Tweet

School ‘WebcamGate’ woes not yet over

Guest post by: Dennis Schooley

Article Overview: Federal prosecutors may have decided not to press criminal charges against school officials accused of spying on students using a webcam but the Lower Merion School District is not yet off the hook.

School ‘WebcamGate’ woes not yet over

Federal prosecutors may have decided not to press criminal charges against school officials accused of spying on students using a webcam but the Lower Merion School District is not yet off the hook.

Two civil lawsuits are still pending against the suburban Philadelphia school district. A federal class action lawsuit filed in February by high school sophomore Blake Robbins and his parents Michael and Holly. The suit alleges that the Lower Merion School District secretly spied on its 2,300 students while in the privacy of their homes. A total of 56,000 images were captured using the iSight webcams on the school-issued MacBook laptops.

In July, Jalil Hasan, who graduated from the school this year, and his mother filed a second lawsuit against the school district. The two accused the Lower Merion of taking over 1,000 images of Jalil and his family.

The teen accidentally left his laptop inside the school premises on a Friday and it was returned to him the following Monday. The incident, which happened last December, triggered the start of LANRev (a PC anti-theft software installed on the computers) taking webcam photos and screenshots of Hasan's laptop, according to the teen's mother, Fatima. The tracking mechanism remained activated for months until the Robbins filed a lawsuit against the district.

The school's officials insisted the remote tracking system was for laptop theft recovery but parents and bloggers described it as "disturbing" and a violation of privacy.

The school's unusual PC monitoring system came to light after school officials called the attention of Blake over alleged improper conduct in his room. The Lower Merion School District's assistant principal accused the 15-year-old high school sophomore of selling and taking drugs. The allegation was purely based on the images captured using LANRev. The teenager, however, claimed the pill-like objects shown in the images were just candies.

The school's officials said they blocked the MacBooks' camera activation feature after the Robbins filed the lawsuit.

According to reports, the images included those of students relaxing at home, sleeping, and even partially dressed. The software also tracked every website the students visited as well as captured all their online chat sessions.

No criminal intent

Six months after the Federal Bureau of Investigation launched a probe into the allegations, federal prosecutors announced that no charges would be filed against the school due to lack of evidence of criminal intent.

The Lower Merion School District welcomed this development, saying it validated the findings of the school's internal investigation.

The school district has adopted new laptop monitoring policies following the spying brouhaha. The new policy stipulates that school officials need explicit written permission from students and parents before they could access school-issued laptops.

When a laptop gets stolen, a police report of the incident is required before the theft tracking device in the PC could be activated. The theft tracking software, however, is banned from capturing screenshots and images of on-screen texts, as well as taking video or audio recordings.

Some web users who were closely monitoring the case expressed displeasure over the FBI announcement. It showed that the U.S. had a weak policy regarding privacy protection, they said, and that the incident may set the stage for other schools to develop ways to pry into the students' private lives.

Computer theft

According to the 8th Annual 2010 BSI Computer Theft Survey, about 5.5 million computers were stolen in the U.S. in the last 3 years. The recovery rate was put at a dismal 3 percent for computers that were not equipped with a theft tracking mechanism.

Laptops were the most commonly stolen, followed by mobile devices, and desktop computers.

The LANRev (now called Absolute Manage) tracking mechanism installed on the MacBooks issued to the students of Lower Merion School District was overseen by network technician Michael Perbix.

In a YouTube video he produced, Perbix admitted that the software was a good tracking feature in cases of laptops getting misplaced or stolen. The feature must be promptly turned off after the device had been returned to its owner, though; otherwise, images considered harmless could also be captured.

"It's an excellent feature. Yes, we have used it, and yes, it has gleaned some results for us. But it, in and of itself, is just a fantastic feature for trying to-especially when you're in a school environment and you have a lot of laptops and you're worried about, you know, laptops getting up and missing. I've actually had some laptops we thought were stolen which actually were still in a classroom, because they were misplaced, and by the time we found out they were back, I had to turn the tracking off. And I had, you know, a good twenty snapshots of the teacher and students using the machines in the classroom," Perbix said.

