Tweet

The Greening of Procurement Revisited

Written by: Jon Hansen

Article Overview: “In our rapidly evolving capitalist economies, where it is in the natural order of things for corporations to devour competing corporations, for industries to carve up and digest other industries, one emerging form of capitalism with a fork – sustainable capitalism – would certainly constitute real progress.” From Cannibals With Forks – The Triple Bottom Line of 21st Century Business, By John Elkington (Capstone Publishing, Oxford, 1997) Do Cannibals With Forks Constitute Progress? So started the introduction to one of my most popular white papers titled, The Greening of Procurement: How Social Consciousness is Re-Shaping Procurement Practices.

The Greening of Procurement Revisited

“In our rapidly evolving capitalist economies, where it is in the natural order of things for corporations to devour competing corporations, for industries to carve up and digest other industries, one emerging form of capitalism with a fork – sustainable capitalism – would certainly constitute real progress.”

From Cannibals With Forks – The Triple Bottom Line of 21st Century Business, By John Elkington (Capstone Publishing, Oxford, 1997)

Do Cannibals With Forks Constitute Progress?

So started the introduction to one of my most popular white papers titled, The Greening of Procurement: How Social Consciousness is Re-Shaping Procurement Practices.

When I first wrote about green or sustainable procurement (the latter extends beyond the realms of eco-friendly considerations to include socio-economic factors) last summer, I had no idea of how voracious an appetite the business community had for information on this subject.

However much the interest in my papers and research material was unexpected, the contentious and at time contradictory opinions expressed by different stakeholders on both sides of the issue ensures that it is a matter that will remain on our collective radar screens for many, many years to come. Even if the progress of these ideals do not gain the same level of traction (at least in the foreseaable future).

With that said, and as part of our 1st year anniversary series, I am pleased to once again share with you the 2-Part Greening of Procurement posts.

Starting with Part 1 today, Part 2 of the series (It’s not easy being Green!) will appear later in the week.



The Greening of Procurement (Part 1) – Reprinted from July 20, 2007



In my extensive travels to exotic locales (alright Calgary may not be exotic but it is certainly a great place to visit), purchasing professionals who have attended one of my conferences have rarely if ever broached the subject of environmentally friendly (re green) procurement practice.

Burdened by the more pressing challenges associated with unnecessarily complex initiatives that are behind schedule and over budget, one can certainly understand the reasons for the paucity of inquiries.

However based on the recent spate of newly released studies and reports coupled with the announcement of upcoming conferences (one of which is the November 2007 Green Purchasing Summit referenced at the conclusion of this post as well as under the PI Blog Roll), I was interested in trying to understand the root causes of the discrepancy between expressed interest (or lack thereof) and the increasing market activity.

The EcoMarkets 2007 Survey

At the beginning of May I received an advanced copy of the 2nd annual EcoMarkets Survey. A collaborative effort between the North American Commission for Environmental Cooperation, the Center for a New American Dream and TerraChoice Environmental Marketing (who spearheaded the program) this ongoing research initiative monitors patterns of green procurement practice within the B2B and B2G communities. (If you would like a copy of the complete survey contact the author.)

The survey’s results were based upon 692 respondents from a total invitation pool of 10,500 procurement professionals. The conclusions are therefore drawn from a 6.6% sample response rate. The respondents’ organizations account for more than $5 billion in combined annual spend.

Clear Answers

Unlike a lengthy dissertation where the desired answers can be somewhat obscured by superfluous (and sometime meandering) statistics, the EcoMarkets 2007 Survey wasted little time in providing meaningful insights. This was no small feat given the fact that the subject matter is simultaneously contradictory in that while green procurement is widely recognized as being important (91% of respondents indicated that they consider green factors at least occasionally) its importance in terms of practical adoption is relatively low.

From a purely statistical perspective, the survey reached the following conclusions (and I quote):

“It is clear that while environmental factors are being increasingly incorporated into purchasing considerations, the translation of policy to practice is mixed and incomplete.”

“The three most important factors that influence purchases are product performance, durability and price. Environment is a lower priority.”

“A strong majority of respondents (60%) report that they will not pay a price premium for environmentally preferred products.”
The question this raises is quite simply what set of circumstances will elevate green procurement from a nice to do “boutique” status to a more meaningful (and essential) element of a sound purchasing strategy? At the risk of answering my own question, I do not think that green procurement in and of itself will achieve this status, nor do I believe that it is a reasonable goal. At least not in today’s dramatically evolving procurement practice climate.

