Chain Myths

Written by: Jon Hansen

Article Overview: While generally interesting, the recent 10 Page Report by ISM, CAPS and Kearney perpetuate a number of the myths that actually fuel the high rate of e-procurement initiative failures. Focusing on what is referred to as the “seven critical supply strategies” for Succeeding in a Dynamic World, I will address each “strategy” over the next seven day period referencing the results of our 15 years (and counting) of research findings and front line experiences.

Recent ISM, CAPS and Kearney Report Perpetuates Dangerous Supply Chain Myths

While generally interesting, the recent 10 Page Report by ISM, CAPS and Kearney perpetuate a number of the myths that actually fuel the high rate of e-procurement initiative failures.


Focusing on what is referred to as the “seven critical supply strategies” for Succeeding in a Dynamic World, I will address each “strategy” over the next seven day period referencing the results of our 15 years (and counting) of research findings and front line experiences.

Please keep in mind that this undertaking is not designed to malign or even call into question the capabilities of the parties involved. The main impetus behind the effort is to provide you with information that will hopefully motivate you to think outside of the framework with which you are most familiar. The fact is that based on my interaction with procurement professionals across North America through my Changing Face of Procurement conference series, the majority already question the validity of what is supposedly “accepted” or “mainstream” thinking. As we progress in this series you will find out why.


Segment 1 The Myth of Consolidation

Category Strategy Development
Consolidate your supply base for each category into a small number of preferred suppliers that can be efficiently managed while mitigating risk. The strategy for each category should focus on the overall value chain over a three-to-five year time frame.
This strategy is the epitome of the two edged sword. While applicable in certain situations it is the broad application of the consolidation strategy across the entire spend which is a major factor in the high rate of e-procurement initiative failures. In my paper Acres of Diamonds I highlighted the results of 14 years research which identified that all commodities fall into one of two categories, Historic Flat Line and Dynamic Flux. Based on the study’s findings the strategy with one will not work with the other. (Let me know if you would like a copy of the Acres paper by return e-mail.)

Unfortunately, virtually all existing applications are structured around the procurement of Historic Flat Line commodities. As a result of the exorbitantly high licensing and maintenance fees clients pay for implementing these applications, when savings (both Cost of Goods and Cycle Time Reduction) dry up organizations employ what I refer to as a “pull through” strategy in an attempt to satiate the voracious savings appetite of a costly underachieving initiative. Specifically, they attempt to justify the application investment by utilizing a consolidation strategy for purchases which are not suited to this approach. The result is an over-reliance on a change management and compliance strategy that consumes valuable cycles in an effort to legislate or enforce a program which should not have been introduced in the first place.


Kearney’s failed efforts to implement such a strategy with the Federal Government of Canada are just one of countless examples where this approach alienated stakeholders both within and external to the client, with the most vociferous resistance coming from the supplier community. In fact for those of you in the public sector (although I am certain that private sector professionals will also be interested), you may want to refer to a US report which came to the following conclusion (and I quote):

“The number and size of bundled contracts within the executive branch have reached record levels. Although contract bundling can serve a useful purpose, the effect of this increase in contract bundling over the past ten years cannot be underestimated. Not only are substantially fewer small businesses receiving federal contracts, but the federal government is suffering from a reduced supplier base. American small businesses bring innovation, creativity, competition and lower costs to the federal table. When these businesses are excluded from federal opportunities through contract bundling, our agencies, small businesses and the taxpayers lose.”