Related Articles
  Short of a Mack Truck: Keep Your Aches and Pains to Yourself
  Have You ever heard of the Entrepreneurs Business School
  The Effect of the Economic Woes and Wellness in the Workplace
  Promotional products a means to cultivate school spirit
  Surface chats at B-school
  Should Teaching Your Child Involve Longer School Days?
  Firing the Principal Does Not Guarantee Improvement
  Paying Kids to Study (An Early Business Lesson)
  Effects of health on child schooling and cognitive development: The Indirect Effects of Investment in Human Capital
  Unique Way to Create Business Goals - Learning from a Kindergarten Student
  A Grandmother Finds Hope After Devastation
  The Value of a College Education
  Change in Mindset
  Background Checks for School Volunteers -- Necessary or Not?
  Over 65 Exemption Portability
  Smoking and the Representativeness Heuristic
  Serious No No's for Homeschooling Parents - Part Four of Four Part Series
  Become a Student Of Success And Change Everything
  What Basics?
  Day One. All Over Again.

Article Tags: concerns, internet, privacy, security, Webcam



Related Forum Posts
Re: Can someone explain Search engine optimization to me? - Search Engine Optimization (SEO) could be compared to a big popularity contest: A High School Computer Geek and a High School Football Captain who are trying to promote a party. The computer geek tells everyone in school & even hands out 100's of flyers about his party Friday night...what happens? his friends end up showing up and a few new people...even the new people leave right away because it is not what they are looking for. The High School Football Captain ends up just telling a few good buddies, and within hours the entire school not only knows about it, but everyone wants to come, and everyone does come & stay. One defenition of "optimize is "To make as perfect or effective as possibe." How effective are your article marketing campaigns? Could you be distributing content (that is what search engines index) more effectively? In a perfect world, who would you want promoting your website, web pages, and web content? Search Engine Optimization (SEO) is determining this perfect & effective way to do this. Jeff
Re: Moderators on vacation - Hi Everyone, Well I am not taking a vacation, but I wanted to let you know I will be visiting this forum less than I used too in the near future. School year started yesterday, and I don't know how my new schedule will affect my days, right now there is a big chaos, I guess they will solve it in the next 2 weeks.
Funnies - Hi There, Here are some bad headlines: Red Tape Holds Up New Bridge Eye Drops Off Shelf Hospitals Are Sued By 7 Foot Doctors Inclued Your Children When Baking Cookies Safety Experts Say School Bus Passengers Should Be Belted Kindest regards Beat
Re: How many nationalities are on the forum? - Hey, Kev: I call myself Canadian ... but I can't speak French! :-[ My oldest granddaughter just started Play School (I think that's what they call it) and she is enrolled in the French Immersion class. That is great! I think it is valuable to be able to speak more than one language, and I think it also helps to stretch the mind and exercise the brain. GT :-]
Re: English TV Programme - [quote="WendyHearn":2wehgyf6]Although I did want another TV programme last night 'Too Fat To Toddle'. So sad to see overweight young children. Although most of the parents got the message that they need to be stricter. Wendy[/quote:2wehgyf6] Hi Wendy, I enjoyed TV chef Jamie Oliver's show [i:2wehgyf6]Jamie's School Dinners[/i:2wehgyf6] when it was on because he was trying to campaign for healthier school meals to be served in cafeterias.


Share this article with your friends. Fund someone's dream.

Leave a comment below or share on the left and you'll help support entrepreneurs in Africa through our partnership with Kiva. Over $50,000 raised and counting - Please keep sharing! Learn more.

Newsletter

Get advice & tips from famous business
owners, new articles by entrepreneur
experts, my latest website updates, &
special sneak peaks at what's to come!

Name:
Email:

Popular Articles

What Makes an Extraordinary Business Consultant?

Get Your Business on Google Places

Suggestions

Email us your ideas on how to make our
website more valuable! Thank you Sharon
from Toronto Salsa Lessons / Classes for
your suggestions to make the newsletter
look like the website and profile younger
entrepreneurs like Jennifer Lopez.