Tweet

Similarity Hueristics, Iterative Methodologies and the Emergence of the Modern Supply Chain

Written by: Jon Hansen

Article Overview: Some professions, such as software developers, regularly utilize the similarity heuristic. For software developers, the similarity heuristic is utilized when performing debugging tasks. A software bug exhibits a set of symptoms indicating the existence of a problem. In general, similar symptoms are caused by similar types of programming errors. By comparing these symptoms with those of previously corrected software flaws, a developer is able to determine the most probable cause and take an effective course of action. Over time, a developer’s past experiences will allow their use of the similarity heuristic to be highly effective, quickly choosing the debugging approach that will likely reveal the problem’s source. Definition from Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Similarity Hueristics, Iterative Methodologies and the Emergence of the Modern Supply Chain

Some professions, such as software developers, regularly utilize the similarity heuristic. For software developers, the similarity heuristic is utilized when performing debugging tasks. A software bug exhibits a set of symptoms indicating the existence of a problem. In general, similar symptoms are caused by similar types of programming errors. By comparing these symptoms with those of previously corrected software flaws, a developer is able to determine the most probable cause and take an effective course of action. Over time, a developer’s past experiences will allow their use of the similarity heuristic to be highly effective, quickly choosing the debugging approach that will likely reveal the problem’s source.

Definition from Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia



In the somewhat hermetically sealed world of programming, the simularity hueristic model as it is described above makes a great deal of sense as one is usually dealing with what are commonly referred to as single stream, “static elements or attributes.” However, the operational attributes of the real-world are vastly different in that they are dynamic in nature, consisting of multiple transactional streams. Therefore when you take this same historic baseline reference approach, and confine the understanding of the problem to a single transactional stream (in this case historic attributes) you end up with a somewhat myopic view of the process. This of course is indicative of the equation-based models that are employed by the majority of ERP software vendors, and is one of the main reasons why the resulting applications have been largely ineffective.

The key differentiator with the methodology as it is outlined, and those that are emerging is the recognition that while past experience can be one of many important indicators of future performance, a single stream point of reference can quickly become irrelevant especially when it lacks an adaptive capacity through which real-world variables are identified, captured and applied to produce a sustainable reference model.

Like the similarity heuristic method, other approaches are also limited by the same capture once – use many, sequential thought process. The iterative or successive approximation methodology for example, estimates the value for an unknown quantity by repeatedly comparing it to a sequence of known quantities (note the word sequence). Once again, and at least on the surface, this approach also seems reasonable. But as is the case with the simularity heuristic method, the same problems occur when the known quantities or declarative values are not dynamically monitored and updated to reflect real-world circumstances. Nor broad enough that they include all of the multiple attribute streams that influence a collective outcome. This means that the reliability of a declarative value of a “known” quantity diminishes over time as it becomes either too narrow in scope or completely ineffective as the assumptive elements or sequence become outdated. My research has shown that the rate of “reliability” degenration is further accelerated in those instances in which the known elements are not properly understood due to a lack of collaboration at the formulation stage.

Applying the above principles to a supply chain practice, demonstrates that the iterative model is reflective of a sequential architecture or thought process in that it predominantly relies upon attributes that have been previously defined in the static “chain” such as purchasing (including indigenous sub-attributes like price, historic quality and delivery performance, etc), tracking and order fulfillment, as well as financial reconciliation (internal, multiple streams). While the attribute tags themselves can remain constant, their assigned weighted value (re level of importance) including those of the corresponding sub-attributes can and do change dynamical at the transactional level. Depending on the weighted importance that is given to each attribute and sub-attribute, combined with the impact of external attribute streams (which are often subject to unanticipated or previously unexpected changes), means that the collective effect will likely and dramatically alter the “known values” upon which the model was originally built. This means that neither the attributes (upon which the comparative approximations are based) including external variables are static in nature, thus making a reliable comparative model somewhat unreliable has time progresses. Therefore the traditional application of the iterative methodology in which either a declarative or imperative programming method is used to define a single attribute stream of practice is largely ineffective relative to quantifying and managing the supply chain process.

The utilization of equation-based methodologies in which an attempt is made to establish a reference baseline that in reality is not static in nature, but is instead in a state of constant evolution, has contributed to the 85% rate of initiative failure.

In fact, by attempting to establish a single stream, non-adaptive reference baseline, organizations are forced to institute a change management strategy in an effort to align the operational realities of their business with a model that is not reflective of how they or their transactional partners actually function in the real world.