Factors such as the ever expanding talent vacuum combined with the continuing high rate of e-procurement initiative failures will likely dampen organizational enthusiasm for going green.

Governmental influence – the fuel for change?

Another interesting statistic provided by the survey indicated that the majority of government departments or agencies in Canada and the United States have instituted a green purchasing policy. Based on these findings, the report concluded that this is a clear indication that “governments are making the effort to lead by example,” and are less driven by “financial constraints or profit-making.” While it has generally been accepted that government procurement practices are measured by a different set of criteria from the ones employed by their counterparts in the private sector*, in the context of green procurement it is still a notable observation.

* (Note: as chair of the 2006 Summit Roundtable on Federal Government Procurement Practices, I prepared a comprehensive report highlighting the key elements of a successful purchasing program. This of course was based on feedback from a diverse group of participants. One of the points for which a general consensus was reached dealt with the very issue of purchasing guidelines in the public sector. And I quote, “it is also generally agreed that government is not a corporation and therefore has different priorities and imperatives to meet when procuring goods and services. This acknowledgement takes into account socio-economic implications including the importance of developing key Canadian business sectors or industries. Examples of key sectors or industries include the SME/minority-owned business community, or Canadian-based manufacturing sectors such as shipbuilding where job creation and community financial stability are taken into consideration.” So it is certainly not a stretch to extend the above statement to include green procurement.)

However, looking beyond the realm of its own procurement practice, governments have historically demonstrated a proclivity for fueling environmentally-inspired change. The Province of Ontario’s energy efficient lighting program of the early 90’s gives testimony to this fact.

Looking for ways to reduce energy consumption, the Province of Ontario offered “significant” subsidies to businesses that made the change from standard compact florescent lighting to energy efficient lighting. With the subsidies covering the majority of the transition/upgrade costs, the rate of conversion skyrocketed as immediate savings were realized with the first electric bill. An unexpected adjunct benefit was also realized through the program as the subsidies also stimulated revenue opportunities for the companies that sold and installed the new fixtures.

Almost 15 years later, the EcoMarkets 2007 survey reflected the continuing enthusiasm for programs like the one offered by the Province of Ontario. The response from survey participants indicated that “energy conservation programs are 3x more common than green electricity purchasing programs.” While I am not familiar with the level or immediacy of the savings associated with the green electricity programs, the success of the energy conservation programs should motivate green marketers to look for parallels between the two initiatives.

This is especially important given Ontario’s recent decision to suspend the Provincial Sales Tax (which is 8%) when an energy efficient appliance such as a fridge or stove is purchased. While this program has obviously garnered a universally positive response, to what degree it actually influences consumer buying habits remains to be seen. That said green marketers should pay close attention especially given the fact that the savings impact is immediate.

The survey’s assessment that “being green won’t be enough to win customers” rings true. Both direct and indirect savings must be clearly demonstrated and easily understood by the purchaser.

To purchase a copy of the white paper The Greening of Procurement: How Social Consciousness is Re-Shaping Procurement Practices ($20.00), contact the author.

Related Articles
  How do you create corporate values?
  The Greening of Procurement Revisited (Part 2)
  The Socially Responsible Procurement Practice: Moving Beyond Social Consciousness (enterprising non-profits Profile)
  How does policy either motivate or undermine employee performance?
  Negotiation- fundamentals!

Article Tags: anniversary series, appetite, business community, calgary, cannibals, capitalism, capitalist economies, capstone publishing, century business, economic factors, green procurement, john elkington, procurement practice, procurement practices, radar screens, research material, social consciousness, stakeholders, traction, triple bottom line