Note that while the report recognizes the fact that contract bundling or consolidation can (and I believe this) does serve a useful purpose, the problems arise when there is an attempt to force feed the strategy against the better judgment of key stakeholders (especially those for whom the initiative is supposedly designed to assist). (Let me know if you would also like a copy of the US Report.) And while I recognize the conceptual value of organizations such as CAPS, or an Aberdeen and Gartner the fact that they have ties to vendors through a variety of non-arms length relationships (either as a collaborative study partner or client) is the main reason that the validity of their study findings are subject to an increasing level of cynicism from key stakeholders such as frontline buyers. When 75 to 85% (some would suggest that this number is even higher) of all e-procurement initiatives fail to achieve the expected results, one cannot help but wonder why the CAPS’ and Kearney’s of the world continue to cling to a broadly applied consolidation strategy. Next Installment: Supplier Development and Management

Related Articles
  What IT Systems Are Critical for a Retail Supply Chain?
  What is the quickest way to get up to speed on supply chain management?
  Are Multiple Supply Chains Important (Survey Response 1)
  Are Multiple Supply Chains Important Survey Response 2
  Is having a website a requirement in the RFQ RFP process today

Article Tags: acres of diamonds, changing face, commodities, critical supply, dynamic world, e mail, e procurement, edged sword, epitome, impetus, ism, line experiences, preferred suppliers, procurement conference, procurement professionals, research findings, strategy development, supply strategies, validity, value chain



Related Forum Posts
Seek Venture Capital & Funding - Hello, Greetings from India. I am Seeking Venture Capital for Offshore Software Company Start-up. Need advise along with Business Model Sample. I have a basic outline for an offshore company. 1. Technology - like Microsoft Dot Net, Java, LAMP 2. Talent Team - Found Good Technology Developers. 3. Where I can get the leads/potential customers - Leads have been identified who are willing to move forward offshore projects. 4. I do not have resources like funding. It is a very critical factor to me Industries: Manufacturing, Real Estate, Retail, Insurance, Distribution & Logistics, Healthcare, Industry Associations and Software Product Development, Agricultural Industries and Etc. Services: Offshore Software Development Company. Offices to be located: Hyderabad, Andhra Pradesh, India and USA. Products/Services/Applications in areas like POS & Billing, Sales & Distribution, Production Planning, Material Management, Inventory Control, Plant Maintenance, Purchasing, Accounting and Logistics. Dynamic Web Programming with Database Driven Content Management Systems, Online Stores for E-Commerce, B2B Solutions, Community Portals, Website Redesign and Development, Custom ERP with Enterprise Wide Functional Modules such as Marketing, CRM, Accounting, Inventory Control, Sales & Distribution, Production Planning, Purchase & Stores, Logistics and Supply Chain. Seek your further questions and help. Thank you, Best Regards, Jayapratap.
Re: Global Moderators - Hi GT, In my case, I only have the Report Post and the Quote buttons.
Re: Kevin needs "social glue" ideas - [quote="ideasuniversity":2w934785]Kevin, Thanks for this post. But please don't take the 10 Recents posts where it is. This is my first point of call when I entered the forum[/quote:2w934785] Hi ideasuniversity, What if we didn't get rid of the "10 Recent Posts", but simply made you click on a link to view it? Or would this be very inconvenient? By listing 10 niche forum topics (with "10 Recent Posts" being one of them), it would allow for more room for social glue ideas and also make navigation through the site easier as well.
Re: New Window/Tab May Inhibit Posters? - Hi Zac - thanks for the suggestion. Are you referring to the Recent Forum Posts section?
Re: How Much Is Your Website Worth? - I guess it is for the website as the section which gives the value is called "Site Value Report". What do you think dnscoop is missing when it values your site?


Share this article with your friends. Fund someone's dream.

Leave a comment below or share on the left and you'll help support entrepreneurs in Africa through our partnership with Kiva. Over $50,000 raised and counting - Please keep sharing! Learn more.

Tweet

Newsletter

Get advice & tips from famous business
owners, new articles by entrepreneur
experts, my latest website updates, &
special sneak peaks at what's to come!

Name:
Email:

Popular Articles

Quick Tips on Buying a Business

How To Be Happy at Work? Acknowledge Yourself

Your Local Small Business Online Marketing Funnel

Suggestions

Email us your ideas on how to make our
website more valuable! Thank you Sharon
from Toronto Salsa Lessons / Classes for
your suggestions to make the newsletter
look like the website and profile younger
entrepreneurs like Jennifer Lopez.