We need to Build Camcorders, Not Improve Canvases

In a paper I wrote in early 2005, I made reference to the fact that software developers needed to build camcorders versus improving canvases. It was an interesting paper to write on many levels as the concepts of agent-based versus equation-based modeling was not widely known in the general market.

The interest in their significant differences was even less at that time as the rate of initiative failures had just started to enter public consciousness.

And while the analogy may be somewhat “dated” so to speak, its message has taken on even greater meaning with the emergence of Web 2.0 (through to Web 4.0) as well as new business models such as Software as a Service (SaaS) and even Free and Open Source Software (FOSS).

Here is the excerpt from that paper. (Please note that I have removed the name of the original vendor and have replaced it with the ABC Company moniker.)

Traditional solutions such as those developed by ABC Company are built around what is referred to as an equation-based model. Equation-based models utilize interactive assumptions, and therefore focus primarily on the somewhat static interaction between independent entities. (The key words here are static interactions and assumptions.)

Recall for a moment the example of the artist attempting to paint a portrait of a subject who is in perpetual motion. While the artist may capture for a brief moment a portion of the image on canvas, the reality is that the effort will always be a work in progress. (It is important to note once again, that most e-procurement initiatives take 1, 2 or more years to implement, only to meet customer expectations a mere 25% of the time.)

While you can improve the quality of the paint the artist is using, add more advanced lighting, and even improve brush stroke speed and techniques, the fact remains that the end result is unlikely to change in any significant way. The only way to achieve the desired result is to create an environment where the subject is stationary at all times. To be specific, you have to restrict the subject from moving, from doing what is natural. (Reference change management.)

Now picture if you will, the same “moving” subject being captured on film with a camcorder. Regardless of the time of day or changing locations, the subject is always captured in real time. In essence, you are now able to adapt and even interact with the subject’s environment. Unlike a painting, when you finish one shot, you can quickly and easily move onto the next, without losing what you have already captured. When required, you have the ability to playback the previous images within seconds.

In this example, you are not asking the subject to change the way he or she operates. Nor are you trying to restrict his or her natural movements. This is at the heart of agent-based modeling. It is the reason that traditional equation-based applications such as the one offered by ABC Company will never achieve the maximum results in the shortest period of time.

The fact remains that it is imperative to simultaneously engage all parties to a transaction on a real time basis, with an ability to meet an evolving set of demands as required. Intelligent, strategic sourcing and procurement, through to tracking and fulfillment and finally financial reconciliation with a “true cost” auditing capability is the earmark of a solution which truly leverages the power of the Internet. To effectively develop this type of solution, one needs to abandon equation-based modeling which is driven by the aforementioned interactive assumptions, and replace it with agent-based modeling which is driven by the ability to understand the unique operating attributes of all trading partners on a continuous real-time basis. This leads to a synchronization of independent capabilities, which in turn creates an environment of adaptive responsiveness, producing immediate results in the area of supply chain efficiencies.

This paper, which interestingly enough experiences periods of renaissance as a result of a growing international readership, indicates that the problem-solving methodologies that are commonly employed by most organizations is represented by the artist attempting to paint a still life subject (attribute).

In reality however, the “subjects” or attributes in a supply (chain) practice are in a state of constant motion and change. This means that the artist, no matter how skilled or advanced is always limited by the tools (or methodologies) he or she is using.

To effectively capture the dynamic elements within this kind of environment, a different methodology such as strand commonality (re camcorder) must be employed to ensure that an accurate picture is captured on an ongoing basis, thereby bridging or synchronizing the chasms between multiple transactional streams.

While this example is an illustrative, 10,000 foot level introduction to the differences between the traditional methodologies that are still in use, and those that are now emerging, it will hopefully create a starting point of reference that will widen the lens through which supply chain practice is understood and ultimately improved.