Related Forum Posts
A Simple Test - I have no franchise, I've got to say this upfront, but, using the 'The E-Myth Revisited' principle as well as a self-taught measure I used for myself and have taught others since. Is it capable of working just as well, if not better if you are not there? If this isn't possible, what tweaks need to happen to make this so? That, I believe, is what might make it franchisable (as well as all the technical stuff that's been said before).
Startup Pitches - Although I am a newbie to this site, I am not new to owning a business. I have read some great comments on this post. Specifically Michele52, Andrew and Connie. My advice comes from a different background, one heavily relying on design and marketing. Once all of the business research has been completed, keep in mind that people buy DESIGN. Sometimes they don't even understand that is what they are buying, but they are. Take two products that are exactly the same. Put one in pleasingly designed packaging and watch how people will purchase it over the other. I am a graphic designer and partner in a design agency. We have also guided one of our clients through most every stage of their start-up business from securing business vendors to all of their direct mail marketing, website, event booth, uniforms, packaging, logo and corporate identity, you name it and we have probably provided it to them. It has helped us gain invaluable experience to be able to pass onto others. If you have specific questions for me, please do not hesitate to ask. Giving back is something that I truly enjoy. Also, read the eMyth Revisited. The best book I have found that really explains indepthly what to expect when starting a business and the roles you must be willing to play in order to make it successful. Good Luck!
Manufacture of POTATO Flour / POTATO Powder - Manufacture of POTATO Flour / POTATO Powder About Project Setting up of a unit for manufacture of potato powder About Product and its use: Potato powder is increasingly being used in a variety of food preparations like snack foods (Mc Donald, Pringle, Haldiram namkeens etc.), soups, curries and other dishes as a thickening agent. Its use at present is mainly in hotels, restaurants, but acceptance in household is growing due to its inclusion in items like ready to cook soups, dals, curries, etc. Market Potential: The potato powder is supplied in bulk to the manufacturers of the various snack food items and restaurants/ hotels. The major demand is in cities like Mumbai, Delhi , Chennai, Nagpur , etc. The demand is much more than the supply at present and is likely to grow with the increasing popularity of the snack foods and other items where potato powder is used as input. There is good potential for its export also. Production process and technology: Procurement of potato -> Washing -> Cooking -> Pulping -> Drum drying -> Potato Powder -> Packaging -> Marketing The plant and machinery can be used for producing other products like fruit powder, tomato powder, etc. Key risk factors: Availability of adequate quantity of suitable chip varieties, which are used for powder making (like Kufri Jyoti, Kufri Chipsona) is the major factor which could affect the project. Availability of alternatives to potato powder for thickening like tapioca, corn starch etc., could affect the market of potato powder adversely. However at present there is no problem Quality control and Statutory Requirements The unit need to obtain a licence under FPO 1955 from the Ministry of Food Processing Industry Clearance from State Pollution Control Board Capacity of processing raw material (potato): a) Indigenous technology - 32 MT/ day of potato for 90 days per annum. b) Imported technology - 96 MT/ day of potato for 90 days Capacity utilisation is assumed on 90 days basis as the storage facilities for these varieties are not commonly available. However, capacity utilisation can be increased if the existing cold storages are modified suitably with an additional investment of about Rs 2000/ MT. Potato powder recovery: 17% of the raw material. Cost of raw material (potato): Rs 2500 per MT, Sale price of powder: Rs. 55000/ MT. Manpower requirement: a) Indigenous technology: Skilled and trained - 2 Nos; Unskilled - 3 Nos b) Imported technology: Technical - 2 Nos; Skilled - 2 Nos; Semi-skilled - 3 Nos. Power requirement: a) Indigenous technology: 40 HP b) Imported technology: 60 HP Water requirement: a) Indigenous technology: 1,50,000 litres per day. b) Imported technology: 5,00,000 litres per day. Contact Us for FULL Project Report and Project Implementation Consultancy alphabeta24365@yahoo.com
Ladies Who Launch Profile: Heidi Flammang - Heidi Flammang Top Dog, Camp Bow Wow When one of the country's first doggy day cares opened next door to her dad's business, Heidi Flammang and her husband, Bion, would sneak over to hang out with the dogs. They fell in love with the concept—and the dogs—and were soon making trades of services with the owner to have their own dogs stay there. When the owner of that business wasn't interested in franchising, Heidi and her husband started brainstorming and the business plan for Camp Bow Wow was born. They were searching for their first location when Bion was killed in a plane crash, in 1994. Heidi received a $1 million insurance settlement after his death, and in the following years attempted a number of ventures, including a financial consulting business to help others handle sudden wealth. But Camp Bow Wow was never far from her mind. In 2000, with the help and encouragement of her brother, she dusted off that old business plan and set out to bring her and Bion's dream to life. Within weeks she had found her first location, and from that point on she never looked back. Camp Bow Wow has now sold more than 205 franchises, 125 of which will be open by the end of the year. It is the premier upscale doggy day care and