Related Articles
  What is the quickest way to get up to speed on supply chain management?
  IT Technologies: Extinction in 5 to 10 Years?
  What can be the "next big thing" in supply chain management?
  Number of SKUs and Business Complexity
  How does the complexity theory apply to business? (A Brief Dialogue)

Article Tags: adaptive capacity, differentiator, erp software vendors, heuristic, myopic view, operational attributes, point of reference, probable cause, professions, programming errors, real world, similarity, software bug, software developers, software flaws, source definition, static elements, stream point, wikipedia, wikipedia the free encyclopedia



Related Forum Posts
Seek Venture Capital & Funding - Hello, Greetings from India. I am Seeking Venture Capital for Offshore Software Company Start-up. Need advise along with Business Model Sample. I have a basic outline for an offshore company. 1. Technology - like Microsoft Dot Net, Java, LAMP 2. Talent Team - Found Good Technology Developers. 3. Where I can get the leads/potential customers - Leads have been identified who are willing to move forward offshore projects. 4. I do not have resources like funding. It is a very critical factor to me Industries: Manufacturing, Real Estate, Retail, Insurance, Distribution & Logistics, Healthcare, Industry Associations and Software Product Development, Agricultural Industries and Etc. Services: Offshore Software Development Company. Offices to be located: Hyderabad, Andhra Pradesh, India and USA. Products/Services/Applications in areas like POS & Billing, Sales & Distribution, Production Planning, Material Management, Inventory Control, Plant Maintenance, Purchasing, Accounting and Logistics. Dynamic Web Programming with Database Driven Content Management Systems, Online Stores for E-Commerce, B2B Solutions, Community Portals, Website Redesign and Development, Custom ERP with Enterprise Wide Functional Modules such as Marketing, CRM, Accounting, Inventory Control, Sales & Distribution, Production Planning, Purchase & Stores, Logistics and Supply Chain. Seek your further questions and help. Thank you, Best Regards, Jayapratap.
An "Easy Button" - In the US, Staples Office Supply company has a commercial that features an easy button. The idea is that when you have a difficult task, you hit the easy button and the task is easier. Staples is saying that they make it easier. But, my question is, what would you use an "easy button" for?? Chris
Books for Women Entrepreneurs - There's a thread for good books in the Resources folder, but it doesn't target books for businesswomen particularly, so I figured I'd start such a thread here. It doesn't matter how successful you are in your business - it's always possible to learn something new. In subsequent posts I give Table of Contents and brief descriptions for various titles - most of them devoted to the businesswoman - and sometimes a review. If anyone else has read a review, or has read the book and found it useful, please comment! 1. The Old Girl's Network 2. Mother's Work 3. The 7 Greatest Truths About Successful Women 4. Pitch Like A Girl 5. Workplace Warrior 6. Treasure Hunt: Inside the Mind of the Modern Consumer 7. Contingency Planning & Disaster Recovery 8. She Wins, You Win 9. Napoleon On Project Management 10. Why Good Girls Dont' Get Ahead, But Gutsy Girls Do 11. Comeback Moms: How to Leave Work, Raise Children, and Restart your Career even If you Haven't Had a Job in Years 12. The One Minute Millionaire 13. Talking From 9 to 5 14. Soloing: Realizing Your Life's Ambitions 15. 101 Best Home Based Businesses for Women: Everything You Need to Know About Getting Started on the Road To Success 16. Work With Passion: How to Do What You Love for a Living. Revised and Expanded 17. Fail-Proof Your Business: Beat the Odds and be Successful 18. Confidence: How Winning Streaks and Losing Streaks Begin and End 19. Women Don't Ask: Negotiation and the Gender Divide 20. Millionaire Women Next Door: The Many Journeys of Successful American Businesswomen 21. Start Small, Finish Big: Fifteen Key Lessons to Start - and Run - Your Own Successful Business 22. Rewired, Rehired or Retired: A Global Guide for the Experienced Worker 23. The Martha Rules: 10 essentials for achieving success as you start, build or manage a business 24. The Essentials of Entrepreneurship: What it takes to create Successful Enterprises 25. Net Ready: Strategies for Success in the E-conomy 26. The Promotable Woman 27. Leave The Office Earlier: The Productivity Pro shows you how to do more in less time and feel great about it 28. The Work At Home Balancing Act: The professional resource guide for managing yourself, your work, and your family at home 29. Secrets of Six-Figure Women
Different Types of Funding - Finance for business can be obtained through a number of different sources. Let's review some of those channels to help you decide what's right for your business needs: Grants There are over 930 different EU and UK grants and loans available from over 100 issuing bodies. This is the cheapest form of finance and an important part of the funding package that companies and individuals need. We can help you find your way through this maze. Technology Micro Projects: 50% of eligible costs up to £20,000 Research project: For a technical and feasibility study of an innovative idea for new technology 60% of costs up to a grant of £75,000. Development project: For development up to pre production 35% of costs up to a grant of £200,000 Developing an innovative idea: valuable for small companies and individuals at the start of a technical project: 75% of costs of hiring a mentor and consultants. Export To start exporting or moving into new markets grants of 50% of costs up to £20,000 each. Training and Education Knowledge Transfer Partnerships, Achieving Best Practice in Your Business, Investors in People Modern Apprenticeships New Deal for various grants. Environment BOC Foundation for the Environment: 25% to 50% of Project cost, typically £20,000 to £100,000 Clean up Fund: Emission reducing equipment up to 75% of cost Community Chest Fund: Up to £25,000 for projects near active SITA sites High Impact Fund: £150,000+ for larger projects near SITA sites Assisted Areas Regional assistance grants of between 10 and 35% for capital expenditure in less favoured areas of the UK. Loans Loans are an excellent source of finance if you have suitable security to borrow against or a reliable earnings stream. This needs to be planned and presented well to obtain funds. Credit cards Provides up to 56 days free credit if you play the game! Overdraft Banks are surprisingly supportive when presented with a well thought through plan and competent management. Bank Loans Lenders tend to look for a good business plan and security. Typically the loan is approved by a centralised back office function rather than the person you meet. Terms and rates depend upon the risk. Repayments can be very flexible to meet your specific needs. Mortgages These can include flexible repayment terms to meet your business needs. This can even be incorporated into your overdraft finance so that you have one flexible account for both personal/ business mortgages and overdraft Small Firms Loan Guarantee Scheme Up to two years trading: Up to £100,000 Over two years trading: Up to £250,000 However these are difficult to obtain and are a loan of last resort. Export Guarantee Scheme This is government backed insurance against appropriate export documentation. Mezzanine This is a halfway house between loan and equity. It can be an innovative way of raising funds for the more established business. Mostly for expansion capital. Equity This is not as easy as the papers would have you know. Only 1% of business plans received by Venture Capital Funds are successful. However, a good business proposition consisting of a strong demand for the product or service, management track record and a sound financial plan will enhance the chance of success. Business Angels These are high net worth individuals who are successful businessmen looking for investment opportunities. They can provide both time expertise and money. Typical investment size is £25,000 to £250,000 but can go as high as £2m for the right opportunity. Exit within 3-5 years. Venture Capital These are investment funds seeking high rates of return. However typically investments are over a million pounds. Some funds are targeted at lower amounts depending upon the sector and region. These funds are looking for exponential capital growth over 3-5 years. Asset backed finance This can cover machinery, sales invoices even sales orders. It can be a very flexible source of finance to the growing business Leasing This will cover your capital expenditure and spread the cost over a three to five year period. It is particularly useful if you do not have taxable profits to maximise your capital allowances. Sale and leaseback of a property you own is another good source of funds. Factoring Factoring offers a sales ledger administration and debt collection service. Up to 95% of an approved sales invoice is paid within 48 hours, quicker if required. Credit protection is also available to protect against a bad debt. The Factor will own and place a first charge over the book debts and they might also take other charges, depending upon the strength of the financial information. Invoice discounting Invoice Discounting can be Confidential or Disclosed; it depends upon the strength of the financial information. The service is the same as Factoring, except that the sales ledger administration and the debt collection is the responsibility of the client and not the Factor. Pre payment of the approved sales invoice is still up to 95% and the factor will still have a first charge on the book debt and therefore own the debt. This service can also have credit protection cover. All sales invoices need to be for a business to business debt, and some proof of delivery is generally required. Trade Finance This is funding provided against stock purchases, signed contracts and orders whereby the funder will prepay a certain percentage of the value Pension fund It may be possible to use your pension funds for a loan back to the business What do u think about it?


Share this article with your friends. Fund someone's dream.

Leave a comment below or share on the left and you'll help support entrepreneurs in Africa through our partnership with Kiva. Over $50,000 raised and counting - Please keep sharing! Learn more.

Tweet

Newsletter

Get advice & tips from famous business
owners, new articles by entrepreneur
experts, my latest website updates, &
special sneak peaks at what's to come!

Name:
Email:

Popular Articles

Stress: What Causes It and How To Deal With It

Leader's Success Secret: Celebration

Ten Twitter Tips For Work-at-Home Moms

Suggestions

Email us your ideas on how to make our
website more valuable! Thank you Sharon
from Toronto Salsa Lessons / Classes for
your suggestions to make the newsletter
look like the website and profile younger
entrepreneurs like Jennifer Lopez.