boarding company, and is expected to generate $18 million in systemwide sales in 2008. What we learned from Heidi: To persevere and never lose sight of your dreams. Heidi was a young widow who tried financial consulting, pharmaceutical sales, and launching a high-end baby-bedding catalog before coming full circle to find success with the idea that she'd loved all along. Not Just Fun and Games "A lot of people come into this business thinking how fun it's going to be to hang out with dogs all day. But we are taking care of people's furry children, all day and night, 365 days a year! It is an all-consuming business and you have to know so much more than people think—everything from dog behavior to disease management, in addition to the nuts and bolts of running a business. We get franchisees from so many different backgrounds and they all have a love of dogs in common, but we have to teach them to be businesspeople and to market the business and not just focus on the dogs. It's a challenge to find people who want to make it a real moneymaker and not just a labor of love." Getting the Word Out "We receive a lot of leads on possible new franchisees through word of mouth from our existing franchisees and open Camps. Also, we've been featured on AOL's main page, Donny Deutsch's The Big Idea, in Pink magazine, and in some other great media outlets, and we advertise in the airline magazines and do quite a bit on the Internet, utilizing our Web site as a marketing tool. All of these have been great resources." What Worked "What has worked for us is to stay focused on our brand and what it's about: offering a place where a dog can be a dog. We don't let ourselves get distracted by other business opportunities that come in our direction, and we don't try to be everything to every dog owner. I am a perfectionist and have been very specific about what the rules are and what the brand is, and that really led the way for franchising opportunities. But we are constantly evolving based on the learning experiences and opinions of our franchisees, and I think that helps us stay ahead of the competition." And What Didn't "Be wary of getting family and friends involved and assuming that because they have good hearts and are interested in your business that they'll have the skills to do it. It's important to be surrounded by knowledgeable people who have great skills, not just people who love you." Networking Is Not Just For the Dogs "People in the dog-boarding business are very protective, so it's not as easy to network and meet people with like businesses as it might be in other industries. I found great mentors at the International Franchise Association, other people who had been there and done that in terms of franchising. I'm very involved with that group and work to champion other women entrepreneurs. I'm also part of a CEO support group called Vistage. There are 12 of us in the group who meet for a day once a month and it's extremely valuable, but I am the only woman in the group. So I also have an informal group of women who I meet with in Denver to share professional successes and disasters. Women are just so much more open to that type of dialogue." Like Mother, Like Daughter "I'm writing a book about starting and running a successful woman-owned business called Tales From the Bark Side. My tween-aged daughter is writing her own book that will be released at the same time called Tori's Tales, about growing up with a mom who's an entrepreneur. My pet project is working with young girls to help them set goals and develop self-confidence and pride in their accomplishments." Man's Best Friend "Last year we started Bow Wow Buddies, a foundation dedicated to improving the lives and health of dogs around the world. We foster dogs, we sponsor a PhD fellow in canine cancer research at CSU veterinary school, and we fund organizations such as RAVS and VIDAS that go into poor areas in the U.S. and elsewhere to spay and neuter stray dogs. We undertook a rescue mission abroad after our in-house counsel vacationed in Greece, a country with no humane society, and saw how poorly strays were treated there. We brought 17 dogs back with us and fostered them until finding them homes." Favorite Quote "'Worry is a debt you may never have to pay.' I really strive to live in the now, focus on solutions that are in the moment, and not worry too much about things that may never happen." Recommended Reading "My favorite dog book is Marley & Me. But I have two business books that I find invaluable: The E Myth Revisited (a fantastic book to help you figure out whether you have the right personality and skill mix to be an entrepreneur) and The Question Behind the Question (a great management book about instilling personal accountability in your people)." Parting Thoughts ... "I will retire when ... every dog has a home." "My greatest strength in business is ... my flexibility." "My dream is ... to give back as much as I get from my life. I have been so blessed with so many things and I want to respect the universe and give back." This featured lady was profiled by Noelle Pechar Hale, a freelance writer living in Los Angeles.


Share this article with your friends. Fund someone's dream.

Leave a comment below or share on the left and you'll help support entrepreneurs in Africa through our partnership with Kiva. Over $50,000 raised and counting - Please keep sharing! Learn more.

Tweet

Newsletter

Get advice & tips from famous business
owners, new articles by entrepreneur
experts, my latest website updates, &
special sneak peaks at what's to come!

Name:
Email:

Popular Articles

Sales Flubs

How do I finance a franchise?

Suggestions

Email us your ideas on how to make our
website more valuable! Thank you Sharon
from Toronto Salsa Lessons / Classes for
your suggestions to make the newsletter
look like the website and profile younger
entrepreneurs like Jennifer Lopez.